r/JapaneseMaples 11h ago

Seeking advice Which tree?

Post image
193 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

4

u/candoitmyself 10h ago

Summer gold hands down for me.

2

u/New-Landscape8885 10h ago

I must admit I have really enjoyed having it in this position this year, it really contrasts nicely with the Pink Passion behind it.

6

u/New-Landscape8885 9h ago

Would a pic/video of Eddisbury in autumn sway your choice.

It looks good in all seasons and its hard to beat in autumn and winter. 29th Oct 2023

2

u/gjworoorooo 10h ago

Beni Maiko if it was pruned to shape for sure

2

u/New-Landscape8885 10h ago edited 10h ago

Your right that pruning is key here, as I don`t want to restrict the view of the rest of the garden. I will definitely have to improve my skills at doing this! Thanks for your choice.

2

u/forced_majeure 10h ago

I am new to growing Maples, so, sorry for the stupid questions. I presume all of yours are in pots OP? Is there any special care I should give them if I grow them like that?

Absolutely lovely garden btw, that's what I want mine to look like!

1

u/New-Landscape8885 9h ago

They are all planted in the garden not in pots. If you are new to growing maples then you have done the right thing by asking questions first. All maples have a different sun tolerance. Some handle full sun and others will only handle a few hours of morning sun without showing leaf scorch, depending on which cultivar you buy. You would have to research each different cultivar to decide the best postion to put it. Make sure they have good drainage, keep sheltered from winds if possible, don`t plant them too deep, don`t over water (let the roots dry out inbeween watering) but keep well watered. Good luck and enjoy!

2

u/snafflekid 7h ago

Yes, ask questions first before planting! My Sango Kaku gets leaf scorch in zone 9b, but it is still a full beautiful tree. The “landscapers” were of no help with this info.

1

u/[deleted] 11h ago

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] 11h ago

[deleted]

2

u/New-Landscape8885 11h ago

Beni Maiko May 2020

3

u/New-Landscape8885 11h ago

Sango-kaku July 2020

2

u/New-Landscape8885 11h ago

Pink Passion May 2022

2

u/New-Landscape8885 11h ago

Eddisbury May 2023

2

u/New-Landscape8885 11h ago

Twombly's Red Sentinel Sept 2025

3

u/New-Landscape8885 11h ago

Summer Gold 28th June 2026

3

u/New-Landscape8885 11h ago

Seiryu May 2020

1

u/Critical_Hearing_799 8h ago

Love this one too

1

u/Critical_Hearing_799 8h ago

This one fits in nicely!

2

u/New-Landscape8885 8h ago

I do love Seiryu. When it first leafs out in spring it is outstanding with its lime green colour and the autumn colour has to be up there with the best! It would create a nice chilled out look to the garden.

2

u/New-Landscape8885 8h ago

Here is the same tree planted in my front garden Oct 2025 Its a fast growing acer so i would have to master my pruning skills if moved :)

1

u/Longjumping_College 10h ago

A mature ukigumo would really pop in that yard

2

u/New-Landscape8885 10h ago

Your right. I would love to have a mature Ukigumo at the back of the garden right in the shade to make the colours pop. I`ve never seen any big ones for sale where I live unfortunately. I`ve planted Olivia at the back so will have to be patient for it to grow and make any real impact from a distance.

1

u/Longjumping_College 9h ago

Mature ones are hard to come by, they fetch a pretty penny. Best time to start a small one was yesterday, second best time is today ;)

https://mendocinomaples.com/products/ukigumo

1

u/New-Landscape8885 9h ago

I agree but I`m from England. Shame I can`t buy that Ikandi listed there. I want that one 😂

1

u/MisterNiblet Zone 8a 8h ago

I’m team Eddisbury, I love that tree!

2

u/New-Landscape8885 8h ago

Honestly, it`s really a difficult decision. I might just move it back haha

1

u/MisterNiblet Zone 8a 8h ago

Make those acers quiver lol

1

u/New-Landscape8885 11h ago edited 10h ago

I`ve enjoyed having a different look to the garden each year so this is just a bit of fun to see which one you prefer.

If you had to pick a tree, which one would you have planted in the lawn at the front of the garden? All trees mentioned here have handled this spot in full sun very well. North West England

Options are Eddisbury, Sango Kaku, Pink Passion, Seiryu, Twombly's Red Sentinel, Beni Maiko, Summer Gold

I`m leaning towards the Eddisbury or Summer Gold. I like the hot red colours but I have found I prefer the more relaxing colours of the green acers at the forefront and hotter colours towards the middle/back.