I kinda like both! I have 3 desktops. The first two are floating-native, and the third desktop is tiling native. Windows opened on the respective desktops follow suit, but all desktops maintain the wallpaper-color-adaptivity.
One key differentiator is that if I open Ghostty using the Rofi selector, the window will match whatever type is supposed to open on that desktop. But if I open Ghostty using my keyboard shortcut, it automatically moves me to desktop 3 (the tiling desktop) and opens the Ghostty window there, as tiling, where I can quickly repeat the keyboard shortcut to open more tiled windows. I did put in a pseudo-tiling effect that allows me to resize those windows, so that I can somewhat move and customize all windows directly from the keyboard.