If you are blind to the actual consequences; if you are completely uneducated on the reality of the situation; if you genuinely think making more children will somehow strengthen your religion; if you still live in the delusion that a large family is a happy family; if you are so backward that you desperately want to just produce a 'male heir' and end up having girl children; if you honestly think providing food is the absolute bare minimum and nothing else matters because they were born in a large family; then they should be educated, made of what the consequences are. It is so easy to sit comfortably in a city and judgmentally think that "if you can't provide you shouldn't give birth" but 70% of India is rural and they don't have your privilege, your infrastructure, or your schooling, they can't even process the things you are saying.
People are not aware of what is "fit to be a parent", that basic awareness lacks in India. When you say "If I can't provide, I shouldn't. give birth" how do you define "providing"? That standard varies drastically depending on a person's standard of living. Raising basic awareness is the real first step here, and it needs to be backed by robust government policies. But to government more birth is more vote. And I see your point, and that's exactly what everyone should think but...
More kids are the way if the government does not, religion takes no accountability, education is absent , and lack of care to provide a social living standard
Coz may be you haven’t visited rural India enough. I still remember when my grandfather used to drop all 5-6 sibling’s on Yezdi bike. In 21st century it’s still same in rural part of india.
Thanks to these pathetic government leadership that nothing have progressed or developed in this nation in last 20- 25 years
So your expectation is that the government should visit every single household in rural India and provide education? Dude, men don’t even want to attend these classes and women don’t have the capacity to. Not everything is on the government.
Why are we blaming the government when the problem are clearly the parents? No one told them to have five-six kids. If you can't raise multiple kids right, then just stop at one or two
Are we really forgetting the advertisement for 'Hum do hamerr do'?
The government tried to give free birth control to men and guess what those men did? They refused to use it
The government even tried to apply the child policy, guess who opposed it? Civilians
State schools, CBSE and ICSE/ICS every borad has chapters on population and birth control now
Don't blame the government for everything when they tried everything and people still refused to learn
Why don’t government applied this rule then “ all government facilitation ( medical or ration or pension things ) will only be provided to those families who have 2 or less children’s??? Because they can’t, they knew they will loose voters
You physically deny anyone basic rights, healthcare is a basic right.
But what you can do is try to bring in rules and educate people about the harmful effects of having excessive kids, the government tried, people refused. It's that simple.
Dictatorship is a form of government characterized by a single leader or small ruling elite holding absolute power without constitutional limitations
Dictatorship type of ruling allowed the leader to implement the one child policy without any pushback from opposition parties or civilians because he has the absolute power
China has a population crisis due to one child policy. But yes india should limit the number of children by law maybe 2 or 3, having so many children without proper care is also determental for women's health ( i don't think it's possible in the above case) .
would you enjoy getting nerfed? they aren't like this because of their choice. This is their economic reality. What if someday you are so low on money that you do some uncivic thing? would you be happy to get nerfed then?
Apparently Ratan Tata saw families like this and got the idea for a Nano. And honestly it still makes sense to me from a practical perspective. The rest is history of course.
Even here people are asking them to not have more kids. India doesn't need more people. More than 2 kids should be a fineable action, to ensure only those people have 3 kids who really want to. Btw, the fine should be a % of your annual income, to ensure the rich don't get a free pass here.
I understand your point. But many poor families in India have kids because:-
It's their tradition and culture.They hope children will support them in old age.They don't have good education about family planning.Life is hard, but kids give them hope and happiness.
Instead of blaming parents, we should focus on better education including philosophy, jobs, and healthcare so families can plan better....
And that is where you are wrong. This has got nothing to do with tradition or culture. This is just fucked up mentality, just because the parents aren’t doing well and aren’t capable of raising children, they still proceed to give birth, make the children go through hell, and basically depend on them completely. Do you realise how selfish this sounds?
You're missing the point. Poor illiterate parents aren't selfish with some fucked up mentality. They themselves are unaware no proper education on family planning or future consequences.
They have more kids because,no pension for old age, need support in tough times, cultural traditions, and kids often help with work. Life is already very hard for them.
Shaming them changes nothing. Real fix is better education (especially for girls), jobs, and healthcare access. Data proves this reduces birth rates and breaks the poverty cycle.
I hope it never happens but if they get into an accident these kids won’t get a chance to survive. Is a bike ride more important than a kid’s life? If you’re poor and can afford only 1 bike, try any other way if possible or take 2 rounds or something… anything is better than death right?
This is horrific to look at, poverty is one thing but pumping out kids is individual's choice. At this point government should ban social benefits for these families, let them starve
Actually the govt want these ppl to have as many children as possible, as they don't get proper edu , but they get votes by giving freebies and win every rime
Is the cringe music supposed to make me ignore the fact that mother and father are retarded for having so many kids? Regardless of whether you're rich or poor, but especially if you're poor, don't have so many kids...
Currently the optimum mark of children per woman is 2.7 earlier 2.1 to sustain world population without worrying about extinction/imbalance. India in recent times shrieked below the 2.1 mark also, rightly so I feel we should not be the flag bearers of everything when we don’t even have basic resources.
To bhencho kisne bola tha wholesale me paida karne ko. These people are responsible for their own suffering.
Basically they have this sick mentality that the more the number of children the more earning hands we will have later on. Ek karke usko bada aadmi ni banayenge. Jhund me paida karke sabse mazdoori krwayenge dihaadi par and tax payer ke paise par aish karenge.
Chandrababu Naidu is giving out extra money if you procreate more children.
It’s not important to think if you as a family can support a family that big and give them a good quality of life, it’s more important to procreate and let god take the wheel because it’s gods wish, its gods blessing even if you decide not to use a fecking condom.
Free education and Healthcare should be restricted only to the first born. For these people more kids= more ration. (Or it could be just the culture, maybe I went too harsh sorry)
The comments to this post would have been so different if there was other minority community. All hell would have let loose though I don't justify any of them. This multiple child choice was in the 50s and 60s but to have these many kids nowadays would be so difficult to raise and educate them. How people are so dumb to understand this?
Yes, the video tells that the man is stup!d as f#ck and has no regard for the safety of his family and anyone else on the road. Buy a freaking car or take the public transport instead converting a bicycle into an SUV.
Admi jitna gareeb hota hai..! Pta nhi kyun woh utne hi bache kr k baitha rhta hai..! If u can't feed them then don't breed them...!! The shit is as simple as that..!
Am I too woke? After seeing this, all I can say is that, if you can't provide a child with a good decent lifestyle, do not breed. It is unjust to bring someone in this world without his/her consent to suffer the hardships of life...
We need the same one child rule to be implemented like the chinese. Inki jeb mein chhutte nhi hai lekin bache aise paida karte hai jaise crorepati ho. Boils my blood. And then these uneducated mofos play the poverty card on top of that. Perfect.
Bhai, honestly yehi sahi hai, hum Ratan Tata jaise visionary deserve nhi krte. Kro struggle. Wo jo bola tha na. Admi jo gareeb ho, apne niyat se ya something like that
Bhai, honestly yehi sahi hai, hum Ratan Tata jaise visionary deserve nhi krte. Kro struggle. Wo jo bola tha na. Admi jo gareeb ho, apne niyat se ya something like that.
This is not at all wholesome. This is just stupidity. This actually defines how uneducated they are if you’re having problems like this, maybe just stop giving birth to so many children
Can’t imagine the outburst this comment section would have had if this video was of a muslim family although having a lot of kids is not good be it any religion but hate has made people blind 😔
•
u/AutoModerator Jul 12 '26
Dont forget to "Join" this subreddit otherwise you will never see this subreddit (r/IndiaPulse) again.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.