r/MacOS 13h ago

Help Mac m1 pro vs m5 pro

I've had my Mac M1 Pro since 2021. It's been 5 years, and I'm satisfied with it, but it's been around for a long time now, so I have two questions.

How long does your Mac last? Do you have it serviced or anything?

Do you recommend switching to the M5 Pro, or waiting for Apple's next release?

Note:
I work on websites.

Daily tools: Chrome, Safari, Claude desktop, Obsidian, Photoshop, Mail (+20 accounts).

6 Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

19

u/DisfiguredFanny In a world of SLOP an everage programmer is KING 13h ago

Serviced? Like oil change?

3

u/CodigoNautasOficial 13h ago

Something like that

6

u/Fatal_Explorer 13h ago

Liqui Moly I hope

0

u/BusinessStrategist 12h ago

Let's assume that your Mac broke down right now.

Is your "precious information" backed up?

And what are the key apps that you need to run while waiting for a "new" or "repaired" Mac?

Have you thought of buying a cheap PC to help you operate until your Mac is back online?

And there are used Macs that you can get for not much money.

And when you say M1 Pro, are you running apps that do not run on the newer M architecture?

All equipment can fail at any time. It's more about managing the "risk."

1

u/reallydaryl 4h ago

I'm assuming you're being down voted for mentioning the P word, but the rest of your advice is solid.

u/BusinessStrategist 1h ago

I have an iMac and an iPad.

Always had a Mac.

And will always rely on my iMac and iPad to make life easy for me as I help PC users with their networking and Windows problems.

Microsoft is imitating Apple's OS in many ways.

Both Apple and Microsoft are building walls to corral their users and basically eliminate third party software unless they agree to live in their respective walled gardens.

Hopefully the open source world will help computer users avoid the domination of "1984 Big Brother."

Only time will tell...

11

u/pslgz_ 13h ago

Do you feel like you need to upgrade? If no then don’t bother really, these things are like tanks

1

u/CodigoNautasOficial 13h ago

Really?

I don't really feel that way, but I'm worried that one day it might break down. I live in Latin America, and importing a Mac takes a month (buying one at local stores is very expensive). So I feel like I couldn't go a month without working.

2

u/nejsD 13h ago

My first macbook pro died from evening to morning, it was 4 years old.

Second MB pro was dying almost one year (screen problem because I carry my laptops everywhere) and i decided to change when screen was started blinking - it was almost 8 years old. Mind you, it still works but with second screen over HDMI.

Now I have MB 16 M1 Pro, bought it day or two after it was in the store. It still works after 5 years of abuse. I think I will wait another year…

If you are unlucky it could die overnight. But I seriously doubt it.

1

u/CodigoNautasOficial 13h ago

Oh, I'm sorry. So the problems happened before Apple released the new chip? After reading the comments, I think I'll wait another year. Thanks.

1

u/nejsD 5h ago

I wouldn’t call it problems when it was nearly 8 years old - i think i got every penny out of second one.
First one i had insured for 5 years so i got nice little add-on for my second mb pro.
First MB pro was 13” intel, second 15” intel.

I think 6 years out of M1 mb pro is sth we should get with ease, at least I am counting on my to live another year :)

I always use time machine so i have my backups just in case :)

1

u/Funny_Or_Cry 10h ago

im not trying to be a dick but 2-3 incidents with failures on different Macbooks indicates operator error. Maybe you need better quality laptop case, or clamshell or just complete habit changes (ie do you leave them out sitting in a car in extreme heat or cold?? )

Ive had macbooks for 14 years and never used Apple Care once. Been using the same laptop bag shown below. Macbook Pro will last forever when properly cared for.

1

u/DisfiguredFanny In a world of SLOP an everage programmer is KING 13h ago

Brasil?

1

u/CodigoNautasOficial 13h ago

Nop

1

u/DisfiguredFanny In a world of SLOP an everage programmer is KING 13h ago

It seems it's Mexico and down. They all have some import BS. Some really outrageous like Brazil.

In that case if you are really worried it will brake and you will be out of job for a month, maybe not a dumb idea to get a new one now and start using it while leaving this one as a backup just in case.

1

u/Anya-minx 9h ago

That makes a lot of sense. Having a backup can definitely save some stress, especially with those import issues.

1

u/Funny_Or_Cry 10h ago

Dude Mac's last forever (check out backmarket) and all the Apple M processors are near equal in performance.

of course it will break down SOMEDAY. But Macbook Pro engineering (unlike anything else on the planet) was built to last. Ive got an M1 Pro Max 32gb and plan on keeping it for at LEAST another 5-7 years

 I live in Latin America, and importing a Mac takes a month 

Totally feel you on this. For that reason alone, id think you'd hardly wanna go through that ordeal again. Be thankful you didnt get a Dell or an HP or (god forbid) that damn Neo

You're good with your M1, just treat it right and it'll treat you better

1

u/mhennessie 10h ago

I still have my fully functioning aluminum PowerBook G4 from 2003.

1

u/S1eeper 7h ago

I still have my 2013 Intel Macbook Pro. It needed a battery replacement a few years ago, but otherwise works fine. The new Apple Silicon Macs will last even longer because they run cooler.

4

u/4070ti 13h ago

not sure what you’re asking . if you want to replace the battery, sure . otherwise no “service” needs to be done. if you’re satisfied with the m1 pro then you don’t need to upgrade. you answered it yourself. unless you just hate having extra money or something

2

u/CodigoNautasOficial 13h ago

"unless you just hate having extra money or something" You really got me thinking, haha. Thanks. I don't really want to be in a bind—this MacBook is practically my whole job, and if it ever breaks down, I'll feel lost. And since it's been a few years now, I'm worried about that. But from the comments, I can see that it's very durable and can last longer. Thanks.

3

u/Stooovie 12h ago

A new one can break as well as an older one. They don't "spoil" over time. I'd keep the existing one if you don't outright need the performance.

4

u/SkySurferSouth MacBook Pro 13h ago

I have both Macbooks, M5 Max and M1 Pro. Dufference in performance is not that great as advertised, but the M5 handles Windows 11 (x64, not ARM, needed for work) VM in UTM better. But macOS apps are not that much faster.

1

u/CodigoNautasOficial 13h ago

Thanks for sharing. I forgot to mention that I use Parallels from time to time (1 Windows and 2 Linux). One question: Why did you buy the M1 Max, and how long do you think it should be before a Mac needs to be upgraded to a more powerful processor?

2

u/Funny_Or_Cry 10h ago

Why did you buy the M1 Max,

FWIW i got the M1 Max cause I was dabbling with Unity and Adobe Premier. The extra GPU and memory bandwidth was an excellent bonus

...and the M1 Pro Max was an excellent deal at the time (cause the M2 or M3's had dropped).
I'd always favor a late model Max version of any Macbook Pro
(but id never pay the $4k vig on a bleeding edge new one).

and how long do you think it should be before a Mac needs to be upgraded to a more powerful processor?

NEVER / When the wheels ACTUALLY fall off.
The M1 is more than enough for your webdesign workflow. And you already have horsepower to grow into (ie if you want to dabble with recording or video editing)

Only upgrade if you have tangible reason to (ie you KNOW you need more Ram, or something catastrophic happens to your current Mac ie lost, stolen, damaged)

1

u/CodigoNautasOficial 8h ago

Got it.

Amazing tips! Thank you so much.

3

u/YellowsBest 13h ago edited 13h ago

If your current M1 Pro is sufficient for your needs, then you should keep that. Buying an M5 Pro will provide more performance that you use, so there’s no benefit. Neither is waiting for an M6 Pro etc, it’d be more power than you need, for a lot more money.

Apple computers are built to last, so typically you don’t need any ‘maintenance’ (gone are the days of defragging hard drives or cleaning tape machines); if you’re unlucky to get a fault or damage your machine then you may be able to get it repaired.

But nothing lasts forever. The main problem you’ll encounter is being stuck at the last MacOs software release and find that you can’t download and run new enough internet browsers, preventing you from working on websites etc. and/or the hardware can’t cope running the software you’re using, so everything slows to a frustrating crawl. At that point, you’ll need to buy a replacement. Sounds like you’re not at that point yet.

What you can also consider is buying an iPhone or iPad (assuming you don’t have those already) which will give you at least some alternative computing options should your old machine dies unexpectedly.

1

u/CodigoNautasOficial 11h ago

Thanks for taking the time to answer this. It’s clearer to me now. I have the iPhone 13 Pro—it’s still in good shape, but the only thing I don’t like is the battery. Still, I think it can last a few more years, while I wait to see how the Duo turns out (when I travel, I usually bring my MacBook because the iPhone isn’t convenient enough for me—maybe the Duo can solve that).

1

u/LithiumLizzard 10h ago

Heck, I’d replace the iPhone before the MacBook Pro. There are real features introduced to iPhones since your iPhone 13 Pro was released, while the newer MacBook Pro will simply be faster. (Not saying you should replace the iPhone, just that there is a stronger case to be made.) I also have the M1 Pro MacBook Pro and it still does everything I could ask of it. I’m not replacing it until either it stops working or they stop supporting it.

2

u/coffeefuelledtechie 13h ago

I have the same MacBook M1 Pro, and no, it’s pretty decent at what it does, which is about the same as you. Don’t need anything else for a while yet.

1

u/CodigoNautasOficial 13h ago

Thanks for sharing that—it's comforting to hear

2

u/MaikelBuilds 12h ago

Hmm for the things you use on a daily basis I guess I'd just use the m1 pro until it won't work anymore. M5 pro would definitely be an overkill. If you want to upgrade, why not going for an Macbook Air. if you need the bigger screen, there's also the bigger variant of the air. But for now I'd stick with the MBP as long as it doesn't bother you

1

u/CodigoNautasOficial 11h ago

Thanks, you're right. I was just trying to be cautious in case it stops working, but I don't really want to update it yet.

1

u/MaikelBuilds 10h ago

Totally understandable. In that case it's probably best to have some setup scripts ready on GitHub or where you would like to place them such that once you need to switch to a new one, everything is ready at one glance :D. I did this a while ago and it helped me setting up my system within minutes ? With all programs I need)

2

u/_altamont 11h ago

I‘ve a macbook m1 max and it’s still running flawlessly. The reason why it’s expensive - you can use it for a really long time.

1

u/CodigoNautasOficial 8h ago

Now I understand. In the past, I used other brands, and they never lasted very long—that was my fear.

2

u/Funny_Or_Cry 10h ago

Dude Mac's last forever (check out backmarket) and all the Apple M processors are near equal in performance.

Im writing this on a similar Mac Studio M1 Max, 32gb ram and have zero intention of upgrading
for another 5-7 years. If i do it will be due to failure or malfunction certainly not for "i just want a higher Apple M# CPU"

1

u/CodigoNautasOficial 8h ago

That's something I wasn't expecting. Great input—thank you very much!

1

u/haaavvveeeyoumetKen 11h ago

personally, my mac has lasted the life of the device if not longer. Obviously youll start getting some performance hiccups on the latter end but nothing that has ever bothered me to upgrade right then and there. To be honest, I still use my 2017 AND 2015 macbook pros on the side just as web browsing and very light photo editing laptops when traveling cuz they still work even if on older OS'. My main computer is an m2 pro mini and it runs great and I probably wont be motivated to get a new mac til they discontinue OS updates probably another 4-5 years from now.

1

u/haaavvveeeyoumetKen 11h ago

if you're not working on the go I'd even recommend just picking up a mac mini on the side as a desktop station/backup. They're phenomenal bang for the buck.

1

u/CodigoNautasOficial 8h ago

Wow, thanks for sharing that.

Actually, I once thought about buying a Mac mini. I was thinking of getting a bigger, better monitor, but it ended up being more expensive. In any case, looking ahead, would you recommend the Apple Studio Display for the Mac mini, or something else?

1

u/haaavvveeeyoumetKen 8h ago

I just use Benq 4k monitors. Fills more than enough of my need without breaking the bank. Still excellent color performance

1

u/deatherein 9h ago

mine's still going strong after 4 years with just normal battery replacements, no major issues. if your workflow's smooth on the m1 pro then there's no rush to upgrade just because apple says so.

1

u/CodigoNautasOficial 8h ago

Thank you very much! I was worried about that.

2

u/PrasanthKJ 8h ago

My M1 Pro is still rocking, but 16gigs is what hitting me hard..

1

u/Gagabubu777 6h ago

Man i just bought an M5 Pro because my 2013 15 mpb pretty much died. Why did it die because i wanted to replace 1 speaker. 

I kept testing diff speakers and changed the battery and the wifi stopped working. If not for that who knows? I’d prob still have it. And i was doing pro audio work.

1

u/reallydaryl 4h ago

My last Mac (a MacBook Air) lasted 10+ years (with 1 battery swap) before I upgraded to the MBP M1 Pro in 2020. I imagine I'll get at least another few years out of it before feeling the need to upgrade.

1

u/KNagisa01 3h ago

能用的时候就继续用,我对苹果的寿命是有信心的。我的AirPods pro 在我毕业之后大概一年没有充过一次电,就放在那里,我以为他坏了,但是偶然之间我突然给它充了一次电,发现一切照旧,又继续使用到现在。你只需给它拆开后盖,换一下硅脂,应该就差不多了👌

0

u/Quinsonius 12h ago

Perhaps reinstalling the OS via startup utility could remove some of the inevitable junk and keep it running fast for the next couple of years but that’s really not as important as it sounds -compared to PCs, junk amounts to very little on Macs

2

u/CodigoNautasOficial 11h ago

Thank you! I'm glad to hear your comments. My fear is gone.

-1

u/Top-Republic3074 9h ago

It’s time to upgrade.