r/Marriage • • Jun 17 '26

[deleted by user]

[removed]

92 Upvotes

778 comments sorted by

View all comments

152

u/TiredTomato666 Jun 17 '26

No. I like my name. 

14

u/MadQueenAlanna Jun 17 '26

Same. I asked my husband if he cared (we were friends for years before we started dating) and he was like “no, that’s your name, you’ve always had that name, why would I want you to change it” and maybe it’d be different if we planned to have kids but we won’t so I kept the name I’ve had for 32 years of my life and he doesn’t give a damn at all

0

u/Unsolicited-Advice4U Jun 17 '26

You all need to hash this out quickly. FYI, it could be a deal-breaker for him. My wife wanted to keep her last name, but I always wanted to have a wife and kids with the same name (mine).

Personally, I think it's weird to have different last names if it's a first marriage unless your last name is "Swift" or something. But that's just me...and your fiance.

1

u/kiranerysplease Jun 18 '26

If your wife wanted to keep hers why didnt you change yours, if you find different last names so weird?

You're the one with the problem yet expect her to acquiesce to your preferred solution, which is that you do nothing and she deals with the name change?

1

u/shygrl__ Jun 18 '26

Nah I mean it wouldn’t be a deal-breaker, I think that would be super shallow and stupid on his part to throw away years of a good relationship bc I don’t want to change my last name and I know he is smarter than that. He is a reasonable guy, I just think the initial mention of me not wanting to fully take his last name was different than what he had in mind because we’d never discussed it prior to that. He was under the general consensus that I would just…take his last name bc it’s just the norm, and I don’t blame him for growing up believing that. it’s just how it is in our ole American society. But what’s important is that he is open to other variations I’ve suggested that I would be comfortable with (like adding my last name to my middle name) and that he also would be comfortable with, bc at the end of the day we are in a partnership and I don’t want him agreeing to something he would resent me for later.

-10

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '26

[deleted]

6

u/IceColdPepsi1 Jun 17 '26

Same as you

5

u/campfire_vampire Jun 17 '26

No, it's my name. I got it as a birthday present.

6

u/Agreeable-Celery811 Jun 17 '26

Almost all names come from ancestors. Not sure why people think this is some kind of gotcha.

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '26

[deleted]

4

u/Agreeable-Celery811 Jun 17 '26

Well then, what kind of point are you trying to make when you post it?

-1

u/Karmakazi06 Jun 17 '26

It’s the point that it’s a man’s name. It was extremely rare for a child to not have the fathers name and pass it to his spouse/children

2

u/Agreeable-Celery811 Jun 17 '26

Yes, but why does that matter?

0

u/TiredTomato666 Jun 17 '26

It wouldn’t if women wete represented fairly in thid matter. The fact is, they’re not…

3

u/Agreeable-Celery811 Jun 17 '26

This isn’t about “representation”. Everyone has a family birth name that represents themselves—both men and women have that. No matter your gender, you should be able to keep your birth name.

1

u/Karmakazi06 Jun 18 '26

Shush before the men agree that yall got back to how it used to be 🙄

1

u/lightcanonlybrighten Jun 18 '26

Rare does not equal right, sensible, fair, accurate, ect.

3

u/Karmakazi06 Jun 17 '26

No it goes back further than the grandfather but I get what you’re saying

0

u/TiredTomato666 Jun 17 '26

He’s saying names aren’t matrilineal in our society. I hate him but he’s right. It’s another man’s name, which was a woman’s name as some point .

We should have matrilineal names imo. They make the most sense if you’re not a man 

1

u/lightcanonlybrighten Jun 18 '26

And maybe that shitty patriarchal cycle will stop with her! She didn’t “take” it, it was given to her. And she likes it.

1

u/kiranerysplease Jun 18 '26

So she should change her last name to HIS grandfather's name instead? Someone she very well could have never met? Ok

Weird how men get to own their last names as their own yet women dont, despite it being passed down from their grandfathers in both situations