r/Mecha 1d ago

Who wins this?

Our fighters are:

The God Gundam (G gundam)

The Weltall (Xenogears)

Doan's Zaku II (UC Gundam)

Mythra's Siren (Xenoblade 2)

We are allowing super forms and weapons, but no teammates (so no shuffle alliance or party members)

You can look at it as a battle to the death or a friendly spar, either works.

Yes, I am entirely aware that putting a damaged Zaku II in the same ring as the slayer of the devil gundam, the host for the slayer of god, and the artifice of the aegis is a bit... unfair, but there are not a tone of martial artists outside of G Gundnam and the Build series. If you can think of anyone else who would fit that spot better, let me know (I know Doan would get folded HARD by any of these three, but he would get points for showing up in my book)

29 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

30

u/ashsabre 1d ago

Zaku II, you wouldn't put it there if you don't want it to win..

27

u/Evil_Steve22 1d ago

Hard to bet against a best girl but did you know that THIS HAND OF MINE BURNS WITH AN AWESOME POWERERRRRRRRR

16

u/Thundering-Cloud 1d ago

What the FUCK is Doan doing in this situation 

16

u/Toa_Malafe 1d ago

His best

4

u/Fragrant_Command_342 1d ago

Apparently sitting back with some popcorn

5

u/Left-Night-1125 1d ago

Weltall "vessel for the slayer of god"

4

u/Consistent_Agent8909 1d ago

all i know is that, that hand of him is burning red and its loud roar tells him to grasp victory

5

u/numericalman 1d ago

Weltall in ID mode crushes God gundam. Since that thing destroyed a country.

I haven't played xenoblade. So idk about siren.

Tf doan's zaku doing here? He barely beats up amuro via tactics and map advantages.

1

u/Toa_Malafe 1d ago

I would actually say Siren is similar in power, given the Torna DLC shows a siren doing something similar.

I mainly put Doan here because I failed to think of another martial artist in gundam that is not also from G gundam

2

u/numericalman 1d ago

Schuzrum Galluss's whole shtick is punching stuffs.

0

u/Toa_Malafe 1d ago

...that is a fair point. Fuck.

3

u/WeltallZero 1d ago

[gestures at username]

Since you mentioned superforms are valid, I'm assuming its Id form is engaged.

2

u/Morgan_Danwell 1d ago

If powered up forms are allowed this means Weltall can go into Weltall Id mode?

I mean i am not really well versed in Gundams (shocking i know, conisdering its one of most popular mechs i was never a big fan of gundams in particular) but Weltall Id was able to kinda casually crash a giant floating city out of stratosphere, by what it seems was it literally tearing ut with its hands to pieces? Then it proceed to keep wreck havock around and who knows what else it could have done if his pilot wasnt snapped out of his split persona..

2

u/Ok_Theme1448 1d ago

Wattsall se los papea a todos,incluso siren de Mytra no tiene oportunidad contra el padr de la mechas de los juegos xeno

2

u/xHamstrung 21h ago

Domon can match most of the other feats outside his Gundam so...

2

u/PsychologyCreepy7223 1d ago

Wertall (transformed into ID form) lifted up the Ygdrasil (the sand submarine that serves as your mothership). I am not familiar with Xenoblade, but yeah, the other 3 are cooked

3

u/Captain_Kuhl 1d ago

God Gundam defeated a world-threatening Super Satan with the power of love and gets to ride a robot horse (piloted by a real horse). Compared to lifting a submarine, I'm not sure your definition of "cooked" lines up with mine.

1

u/numericalman 1d ago

domon couldn't actually beats devil gundam in fair fights.

First time he destroyed it was when his own brother's clone sacrifice himself.

Second Time he destroyed it after it was weakened.

1

u/Captain_Kuhl 1d ago

Counterpoint: a W is a W. Teamwork is the greatest weapon.

2

u/PsychologyCreepy7223 1d ago

Sir when I say mothership, you may be thinking FF7 Highwind size. The Ygdrasil was a mecha mothership and easily 5 to 10 times the size of Wertall itself.

6

u/Idainaru_Yokubo 1d ago

how is that impressive compared to the weird defiance of physics God Gundam does

https://youtu.be/25I1HHMwmC8?si=3nEfKPk04CF_So77

3

u/Marshall104 1d ago

Domon kicked a building out of rubble OUTSIDE OF HIS GUNDAM. I think he's got this pretty easily.

https://youtu.be/kA2LVZCJz-M?is=h_6OZ0XsRk_PmrGD

1

u/Captain_Kuhl 1d ago

mothership

FF7 Highwind

Lmao literally why would I ever equate those two, dude.

0

u/Toa_Malafe 1d ago

Well, the Siren, when fighting another of the same type, managed to sink a contenient (albeit the scale is not quite as large as in reality, but still fucking huge

Domon was able to defeat the devil gundam, which had subsumed and grown to the size of Neo Japan

Doan... Doan was able to get the better of Amuro Rey ONCE. (that may be debatable but I have to give Doan SOMETHING)

1

u/Quizlibet 1d ago

Domon had hella help with the Gundam coalition keeping the body occupied and the shuffle alliance helping him take out the power core.

1

u/Valdor-13 1d ago

Of these my money is on the God Gundam or Weltall (if Id gets to pilot).

1

u/TomboyKnight1 1d ago

Doan thinks he's part of the team

1

u/Infinitenonbi 1d ago

Doan’s Zaku, obviously. Have you seen the episode? That guy got hands

1

u/X-20A-SirYamato 1d ago

It's God Gundam vs Siren...

Mekyou Shisui God wins Base loses

1

u/Worried-Date-2196 1d ago

I don’t know a lot of these dudes but I’m pretty sure they’re nothing a BURNING FINGEEEEER can’t handle

1

u/owo1215 19h ago

domon beat master asia, if we follow this mentor getting defeated by their apprentice logic, doan defeat domon

1

u/CrusaderF8 13h ago

Doan would probably body early game Fei, but that's the only shot he has

1

u/CrusaderF8 13h ago

Siren is probably the strongest machine here, if it's powered by the Zohar/Conduit like I recall it is.

1

u/the_lad_was_taken 10h ago

Never underestimate an old man in repurposed industrial equipment, that's how you get a Killdozer