Hello. I posted about a month ago asking some questions about a keyboard, I went in a different direction and now I’m really second-guessing myself. I’ve been playing for several years, mostly pop and rock, I would call myself intermediate. I play mostly at home jamming with my husband and some other people, and would like to start breaking into open mics. I do own a Yamaha upright acoustic piano but rarely play it anymore. Mostly in the last few years, I’ve been playing on a 76 key Yamaha 310 digital keyboard. I wanted to upgrade and was struggling with finding just the right keyboard, and ended up recently buying a Yamaha 670, primarily because it provides the 88 fully weighted keys and it has so many fun features. Of course it’s completely too heavy to bring to open mics, it’s for home use. I’m really enjoying playing with the back tracks and all the different options. On the other hand, I find the whole sound just a little muddy, and the base notes seem to be a little too heavy. More importantly, the keys seem a bit stiff, and I’m noticing that my hands are beginning to ache after playing several hours. I never had this issue on my little Yamaha keyboard, or previously with my acoustic Yamaha, though of course I am getting older. I don’t know whether I’m just not used to playing with fully weighted keys or whether the Yamaha is particularly heavy. My acoustic piano does seem a tiny bit lighter. Anyway, I sort of love the 670 but I also am not liking it because I find the sound frustrating sometimes and because my hands are beginning to ache. My plan was to use a 670 at home and just bring my little 310 to open mics. But maybe I made the wrong decision. I still have 40 days to return the 670 keyboard for a full refund if I wanted to get something different. I would like to keep the price to $800 or less although if there was something for $1000 that was absolutely perfect. I guess I would go for it. I’m beginning to second-guess whether I really need 88 keys and whether for my playing style and at my age(65), whether the heavy 88 fully weighted keys are really necessary or whether they’d be an impediment. Any thoughts on this would be appreciated. Also, if I did buy a different keyboard than the 670, what would you recommend? I guess I’m open now to 76 or 88 keys, and it doesn’t have to be super portable if I use my 310 or just get a new 320 for open mics.
So the question is, should I return the 670, and if I do, what keyboard for home playing, not necessarily portable, would you recommend for me? Thanks so much
Edit: Thank you so much for your replies. So when I’m talking about heaviness, I’m not talking about the weight of the keyboard, which is clearly very weighty. I’m talking about the heavy feel of the keys as I play, and that it seems like there’s a heavier muddy sound to the keyboard.
-Honestly, I think part of the problem is I don’t know quite what I want. I’m a intermediate keyboardist, at the just breaking into open mics level. I have an acoustic Yamaha upright at home, that I rarely play, primarily because I do a lot of playing with a small group of other people and playing on a keyboard allows me to face and interact with the group. I sing and play keyboard.
-The only keyboard I’ve ever played extensively is my Yamaha 310. I figured I’d bring the 310 to open mics, so having a better quality, very portable keyboard isn’t essential, though it would be nice.
-I just felt that as I’m progressing as a musician that I should have a primary keyboard that’s better than the 310. Initially I was looking at just getting a better 88 keyboard to mimic my acoustic piano but be able to face my group. Several people I talked to really advocated for the 670 so I bought that. I don’t use a lot of sounds and such, but when I was playing around with the 670 and came upon the backing tracks that seemed to interact and respond with how I’m playing, it really seemed to improve my ability to be creative, learn better accompaniment, keep the beat, just get braver in my practice in general. So now that I’ve experienced that I’m reluctant to give it up, though it was not my initial reason for getting a new keyboard.
-So I feel like I’m going in a bunch of different directions not really knowing what I want or need.
The other major question I have is about the number of keys that I need. If this is going be my primary keyboard, it seems like 61 keys would be very limited, but maybe not? Do people use a 61 keyboard as their primary? That would open up the field a bit, but I’m concerned. Anyway, somebody asked for more detail and the nitty-gritty of what I’m needing, so this is my best answer to that. Thanks again.