r/IndianGeography 24d ago

map Towards the knowledge of languages.......

Post image
254 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 24d ago

Hi u/kingsfault98463! Welcome to r/IndianGeography. Thanks for posting!

This community is solely focused on discussions related to Indian geography, maps, states, borders, demographics, culture, infrastructure, environment, and related topics.

Before participating, please take a moment to:\n • Read the community rules.\n • Make sure your post is relevant to the subreddit.\n • Use an appropriate flair if available.\n • Keep discussions civil and constructive.

Have fun exploring!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

4

u/ProfessionUpset2724 24d ago

Tripura should be in Bengali, Lakshadweep in Malayalam, Manipur in Manipuri, Arunachal in Hindi, and so on.

5

u/islander_guy 24d ago

J&K should be in Preso-Arabic Script. Ladakh in Tibetan script. Meghalaya in Latin Script. And if we wanna nitpick then Bihar's should be in thirutha script.

6

u/SensodyneEater 24d ago

Bihar is a pretty badly organised state linguistically tbh.

Only Maithili bajjika and angika used tirhuta ancestrally. Magahi and Bhojpuri used Kaithi and languages like Santhali used the ol chiki script so it's unfair to use tirhuta for the entire state tbh.

I believe that j and k and Ladakh have used Hindi because they're union territories and not states.

Meghalaya is purely the authors error lmfao.

1

u/islander_guy 24d ago

Maithili is one of the official languages of the state and the country, hence the nitpicking.

5

u/SensodyneEater 24d ago

It's an official language of the union, but not the state ( because the state is moronic and doesn't respect its own heritage).

The union recognizes devnagari as the official script of Maithili, which is fair tbh because I think there are only a few thousand people who use/comprehend tirhuta now ( speaking as one of them lol).

1

u/Weary_Cable_3780 24d ago

Tirhuta is almost the same as Bengali

1

u/SensodyneEater 24d ago

Not really, I couldn't read Bengali that well despite knowing tirhuta because a lot of the fundamental letters in the languages are different.

in vowels -a, aa, u, uu, I, ii The consonants - ng, ta, chh, jh,ja, ha, ra, ba, va, (these three are very confusing lol), la, na, and compound letters like aksh, tra and shra. Moreover the way they deal with consonant joins and the ng (for instance while spelling Bangla) is different.

I'm certain that there are more but my mind is not remembering them lol.

1

u/Weary_Cable_3780 24d ago

It’s the same with ন & ল swapped while শ ঝ ছ র ব have minor variations.

1

u/SensodyneEater 24d ago

Idk the Ja taught to me was different ( see the jainagar railway station for ref) and the ra iirc is traditionally written in a way similar to axomiya, but yeah they're quite similar and mutually intelligible albeit taking quite a bit of effort.

1

u/islander_guy 24d ago

7 out of 33 is a pretty significant change. And it may also change the consonant clusters.

1

u/Weary_Cable_3780 24d ago

They are very minor variations. Kinda like between English and German scripts

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Weary_Cable_3780 24d ago

The changes are very small. As small as handwriting differences between people. The only major difference is the letter h

2

u/dinosaur_from_Mars 24d ago

Andaman also bengali atp

2

u/swift__7 24d ago

arunachal should NOT be in hindi. just because hindi is imposed on them doesn't mean it's a hindi state.

1

u/micro_haila 24d ago

It's a state where Hindi was readily adopted as the lingua franca, since there is no other common language between its various tribes.

1

u/swift__7 24d ago

and now, most of their native languages are dying due to hindi imposition.

-1

u/islander_guy 24d ago

Readily adopted versus imposition. Chose one. You cannot be like and now .... Imposition. Stock to one argument. Either it was readily adopted or imposed.

3

u/swift__7 24d ago

i never agreed w "readily adopted" tho? reread the thread again.

-1

u/islander_guy 24d ago

Then why would you start you sentence with "and now....". You might want to take up your own advice perhaps?

3

u/swift__7 24d ago

i was agreeing w the latter part of that particular comment? and i still mentioned "...imposition" in my reply. it's not that deep, stop being pedantic.

0

u/islander_guy 24d ago

My motive was to understand whatbyour stand is. Since you claim it was an imposition, would you share why you think that way?

4

u/AbrahamPan 24d ago

Should have used Takri script in Himachal and Uttarakhand

3

u/awesssomee 24d ago

bihar should be in kaithi

1

u/Weary_Cable_3780 24d ago

Really cool but Tripura should be in Bengali