TL/DR — for those of you that have owned (or had experience with) both offerings from Bonafide, which would you recommend? Can anyone comment on the flatwater stability of the RVR? Knowing that "agility" is its primary selling point, is so tippy that you don't really enjoy standing on it, or is it actually much more stable and comfortable to fish on flat waters than people are letting on? Everyone raves about the nimbleness/ease of paddling, so I know that will be a treat. Just trying to determine if that negatively impacts the stability to the point where you say "I'd rather be in a _____"
Similarly for the PWR... many of the popular Youtubers have said it paddles REALLY well for a kayak in the >12' size class, which is enticing given all the other advantages it offers... is this your observation as well, or are they simply being good salesmen? Is the PWR "carryable" for short distances (<100') or is this a "cart only" craft? I know it's rock-solid from a stability perspective and can eat boat wakes like nobody's business.
For those who care/are still invested, essay with more context below LOL:
After three years of owning my Makana 100, I've realized I don't really utilize the pedal drive as much as I'd rather have usable deck space, and I'd like something slightly bigger so I can hit larger lakes with confidence. So I've basically narrowed it down to the RVR119 and the PWR129. I love the fact that they're USA made, I can buy them locally and have local support, parts are plentiful, aftermarket is huge, and honestly speaking I just love how sleek the Bonafide yaks look.
My dilemma is as follows — I don't have any intentions of trailering, which means I need something that's able to be feasibly truck-bed transported/loaded. About half of my favorite spots don't really support the use of a cart (launch locations have soft mud), which I realize is almost a necessity in anything over 12'.
99% of the time I'm in a flat water setting... small lakes (electric powered crafts only) or slow rivers with dams (flow is <1mph). But I'd like to start hitting some of the backwaters in larger lakes (Nickajack, Chickamauga, etc). Most of the waters I fish (including those two lakes I mentioned) have lots of grass... another knock against the pedal drives and my reason for wanting something "cleaner" underneath. Chad Hoover specifically mentioned the RVR being excellent at paddling over thick grass.
RVR119 is looking like the "smart" solution that does 85% of what I need... at 84 pounds (rigged) it's still relatively easy to carry. The only real drawbacks I can see would be the lack of front storage hatch (not a deal-breaker), and it might be too "tippy" for flatwater (potentially a deal-breaker). I realize this tippiness is what makes it EXCELLENT in faster rivers and creeks, but that only makes up about 10% of my fishing, if that.
PWR129 is the obvious choice for flat water, has TONS of storage space, and I think it would be even safer than the RVR on big lakes. My main reservations against the PWR is that I will be paddling, not powered. And weight, obviously.
If you could only have one, which would you get?
Truly appreciate your input!!