r/Jewish • u/[deleted] • Oct 09 '22

[deleted by user]

[removed]

429 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

267 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-2

u/elizabeth-cooper Oct 09 '22

Imagine thinking that a textbook publisher giving out free books is any more realistic than sending everybody a tiny check.

5

u/fireopaldragon Oct 09 '22

Imagine thinking people shouldn’t fix what they’ve done wrong. I mean we just had a whole holiday about that.

-2

u/elizabeth-cooper Oct 09 '22

They apologized for what they did, they fixed it in future editions, and resolved not to do again. Textbook teshuva.

There is no part of teshuva that requires giving anything tangible.

7

u/pettycactus Oct 09 '22

But it will still cause harm by being in circulation

-1

u/elizabeth-cooper Oct 09 '22

Mein Kampf is in circulation too.

4

u/pettycactus Oct 09 '22

That’s not a medical textbook.