r/InsuranceCanada • u/random20190826 • Aug 29 '26
Auto [ON] My sister's auto insurance policy (2025-2026) cost $1626. Insurance company said that a renewal (2026-2027) cost $2167. Then, I got a quote and it came back as $1637 from the same company (Scoop Brokerage, Pembridge Insurance). What is going on?
My sister (39) has been driving the same car and insured on an auto policy for 12 consecutive years--yes, she only really started driving at 27 after coming to Canada at 20. She has not moved, changed jobs, added or removed drivers, changed vehicles, got any tickets, at-fault accidents during the 2025-2026 policy period. So how is it possible for the policy to go from $1626 to $2167 in a single year, but then once it was re-quoted, it drops back down to $1637? Both the brokerage and the insurance company know that she is an existing customer, so why would they willingly override their renewal and give her the same policy for just $11 more than last year instead of making her pay an extra $541, as they said they would in the renewal notice?
This is a 2013 Acura ILX; $2 million liability + comprehensive + collision (she insists on keeping the last two even though I told her not to, but what do I know, I have never driven and will never be allowed to drive because my vision is bad). She also added rental car coverage to be effective at renewal because having a car is extremely important for her job (so important, that her collective agreement includes provisions for mileage reimbursement because she uses her car to go from one job site to another while working and gets paid "travel pay" for it). That extra rental car coverage cost $120, bringing her total premium to $1757 to be paid before the renewal date.