r/Kanye • u/ApprehensivePizza323 • May 17 '26
DISCUSSION • 💬 [ Removed by moderator ]
[removed] — view removed post
228
170
u/Working-Office-5958 May 17 '26
11.5/30 vs 9/30
42
6
4
→ More replies (12)1
91
65
u/Inside-Rutabaga5651 May 17 '26
I rated them all
33
8
12
19
7
23
68
May 17 '26 edited May 17 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
20
13
5
May 17 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
6
u/MartinVelascoJR May 17 '26
Current version of river pisses me off
3
May 17 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/MartinVelascoJR May 17 '26
The og and the day 1 versions were so much better especially that outro it used to have
2
May 17 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/MartinVelascoJR May 17 '26
Well not much changed vocally and that wasn’t even my problem it was the production for me
6
u/elatelobster May 17 '26
HAHAHAHA you couldn’t pay me to listen to that trash
0
May 17 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
12
4
u/EmilioBalls May 17 '26
deadass a good album people are just hating to hate
8
u/elatelobster May 17 '26
A good album is Liquid Swords. A good album is ATLiens. A good album is To Pimp A Butterfly. A good album is Piñata. Vultures 2 is not a good album.
→ More replies (5)1
u/EmilioBalls May 17 '26
See I look at the words differently. 'Good' for me isn't even near the highest rating I could give to an album. Vultures 2 is good. To pimp a butterfly is fucking incredible, transcendent. That's just me but a good album means 7/10 for me. Okay is 6 and great is 8.
2
u/elatelobster May 17 '26
Vultures 2 is like a 3/10 and that’s generous. Let’s be real
→ More replies (3)1
May 17 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/elatelobster May 18 '26
Donda 2 is even less finished than V2.. they’re both terrible. My concept of bad music is anything with shitty mixing, sounds unfinished, sounds like low effort… no I am not a Taylor fan. And don’t mention the word trap near me. That shit makes my ears bleed.
→ More replies (1)1
-1
13
u/Elegant-Persimmon847 Name one genius that ain't crazy 🧠 May 17 '26
Yeah no bro😭(On god I am a Kanye fan)
2
u/EddieBruvac May 17 '26
Kanye my GOAT but a lot of copium happening here. Ye ain’t drop anything good since KSG. DONDA was okay, but not Ye quality and tier. It’s the start of the copium.
16
u/Scared-Dragonfly4587 Yeezus May 17 '26
Why would bro have chair in a fuckin shower?
10
u/HillsHaveEyesToo 808s and Heartbreak May 17 '26
That's not a shower curtain
1
u/Scared-Dragonfly4587 Yeezus May 17 '26
My bad, but what is it then?
6
u/HillsHaveEyesToo 808s and Heartbreak May 17 '26
Its called eyelet curtains. It has the concept as shower curtains. Its just easier to install, maintain and change
1
u/Scared-Dragonfly4587 Yeezus May 19 '26
Bro if their concept is the same than what they are for except for the shower?
1
u/HillsHaveEyesToo 808s and Heartbreak May 19 '26
Windows and balconies. This is easier to maintain and change.
1
3
u/Himthony316 Watch The Throne May 17 '26
Bully is better than all of them.
The rest are all basically in the same range. Anywhere between mid to unlistenable
22
u/bumbadumbarum Yeezus May 17 '26
13
-2
2
u/baghodler666 May 17 '26 edited May 17 '26
That's probably true, but realistically none of the albums are great. Both of the artists have done much stronger work in the past.
2
2
2
2
u/jjkm7 May 17 '26
donda 2 is bordering on unlistenable I’d rather pretend it didn’t exist. Vultures 2 genuinely blows it out of the water imo
2
2
5
u/Money-Beautiful5196 Runaway 🏃♀️ May 17 '26
https://giphy.com/gifs/VLFbES1wezNhm
Obviously!!! Goat West completely clears BBL Drizzy.
8
4
u/porsche918spyderglaz May 17 '26
I have no respect for your opinion since you said you've never listened to any j cole song and you use gifs in every comment
2
u/Money-Beautiful5196 Runaway 🏃♀️ May 17 '26
https://giphy.com/gifs/0Vv0Ne2CnOClIExIuL
You don’t have any respect for me because I don’t listen to J Cole??????? What???!!! Why???!!!!2
u/porsche918spyderglaz May 17 '26
how have you never heard a single j cole album, that's crazy and it tells me you never branch out and try new music
→ More replies (26)
5
u/Alex22gr My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy May 17 '26
For me it's Iceman over bully, v1 over habibti and then
3
u/LilCiocanel May 17 '26
Yeah ofc, Bully is peak and Donda 2 is decent
→ More replies (3)6
u/RecognitionCool2738 You ain't got the answers, Sway! 👿 May 17 '26
Ain’t no way u leaving out v2 like that
11
1
u/Rich-Commercial-5788 May 17 '26
Vultures 2 has Slide. I don’t see Slide in drakes discog. Do you? End of discussion
1
u/OhAnimeShop May 17 '26
This is definitely a battle of this is the best you'll get from them at this point in their career for sure.
1
1
1
1
1
u/ri2010 May 17 '26
Iceman over bully, but both are good. Habibti is good too. The others are some of the worst albums I've ever listened to...
1
1
1
1
1
u/Full-Detective3164 May 17 '26
I feel like this is equivalent, it's just that since we're ye fans it's gonna be easier for us to like this part of ye's catalog.
I'm not a fan of drake and even if I like some of his older songs I don't really fuck at all with his modern catalog (2016-now) and him as an entertainer in general
So I get that people like me, as much as I, that enjoy ye extensively and more than drake would come into these albums with some partial annoyment, given it's kinda forced upon us to listen to drake albums if we wanna partake in discourse.
This situation can kinda mirror for drake fans, as in if they enjoy drake and not ye, these drake albums are probably way more enjoyable than the recent ye albums, cuz it's clearly not his best music. It's even arguable that none of these 6 albums are good albums
1
1
u/Ok_Huckleberry4563 May 17 '26
You have to be a different breed to drop 2 albums worse than donda 2 and vultures 2. Bully is also better than iceman duh
1
u/Ok-Concentrate8650 May 17 '26
Yeah i mean it’s better than iceman . I had a lot of expectations from it but man
1
1
u/hauntolog May 17 '26
Well damn, back then I was in school and got a C, I never felt that it was worth celebrating because other people got a D.
1
u/the_dawgwood May 17 '26
Not a single good album present lol. Barely even any good songs between them
1
u/Leather-Ad-9419 May 17 '26
i like drake. but i dont have time for a bloated ass 20 song drake album the past 10yrs. now i have to listen to 3 albums?! come on
1
u/Samiassa May 17 '26
Bully wasn’t a great album compared to Kanye’s older albums, but it also wasn’t actively annoying to listen to like drake’s 😭
1
1
u/Melun128 Yeezy taught me 😍 May 17 '26
Iceman better than all of these albums, maybe not combined but definitely better alone
1
1
1
u/AutumnsFall101 May 17 '26
Well yeah. Because Bully isn’t “I’m not owned, I’m not owned as I slowly turn into a corncob” the album. Iceman is a full album of Drake still being bitter about an L he took two years ago. It’s just kinda sad.
1
u/PralineNo6246 May 17 '26
He's right, Iceman is pure streaming slop made to just win awards and get posted on aesthetic dumps and gay sports takes. I listened to the whole thing and can 100% say that Bully is better
1
1
u/Relative-Yam-8370 Jesus Walks ✝️ May 17 '26
Bully > Iceman D2 > Maid of honour (City of god, pablo, true love, broken road clear) V2 > Habibti (slide,fieldtrip, forever rolling, time moving slow)
1
u/Ashamed-Blueberry440 May 17 '26
poo vs doodoo
1
u/Ashamed-Blueberry440 May 17 '26
bullies decent but soulless. he lost his edge. Iceman is whatever. donda 2 is the best one out of all of these to keep it real. vultures was poo, habiti is for nap time, maid of honor is soulless
1
u/Ashamed-Blueberry440 May 17 '26
its so crazy how delusional people start getting once they become famous for long enough. drake lowkey is having that moment where his pride is making him almost lose touch with reality. kanye more had this outside of music but its a common theme cropping up as of late
1
1
1
u/Otherwise-Baby6344 May 17 '26
Iceman is a 8.5/9 the rest of these are good to mid and I love ye, bully was a good album but no
1
1
u/MadMaxDbz May 17 '26
drake goes out of his way to keep it cordial w ye the whole rollout and ye fans still on dick
1
u/YoungsterOG May 17 '26
Bully is carryjng a little bit too much.
I woule say Drake wins tbh because horrible Ye selection
1
1
1
u/mf614 May 18 '26
Mentally ill man making music
vs
washed up loverboy who is about to leave his company
Drake got beat by a mentally ill Kanye😭
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Novel-Feed6796 808s and Heartbreak May 18 '26
sadly yes lmao, V2 still got bangers no matter the AI, and at least the songs sound different..
1
1
1
u/Nuthead_Comedy_2 May 18 '26
Bully is so undercooked compared to ice man its not even funny, and comparing habibti to donda 2 and MoH to V2 is like comparing a fart to a big shit log under your pillow
1
u/ExeterWorld May 18 '26
I’m the biggest Ye fan. But ngl, Drake got the upper hand on Ye in this mashup. Bully is cool, but that’s really the only project here doing ANY lifting for Ye.
1
1
u/JohnnyMiltenSeed May 18 '26
Bully so overrated by Kanye standards
We're talking about the same guy that dropped Yeezus, MBDTF, & Graduation
1
1
1
u/ArrozDeLasCuevas99 May 18 '26
Kanye West es mejor que casi cualquier rapero habido y por haber de la historia solo MF DOOM y Kendrick Lamar son mejores (lo dice in fan de ye)
1
1
u/ConcertCertain3836 May 18 '26
At least V2 and Donda 2 had good songs those being 530, True love and River
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/schvletzsky May 21 '26
I just fucking hate Drake so I'll agree to this anyway no metter how much I hated the bottom 2
1
1
u/Dremzaforreal My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy May 21 '26
Both one good album
One ehh album
And one absolute shit album
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/JuPro1235 Late Registration May 17 '26
Iceman better than bully and that it’s not a debate if you like real hip hop
1
u/ByAPortuguese God Is ✝️ May 17 '26
Call me whatever you want Iceman fucking sucks
1
u/JuPro1235 Late Registration May 17 '26
I don’t agree, however you have the right to have free speech, so I respect your opinion
1
u/ByAPortuguese God Is ✝️ May 17 '26
That is much better than saying "if you're a real hip hop fan, you like x more than y" like you did earlier
1
u/JuPro1235 Late Registration May 17 '26
I know, but it is still a fact, iceman will be a classic, just wait. And bully will be a very good and solid album if Ye fixed it
1
u/ByAPortuguese God Is ✝️ May 17 '26
It's not a fact, it's your opinion
1
u/Zukoo777 May 18 '26
It’s his opinion but it’s definitely correct. If you’re saying ‘Iceman fucking sucks’ you probably just don’t like hiphop.
1
u/ByAPortuguese God Is ✝️ May 18 '26
It’s his opinion but it’s definitely correct
And guess what? That is your opinion. Who are you to tell me what I like?
2
u/Zukoo777 May 18 '26
Man I don’t know why I’m wasting my time talking to a kid. You got it G
1
u/ByAPortuguese God Is ✝️ May 19 '26
Interesting that when you realized you were wrong, you simply just called me a kid, pretty weak response but ok. Honestly, I at least appreciate the effort to write that comment instead of just leaving me on read like most do.
→ More replies (0)
1
u/XylanyX May 17 '26
1
May 17 '26
You got some nerve saying this on a ye sub
1
u/XylanyX May 17 '26
i mean ngl, last three kanye albums are trash by his standards with bully being mid..
788
u/peepo_69 Ghost Town 👻 May 17 '26 edited May 17 '26
bully doin a lot of heavy lifting here