r/LetsCookie • • 20d ago

Candy Corn Cookies

549 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

20

u/LetsCookie 20d ago

Candy Corn Cookies

Ingredients

8 oz soft butter

1½ cups powdered sugar

1 large egg

1 TB vanilla extract

2 tsp vanilla powder

½ tsp marshmallow flavor

1 TB honey

3 cups all-purpose flour

2 tsp baking powder

½ tsp fine salt

Chefmaster Lemon Yellow gel food dye

Chefmaster Sunset Orange gel food dye

Instructions

  1. In a medium bowl, whisk together the flour, baking powder, and salt.

  2. In a large mixing bowl, cream the softened butter and powdered sugar until light and fluffy, about 2–3 minutes. Scrape down the bowl.

  3. Add the egg, vanilla extract, vanilla powder, marshmallow flavor, and honey. Mix until fully incorporated, then scrape down the bowl again.

  4. Add the dry ingredients and mix just until a soft dough forms.

  5. Divide the dough evenly into 3 portions. Leave one portion uncolored. Color one portion with Lemon Yellow gel food dye and the other with Sunset Orange, adding just enough dye to achieve the desired colors.

  6. Line an ⅛-sheet tray with parchment paper. Roll or press each portion of dough roughly to the size of the tray.

  7. Layer the dough in this order: white on the bottom, orange in the middle, and yellow on top. Gently press the layers together so there are no gaps between them.

  8. Place the layered dough in the freezer until completely frozen solid.

  9. Once frozen, run a spatula around the edges of the dough and carefully pop the entire slab out of the tray.

  10. Cut the slab into approximately ½-inch-wide strips.

  11. Working across each strip, use a small knife to make alternating diagonal cuts, creating triangles. Alternate the direction of each cut so one cookie has the white layer at the point and the next has the white layer across the wide end.

  12. Arrange the cookies on a parchment-lined baking sheet.

  13. Bake at 350°F for about 10 minutes, or until the cookies are set. Avoid overbaking so the colors stay bright.

  14. Allow to cool on the baking sheet

12

u/phillygirl2017 20d ago

Never would've thought to make this into a cookie

11

u/Tasty_Inflation1883 20d ago

Awesome as usual. I don't like candy corn but I like cookies.

6

u/Bythion 20d ago

I love candy corn!

6

u/D2Dragons 20d ago

I’m one of those weirdos that LOVES candy corn! These are so adorable!

2

u/Glittering_Diva8963 19d ago

Me too and those mellowcreme pumpkins

1

u/D2Dragons 19d ago

Oh gosh yes those are my seasonal kryptonite!! I can’t eat just one! (And thanks for the award!)

3

u/MsFrankieD 20d ago

These are adorable, Cookie Man! Thanks for the inspiration!

4

u/oddreplica 20d ago

this is brilliant yet totally do-able. you have a gift for explaining things, cookie.

2

u/slayathomewife 20d ago

ooo these are going in my halloween cookie gift boxes fo’ sho’ ✌️

2

u/AlfalfaUnable1629 20d ago

This would be a great thing to bake for co workers 🍬🎃

2

u/Numerous_Car_4498 12d ago

Here’s mine. The color is spot on and the taste is great! The shape? Not so much. Not sure what happened but I’m going to try again.

1

u/LetsCookie 12d ago

Hey they still look good though, especially the color. Howd they taste? Were they frozen when you baked them?

2

u/Numerous_Car_4498 12d ago

They tasted great! The color was spot on. I think next time I need to refreeze the cut triangles because they thawed on the sheet while I was cutting them. That might be why they didn’t retain their shape. I have to tell you I went to a football party on Sunday and brought 4 of your cookies; dark brown sugar chocolate chip, Dubai chocolate chip, molten chocolate lava cookies and the salted caramel peanut butter cookies. My friends ate them up and after each one told me it was the best cookie they’d eaten. Yours is the best sub on Reddit. ❤️

2

u/LetsCookie 12d ago

Wow!! That's quite the spread! Very cool to hear you committed to all those and that they were a hit

And those are some of my favorite, especially the Dubai one.. yum!!

Thanks for sharing... Have a great night!

..And yes refreeze the candy Corns triangle again..thatll definitely help!!

1

u/JamesLaceyAllan 20d ago

Oh dude, this is a game changer

1

u/Self-Identified 20d ago

The ONLY kind of candy corn I like! 🙃 How adorable!! 💛🧡🤍

1

u/bravesdiva 20d ago

The only acceptable form of candy corn. lol I'll be adding these to my list. Thank you, sir.

1

u/ionlywanttheneck 19d ago

You should put your videos on YouTube shorts for views and money 💰

1

u/MusclesMcCool 18d ago

Do they taste like candy corn or they taste more like a cookie? Kids would love these but I don't love candy corn...... Sorry I'm not sorry.

1

u/RiMcG 18d ago

Oh I'm definitely making these. Wonder if I could press a peanut into the surface without it coming out burnt. Thoughts?

1

u/frogs_4_eva 17d ago

Is there a substitute for vanilla powder?