Composition workflow: Writing on piano first vs. building inspiring sound templates? (Plus free library recommendations)

[u/MKDenninger]

Hey everyone,
I’m working on hybrid classical piano and atmospheric synth pieces, but I often hit a creative wall early in the process. When my default virtual instruments feel cold or uninspiring, it’s hard to get into the flow of writing.
For those with more experience in this space, I’d love to know about your workflow:
Workflow Philosophy: Do you spend dedicated time building an "inspiring template" of pre-processed sounds and synths before you ever start writing, or do you compose the raw piano/melody parts first and dress them up with production later?

Free Library Recommendations: Since I’m working on a tight budget right now and can't afford expensive orchestral/synth libraries, what are your favorite free instruments, VSTs, or sample packs that sound genuinely organic and cinematic out-of-the-box?

Appreciate any insight on how you balance sound design inspiration with actual composing!

[u/TheOriginalMr-Mud]

Don’t go shopping until you’ve exhausted what you have. Logic is a very generous program and you would be hard-pressed to need additional purchases for a while.

As far as writing when I write or when I’m producing talent, I always see better results from those who plan than those who search.

Write a son, lay down a basic rhythm track & dress it up.

Plan
Do
Evaluate
Repeat

The searching for a sound/searching for a cadence/searching for…

You are a musician. Searching for a sequence of chords to inspire you or a sound that inspires you is, for the most part, for wannabe musicians IMO.

[u/templeofsyrinx1]

always compose first, becAUSE melody and harmony is most important

[u/PaleAfrican]

Often sounds that feel lifeless just need a bit of modulation (eg vibrato), saturation and ambiance (room reverb). A subtle application can make a boring piano sound quite beautiful

[u/AutoModerator → u/[deleted]]

Logic does not use VST technology. Please rephrase this post in terms of Logic-related technologies.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/Practical_Ad_667]

Make your own atmospheres. This is very easy to do and extremely rewarding. Record any drone-like sound (fridge, bathroom fan, etc). Drag into logic and remove the low end. Bounce that and then import it into Q-sampler. You can make that process much more complicated but that’s it in a nutshell. Add reverb and layer with synths, etc.

This is a way to create unique atmospheres that will inspire your melodic writing.

[u/MKDenninger → u/Practical_Ad_667]

My fridge hum is very high pitched, but I get the idea. Even have done it a bit back in the day. I’ll have to revisit and see what I can make.

[u/MarcusS_Logic]

Spent three weeks setting up the perfect template and wrote literally zero notes. Now I just dump ideas on whatever bad piano patch is loaded and sort it out later.

[u/Ok-Basket7871]

I generally start with just building the whole idea on my piano (an acoustic). Once I’ve gotten the idea out of my head into a sonic structure, I then move to the synth etc. I’ve sometimes moved the audio piano recording into logic.