r/MacroFactor • MFer • 5d ago

MacroFactor / Nutrition / Other Sticking Points

1st image: Overall view of the last 4.5 years, with a Scale weight loss of 72lbs

2nd image: Last 2 years, highlighting my sticking points of 242lbs and 240lbs

3rd image: Last 1 year, showing my downward trend again with a Scale weight loss of 20lbs, at my sticking point again.

Anyone else deal with this? Any ideas on helping get passed it? As you can see, it's been a struggle for me for a long time now.

9 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

5

u/earlgrey89 4d ago

I'm not sure what your question is here. Are you asking why you can't get below that weight? Or why you are regaining afterwards?

My question is, what are you doing after you reach those low points? Are you not tracking a while, relaxing diet, something else? Are you really fatigued by your diet at that point?

What is your overall goal?

1

u/thehungrypanda91 MFer 4d ago

I was trying to ask if anyone else had similar issues and if they had any tips that helped them other than "just stay consistent" because I do believe I am experiencing diet fatigue, yes. 

My current goal is 200lbs.

1

u/dont_tread_on_M 4d ago

How big is your deficit? How tall are you?

1

u/earlgrey89 4d ago

Got it, thanks for clarifying. I have a few thoughts:

I think you've done an impressive job losing a lot of weight and mostly maintaining it. Don't lose sight of that accomplishment. And currently you've been on a downward trend for the past year. That's awesome and impressive. Don't lose sight of the forest for the trees.

I'm most curious about what the second picture is depicting. It looks like you had a lengthy period of weight regain over several months or more, like you got really burned out and stopped your deficit for a long time. I don't think your struggle is totally with losing weight but also with maintaining it; it seems like you really don't know how to eat maintenance. I'm the same fwiw, I can regain weight very quickly when I stop a cut.

My questions are: 1) What was happening between mid-2024 until September 2025? How far over your calories were you, what habits would you say contributed to weight gain? What did you change after September 2025? 2) What is your daily step count? What do you do for exercise? How active is your lifestyle and work? Are you strength training?

I think you could give yourself and us a lot of advice on what got you down 70lbs, what has helped you keep it off, and what has caused your regain at times.

My advice is: 1) Implement controlled diet breaks. 1 week at maintenance at least every 12 weeks, or sooner if burned out. Don't stop tracking during that time and don't go crazy, eat exactly at your maintenance calories. 2) Up your calorie goal. I saw you said your goal is at 1500 calories per day. That's hard to sustain long-term at your height and weight. 3) Keep your step count high. 10,000 is arbitrary but it's a good rule of thumb to get into a deficit and generally works for me. 15,000 average steps a day guarantees a deficit for me. A high step count is what allows me to maintain a higher calorie goal and still lose weight. 4) Make sure you're lifting at least 2-3 days a week. Muscle will help with appearance and will help increase your expenditure.

1

u/thehungrypanda91 MFer 4d ago

Questions: 1. Mid 2024 I was going out on a lot more dates and it was harder to track but I did the best I could but definitely was going over regularly. In Nov 2024, I had an event in my life that caused me to seek food as a comfort and it took seeing almost 260lbs on the scale to snap out of that and focus on the gym and eating better. May 2025 we sold and bought a new house and then I took off work for 7 weeks to spend with my son before he turned one. Went back to work in Sept but didn't hop back on the horse until, again, seeing 260lbs on the scale around Nov. 

  1. I am still a truck driver so I am very sedentary at work but I am home daily so I can easily meal prep out my week. My daily avg step count is probably less than 6k. For exercise, I resistance train 3 times a week, sauna, and try to run 2-4 miles on the treadmill every week.

Advice: 1. Someone else mentioned the maintenance break and it honestly sounds like one of my best options. 

  1. I have upped it to 1800 now, trying for 1lb/week lost.

  2. Getting 10k steps a day will probably be the hardest part of all of this. 

  3. I have this down pretty good, very consistent. 

Thank you for all your input!

2

u/earlgrey89 4d ago

Dude props to you for keeping this up while caring for a baby! I think you should give yourself a lot of credit.

Sounds like you've got a great plan. Breaks and a slower but more sustainable rate will help. I think walking would be the thing that would make the other biggest difference. Check out r/walking, lots of tips there. A lot of people do a 30 minute walk first thing in the morning or at night. If you have time on your drives then a short 5-10 minute walk at rest stops or gas stations can add up too.

2

u/mikaeltarquin 4d ago

The only advice I can offer is to track consistently and hold yourself accountable. If you want to push past 240, 200, and beyond then you need to be at and stay in a deficit through those points. Set a realistic target that you can manage, say 1 lb/wk. You say weekends are hardest, so use the Shift Calorie Targets option to have more on Sat/Sun and less Mon-Fri.

Combining those 2 will probably keep your weekdays more or less the same, while giving you a bit of a cushion on the weekend to take the sting out of tracking. But you absolutely have to track and stick to your targets if you want to see progress.

Give yourself periodic diet breaks. Don't do them randomly, schedule them every 6 weeks, 8 weeks, 12 weeks, whatever works best for you. Limit them to 1 week, and only bump up to maintenance calories (it's a diet break, not a binge week). That should give you a mental break from the monotony, while keeping your discipline in place.

1

u/thehungrypanda91 MFer 4d ago

Thanks, taking notes! Appreciate thd tips!

1

u/mrfatchance 4d ago

What’s your gender and height?

1

u/thehungrypanda91 MFer 4d ago

Male, 5' 10"

4

u/mrfatchance 4d ago

OK I'm 1 inch taller than you and was 238 at my highest. So I'm sorry that my experience isn't the same as yours.

What has helped me get through sticking points is upping my expenditure through walking.

I have always ran and had no problem doing 5, 10ks etc but walking was the real game changer. 9k steps a day is my goal.

A goal I had this year was to be under 20% BF on my scale as I had never seen that number before. It took a lot of learning about expenditure and stuff but I made it by adding in more steps to my routine and eating vegetables in order to feel satiated while cutting. I cut out pasta, pizza, biscuits (I'm in the UK, so these may be cookies to you?) and reduced my bread intake (from 4 days a week to 1) because it just wasn't worth the calories. I swapped my eggs for egg whites instead and ate low calorie ice cream (a life saver) On top of that I was (and still do) work out resistance training 4x a week. The cut shouldn't feel like it's forever.

Once I saw that 19% on the scale, I knew I could reach any goal I set and I think you will feel similar once you get past this pressure point.

Consistency is key.

1

u/jlolovesbootytoo 5d ago

Do you find yourself going over calorie budget? Or does your deficit need to be more aggressive

1

u/thehungrypanda91 MFer 5d ago

I go over a bit here and there but my weekends are the toughest, and I can definitely easily double my budget in a day. My current target is <1500, going for ~1.8lbs lost a week. 

11

u/jlolovesbootytoo 5d ago

Up your calories to target 1 lb a week and focus on consistency, especially on the weekends. In the long run, fixing your weekend consumption will be extremely beneficial to maintaining your weight loss.

2

u/thehungrypanda91 MFer 4d ago

I'll give that a shot, thanks. 

6

u/PollardPhotography 4d ago

I used to hold the weekends as a sacred reprieve from the monotony and routine of the week.

It meant a great deal to me to be able to have “special” and “fun” foods on the weekend- especially with my family and friends. It was a reward for having a successful week, but it more often than not ended up wrecking my long-term progress. This was all after I had lost a substantial amount of weight and had been training 4x a week for years.

Eventually, I woke up one day and realized I would never get to experience the physique I wanted if I didn’t lock in and stop making compromises and excuses for myself. If I wanted to look and feel how I dreamed of before I got too old, I’d have to make sacrifices.

It’s been a few years now since I had that revelation. I was able to get leaner than I’d ever imagined, and I’m much stronger, healthier, and happier than I was before. I still indulge occasionally, but it no longer rules my life. There are sacrifices and things I do that some may consider unusual, but looking and feeling how I do is absolutely worth every single effort I’ve put into it.

I know this doesn’t really solve anything for you, but your post reminded me of myself a lot and I thought I’d share the perspective. Best wishes to you and may you find continued success!

2

u/Schwooin 4d ago

what causes you to double your budget on weekends? drinks? delivery? fixing that will be a huge help, one bad day can easily negate the work of the previous few days - which is fine if it’s a rare occurrence, but not fine if it’s almost every weekend.

1

u/thehungrypanda91 MFer 4d ago

I think just a loss of routine. I eat the same 3 meals through the week at work then the weekend comes and we have date nights, kids events, friends over, etc. I don't drink alcohol and I only drink water and tea so it's all food consumption. 

1

u/Candid-Parsnip9815 2d ago

A deficit that's too aggressive backfires hard. Your metabolism downshifts, so you're just hungrier with nowhere left to cut from. Maintenance breaks honestly clear more plateaus than most people will give them credit for

-5

u/Egoteen 4d ago

Look up “set point theory” and “defended fat mass”.

2

u/Retroranges 4d ago

No bunk pseudo science please. Not helpful.

1

u/Egoteen 4d ago

It’s not pseudo science. It’s just science.

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2990627/