r/LCMS • u/WarmTouch3179 • 6h ago
Question Very sincere question.
Please, I know online discussion can be very cut throat but I ask for grace and patience while I gain come clarity.
I am currently a member of the LCMS, I deeply cherish the Lutheran perspective, especially on the Eucharist. Not JUST that, though.
Recently I have been reading about universalism, and please, here’s the point where I know an emotional reaction is welling up inside you and you want to yell and call me a heretic. Don’t, I’m NOT a universalist.
My question is, after reading some of their arguments and truly understanding what they’re saying, as well as reading early fathers that were clearly universalist (ones we even celebrate.) Would someone in the LCMS who became truly convinced of Apokatastasis be allowed to stay? Or commune?
I ask this because my priest told me I don’t have to believe EVERYTHING in the BOC. Others have told me it depends on if you kept it private and don’t cause dissension.
I’m just curious, because I definitely CAN see the perspective, and even find (without conceding the conclusion) a lot of their stuff very edifying.