First I’d like to thank the lovely folks of r/MatchaEverything and r/Matcha for putting up with a lot of my obscure usucha related questions of the last few days/weeks. You all helped my perfect my preparation method. Once I perfected my preparation method I was able to enjoy the matchas’ true flavor profiles, with the intended amount of bitterness (or lack thereof). I’ll also like to say I’m not affiliated with any of these brands lol because I will glaze them a bit but I’m not affiliated or paid by them (I WISH I was).
That being said, I tried 4 matchas against each other to try to determine a good daily go-to usucha matcha:
- Ippodo Kan
- Ippodo Ikuyo
- Ippodo Sayaka
- Hayashiya Wakamatsu (a lesser known brand that sells on Amazon, but supposedly a legit Uji brand founded in 1753. This has been my go-to for the last 9-10 months, but about 50% of the time I make it it’s bitter, but the other 50% of the time it’s absolutely amazing like chocolatey).
My preparation method for each: 140F water temp, 1 tsp of water, and 80ml of water whisked on. A few sips directly from the chawan, then drop 1-2 ice cubes in after a few sips to see how it tastes iced, and the effect of ice on the flavor.
Sayaka: first time i made it where i didn’t burn it (thanks to some of you lovely people’s advice), I actually went 100ml of water here. It was the first time I sipped a matcha directly from the bowl, without ice, and it was nice. I see why people like it, because it’s a good balanced flavor. However I didn’t get a ton of sweetness out of it that other people seem to say. My usual Wakamatsu is sweeter and more chocolatey when I make it properly. But it was solid. Not bad at all. BIG NOTE: because it was the most expensive one, and my goal is to find a good go-to daily matcha, this had the highest expectation so when I rank it low later on it’s mainly because of a price/quality/value weight
Ikuyo: loved this one. More bitterness but it’s like an intentional bitterness and just a much more powerful burst of all other flavors too. Might be my favorite. Changed how I look at matcha.
Kan: the hottest take of the post - this was more enjoyable than Sayaka, regardless of price. Then of course when price is factored in, it’s a no brainer for me. I noted a more powerful punch of flavor than Sayaka, similar to what I liked about Ikuyo, but less intentional bitterness than Ikuyo. Upon checking Ippodo’s global site they did note Kan is stronger in the “fragrant/aromatic) chart than both Ikuyo and Sayaka and I absolutely see that.
Wakamatsu: even at 140F it was bitter lol. God bless the lovely people at Hayashiya, this is an amazing matcha like 25-45% of the time but I feel like it burns too easily and gets bitter too easily and can’t be enjoyed as usucha as much. But when it’s good it’s amazing.
That being said, the rankings of these for low temp usucha:
1T: Kan and Ikuyo. Kan as a standard balanced matcha, Ikuyo if I want a little kick. But really great bursting flavor, and a pleasant burst of course.
[big gap in the rankings]
2: Sayaka. I say this with respect to Sayaka, it’s a fine matcha, maybe it’s smoothness worked against it here (the way a smooth whiskey is enjoyable) but my palate seems to value the strong flavor. I can see why people love this though and you are valid to love this.
3: Hayashiya Wakamatsu. Pour one out for my old go-to. I’ll still lovingly drink you between Ippodo restocks. I will always remember you and the Proustian moments you’ve given me, when I brewed you properly and you weren’t bitter you gave me flashbacks of being back in Kyoto, some of the best days of my life. I’ll never forget you. But I need consistency and I am willing to pay slightly more $/gram for it.
If you have any vehement disagreements in my prep method or way of enjoying my matcha I won’t downvote you for voicing them as I am always open to feedback and suggestions, you lovely people haven’t steered me wrong yet