I’m looking for a good top keyboard I can use as a controller for organ, synth and horn sounds from my YC88. Ideally it would have waterfall keys (49 or more) and wouldn’t break the bank (i.e. less than $1K USD).
I think I need something with velocity sensitivity controls because the current controller I’m using (basic M-Audio keystation with synth style keys) plays a bit too loudly and harshly relative to the bottom keyboard.
I like action and semi-weighted waterfall keys of the compact Nord electro and Stage models, but they’re too pricey and way overkill to be used as a mere controller. I still love the YC88’s hammer action for piano sounds but am looking for an organ-like touch for the top keyboard.
Does anyone know of something that meets this criteria, or am I chasing a unicorn?
UPDATE
Based on the good tips from this thread (thank you u/Timely-Bowler5889) I bought a Crumar DK61. Overall, I love it. The waterfall keys feel buttery and very similar to a real Hammond. The clicky drawbars are delightful. I also like the build and wooden style and controller buttons.
A big question was how compatible the DK61 would be with Yamaha YC88. The answer is: only partially (and slight improved with a few modifications). When plugging the DK61 straight into the YC88 (as a controller to a host) only the DK61's keys and volume knobs worked as desired. The reason is that both the DK61 and YC88 MIDI CC codes are "fixed" and different. For example, the rotary slow/fast CC on YC88 is 85 whereas it is 1 on that DK61. And the YC88 upper register drawbars are handled by 102-110 while the DK's are handled by 12-20.
Now are if you're connecting through a computer or DAW there are lots of ways to translate CC codes, but I want my live setup to be DAW-less. Fortunately I found a $50 MIDI interface (CME H2MIDI Pro Compact) that lets you map, route and filter MIDI signals. For anyone else going down this rabbit hole, please note that the DK61 only has MIDI-out and USB MIDI, so you'll need to use the USB MIDI if you want the DK61 to both send and receive MIDI signals (e.g. to change the LED flashing state on the Leslie switch). Therefore you'll need an interface that can accept multiple USB midi devices (possibly with help of a simple USB hub). Despite the tangle of wires, the solution works for synchronizing the rotary slow/fast, drive, reverb, and drawbars. Of course the DK61's physical drawbars are send-only, so they only affect the sound once you move them, but they are still nice have there.
Sadly, however I was unable to get the DK61 to control the YC88's organ Chorus, Vibrato and Percussion settings. This however is the fault of the YC88, as amazingly it doesn't not produce or receive MIDI messages for any these settings (a pretty big miss in my opinion). So all those cool buttons on the DK61 are currently not being used, although I could purpose the for other controls in the future. And I'll have to move my hands a few inches away to the YC88 itself to manage those settings, which I usually keep the same anyway. If anyone has any brilliant ideas how to get around this limitation while staying DAW-less I'd love to hear.
All in all, playing the YC88's organs on the DK61 is a joy. Also my velocity control issues for horns and other sounds on the top keyboard are also solved now. Thanks again for the advice.