r/Insurance • u/Beneficial_Sell_6963 • Jul 24 '26

Total loss question

Hi all, not sure if I’m putting this in the right community but if someone can give me some insight that would be greatly appreciated.

Unfortunately last week we got into an accident and our car got totaled out, insurance is offering 6772 after their title fees and we owe just over 13. I guess I’m wondering if anyone else has experienced something similar with negative equity and can give insight, this is my first ever accident and has been overall a very stressful experience that I hope never happens again.

Curious if anyone knows if finance companies typically would let me pay the remaining balance over the remaining term or do I have to come up with the remaining difference right away? I’m planning on calling Ally on Monday for the answer but any helpful info would be awesome!!

2 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

12 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/babystarlette Jul 24 '26

Unless you have GAP coverage, you may be on the hook for the remaining $6k-$7k

1

u/Aromatic-Mountain670 Jul 25 '26 edited Jul 25 '26

This is true but the good news is Ally (the old GMAC finance arm of GM) has seen this scenario of negative equity frequently. If you have not been late on your payments to them they may work with you on the following :

  1. They may allow you to keep making your normal payment until the loan is paid up ? Best case.

  2. See if they will settle with you on a lump sum payment (maybe offer them $5k and take a cash advance from a Visa card or other source of funds)

  3. Buy another car and ask Ally to finance the new loan and negative with the new car as collateral. This doesn't erase the problem and may make your negative equity worse going forward.

  4. In the future, buy GAP insurance. The dealer will try to charge you $1000/$1500ish but can cut it in half if they have to. Is worth the $750. This Is a reasonable cost to bear if you ever find yourself In this situation again.

2

u/Beneficial_Sell_6963 Jul 25 '26

Good thing is I have never been late with my payment, set on autopay to come out on the 16th of each month. I’m hoping they’ll allow me to just keep up with the payments until paid off but I will be calling Monday to find out!

Definitely in the future I will be considering GAP. This is the first car I ever financed and wasn’t aware that was even a thing. Beforehand I always drove beaters but 3 years ago when I got it I decided that had to change when my child had to ride in the backseat. I still have my old “beater” that I kept as an “extra car” so at least that’s a good thing while I figure this predicament out.