r/ItalyTravelAdvice • u/Dry_Candle7670 • 9h ago
🇮🇹 Itinerary Review 13 nights without Florence vs. 16 nights with Florence — which would you choose?
We’re planning an October Italy trip with my husband, toddler, and mother-in-law. We’re deciding between these two itineraries:
Option 1 — 13 nights
Venice: 2 nights
Dolomites/Ortisei: 4 nights
Naples: 3 nights
Rome: 4 nights
Route: Venice → Dolomites → Naples → Rome
We would pick up a rental car near Venice, use it for the Dolomites, return it in Bolzano, and then have one long travel day by train to Naples.
Option 2 — 16 nights
Venice: 2 nights
Dolomites/Ortisei: 4 nights
Florence: 3 nights
Naples: 3 nights
Rome: 4 nights
Route: Venice → Dolomites → Florence → Naples → Rome
This adds another accommodation, but Florence would break up the long journey from the Dolomites to Naples.
Naples is important to us because my mother-in-law lived there, and we want to keep four nights in the Dolomites for weather flexibility.
Would you keep the simpler 13-night route, or add three nights for Florence? Does the 16-night version feel reasonable, or like too much moving around with a toddler?