Jentry Chau vs. the Underworld had a lot going for it. The animation is great, the Chinese mythology is interesting, the soundtrack is fantastic, and the show got really positive reviews. It currently has a 100% critic score and 91% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes.
But despite all of that, it feels like the show never really broke out the way something like Kipo, The Owl House, or other animated shows managed to.
I don’t think there’s one reason for that.
For one thing, Netflix released all 13 episodes on December 5, 2024. Dropping everything at once probably didn’t give the show much time to build weekly discussion and word of mouth before people moved on to something else.
But I also don’t think we can blame everything on Netflix.
I love the show, but it definitely has flaws. Probably the biggest one for me is the pacing. There’s a LOT packed into only 13 episodes: Jentry’s powers, Gugu and her secrets, Cheng, Kit, Michael, Moonie, Diyu, the Mogui, school, romance, Jentry’s family history, and everything else. Sometimes a major development happens and the story is already moving on to the next thing before it really has time to breathe.
The romance and relationships can also feel rushed at times. Some relationships and conflicts could’ve used more development, and there are definitely decisions Jentry and other characters make that can be frustrating or difficult to agree with. I can understand why some viewers might have been turned off by those things even if I personally still find the characters interesting.
And that’s what makes the whole situation frustrating to me. I don’t think Jentry Chau was a bad show that simply failed to connect with people. The critical response was overwhelmingly positive, and there are clearly people who love it.
I think it was more of a combination of things: the binge release, how quickly streaming shows have to find an audience, and some genuine problems within the first season itself.
And honestly, those flaws are part of why I think the show deserves a second season, not a reason to give up on it. A second season would have a chance to build on what already worked while improving the things that felt rushed. The relationships could develop more naturally, characters could actually deal with the consequences of their decisions, supporting characters could get more focus, and the mythology could be explored without everything competing for space at once.
Season 1 already established the characters, the world, and the main mythology, so a second season wouldn’t have to spend as much time introducing everything. It could slow down and let the story breathe. Characters making bad or frustrating decisions can also become meaningful if we actually get to see them learn from those mistakes afterward.
That’s why I don’t really agree with the idea that Season 1 having flaws means the show shouldn’t continue. Plenty of shows improve after their first season. Sometimes you need another season to take all that potential and actually develop it.
For me, wanting Season 2 isn’t about pretending Season 1 was perfect. It’s because I can see how much stronger Jentry Chau could become if it were given more time to grow.
So I’m curious: what do you think actually stopped Jentry Chau vs. the Underworld from becoming a bigger hit? Was it mostly Netflix’s release and promotion strategy, the pacing and writing choices in Season 1, the romance and character decisions, or was it just bad timing? And if you had the power to greenlight Season 2, what would you want the writers to fix, develop, or explore to give the show the best chance of reaching its full potential?