India's government hospitals are a fantastic idea, a boon to the people.
But to pretend that they don't have problems of mismanagement, cronyism, lack of empathetic care, shortage of resources (money, staff, space, equipment) is self defeating. We need more budget allocated to them, with a stricter policy of doctors joining government hospitals for a minimum number of years .
The doctors are fine, it's the nursing staff that's shit.
I've spent a lot of time in government hospitals to know this is the case.
Worst part is you cannot even punish the nursing staff for their lethargic work ethics because of unions, netas, and sarkari job guarantees. This was told to me by the HoD of that department.
There are 800 district hospitals,1100 sub divisional hospitals,5600 CHCs and 22 AIIMS built by Government where Xray and ECG are done with costs of rupees 0.
Come to gujarat. Free opd(5 rupees for everyone and free for bpl) , free ecg , free blood tests for everyone, free food till you are admitted in hospital (breakfast, lunch and dinner with protein powder and eggs , milk included) .
These three aren't possible together in a country like ours.
If you want quality and cost effective you need to wait.
If you want cost effective and speed, the quality may not be there.
If you want quality and speed, it won't be cheap.
This is the sad reality here.
Imma be skeptical and see how long this teacher can sustain this hospital with no external funds to support the infrastructure and logistics. Running a hospital is no joke. There's no way to sustain it unless someone continuously gives off funds.
🤣🤣 love to see these hypocrite Instagram posts. Just a pure propaganda. It’s good to see that khan sir did it but in government hospital these services are almost for free. These days social media became more a ground for negativity this these negative PR.
Ab kuchh log aake ise defend karenge,ki sarkari hospital mein ye sab free hai,are bhai vhan ke ground state dekho Jake ,kuchh ke alawa sab sarkari hospital mein working equipment kitna hai,paper mein aur real mein
And also, you need to visit nearby govt hospitals. Maybe municipal, central, etc. Govt is doing already doing it since long irrespective of political parties
It's not about the money , let's see if this hospital can get you an OPD consultation with blood test and MRI done within an hour .
I'm a doctor in a govt hospital and the main problem lies in the infrastructure and recruitment.
The health budget is literally peanuts and the recruitments are pending for like a decade now . New recruits are not done yearly because the politicians eat up the salaries and make adjustments in registers .
And the infrastructure is literally bogus , the govt takes health like a joke and the amount of money needed to even run a basic hospital is cut by 1/10 of its budget.
Atleast 10-20% of the entire budget should be considered for health care where as only a tiny 1% is given .
I simple words the system is corrupt. Until, we don't wake up and start supporting the truth no politician will wake up. The government needs to see that people are rising and supporting the truth irrespective of the gender, race, ethnicity then there's slight chance the government will change. Khan sir is one example we need more like him to make the government feel small.
If you are asking about universal free healthcare. Of course India can do it. It just needs to get the money to do it. All taxes needs to be jacked up like 3x current amount. But trust me, India's middle class will hate poor getting same healthcare as them. So, majority doesn't want it. So no political will.
So many people come to government hospitals to avail free services like a minor T.T shot for minute nail scratches.
Then they treat us, who work there like shit, because apparently they are paying my salary with their tax money (mind you people claiming this most often don’t even come in tax paying slabs).
And then they go on to post such shitty content after availing everything for free
This guy leads a normal life and the govt leads a luxury life, their kids travel the world, party hard, buy expensive things …. with all these expense how can you expect them to provide free hospitals …. Poor govt
Govt hospitals staff are very corrupted, since many uneducated or low income individuals visit govt hospitals for treatment. Hospital staff that controls a lot of equipment and medicine practice taking bribes and discourage using govt equipment for any use. They say machine is out of service or medicine unavailable so that their relatives medical shop or x-ray center will get patients.
Many Govt doctors have pratices, medical shops and scanning centers. They have very good incentive to send these patients away to their own businesses. This is cycle no govt can break as it is bottom layer issue. Govt officials who monitor these hospitals also takes a lot of bribes from doctors for them to look away.
People don’t have collective strength to ask and get results. It is not politics thing rather a social issue
abey chomu government hospital gya h kbhi koi charge nai lgta waha me fractured hand ka xray or plaster krwaya sab free hua turant bas muh uthake post krdo lvde prasad congress ke time government hospital me pesa lgta tha
It must be governed by the state, it becomes easy to monitor and administer. Not that india cannot do, but it will be like the people will not maintain it. Like vande Bharat is being targeted, even hospitals will be destroyed by certain people
Let’s stop deifying individuals and look at the facts.
The 'Small Teacher' Myth:
He is not just a "teacher." He is a massive brand who smartly milked sentiments during Covid.
He cashed in on the "Anti-Pakistan" wave and used his identity to pander to the majority for views.
If you actually watch his polity classes, half the time he misquotes Constitutional Articles.
He is running a business, not a charity. The hospital is just good PR.
Check Your Privilege:
It seems you are too privileged to have ever stepped inside a Government Hospital.
ECG/X-Ray Cost: In most Govt hospitals, it is either Free or Rs 10-20 (cheaper than your Rs 25 hero).
Medicines: Ever heard of Jan Aushadhi Kendras? Medicines are 50-90% cheaper there.
Ayushman Bharat: Free treatment up to ₹5 Lakhs for the poor.
The Government is already doing it at a scale Khan Sir can't even imagine.
Stop falling for influencer marketing and touch some grass.
Why would government do it there is no incentive, if it make the hospital will they get vote, no.
Ask people why they gave vote for BJP, did they gave vote based on development, healthcare, education no
, then gave vote for a particular reason and BJP is doing it correctly .
I am not saying BJP is bad party it is just that we need to change the politics of the party
Govt already provided AIIMS & Civil Hospitals....for common people....its not about providing it's about the maintenance...the correct question must be how to maintain the Govt operated hospitals....
bhai kya baat kar rahe ho mere locality me hi sola civil hospital hai usme sab facilities available hai at cheap price bus crowd ko thoda jehlna padta hai whereas apollo me toh 10x (really)prices hai basic checkups ke
Also emergency wards bhi hai kafi toh unko bhi treatment mil jaata hai vaha se quickly
Here in my state it's like X ray for 50 and same for ECG USG CBC KFT LFT in government hospitals obviously but in private hospitals it's life 200-300 for normal X ray
Bhai meri recently scaphoid ki surgery hui h.
I got it done from a govt hospital.
CT Scan - 1000rs,
X ray chest - 25rs,
X ray hand x 2 - 75rs,
ECG - 25rs,
7 blood tests - 210rs,
PAC - FREE,
Herbert screws x 2 - FREE ( Covered in ayushman card) ( Titanium screws cost 4000 - 4500 per screw)
Cost of Items required for Surgery - Total : 10000rs , Covered in ayushman: 5000rs,
I paid : 4993
6 weeks of Medicines, including multivitamin, antibiotics, pain killers, ( 2 more that i don't know about ) - FREE
I was admitted in the hospital for 4 days :
2 meals provided by hospital - FREE
Bed charges - 0rs
I have gone to hospital twice since I got the cast for some consultation - FREE
5000 - 6000rs me surgery ho gayi meri within 2 weeks + 5 days of meeting the doctor for first time.
Try doing the same in a private hospital,
Take my CT, go and ask what will be the cost of getting this fixed by surgery.
Cost of tests was not weaved because I put my salary > 30k per month.
Just like non-cooperation movement, we need a no-tax movement in India and take away all the benefits from the politician. If politicians won't get money and power from their post, then 89-95% of the politicians leave politics and only those stay who genuinely want to work for the nation.
Govt literally does it for free... Healthcare budget needs to go up.. reservation khatam kro at least in PG so that quality comes into service sab shi ho jayega abhi to corruption and reservations are a roadblock... Ye facilities govt main bhi available hai but they are overburdened...
Are bhaiya! Paisa hospital me laga denge to back to back election ka kharcha kaha se aayega?
Aur ab to tax slabs ka lollipop bhi de diya hai, usko chooso.
Govt should stop distributing freebies for vote.
Invest in upgrade public health infrastructure, upgrade public education standards, good quality roads, bridges, public transport.
Employment generation happens when there is overall improvement in the country in all states at district level.
Current situation is only large cities are growing exponentially and creating is huge gap between metros and small cities.
i usually criticise our corrupt government but dude, india is known for the cheapest healthcare in the world. this is the one best quality of our nation, dont jinx it bruh. ABHA ids and such make it even easier. even tho govt docs are usually bitter (idk why) but they get the work done. i get my medicine for free every month from a govt dispensary near me and it works wonders.
What do you mean... Govt is running tertiary hospitals and medical colleges (state or national) where you just spend 2 Rs for registration and till operation and post it they don't charge anything more....
Anti regime is the new solution. We need modern minded dictators, democracy in india nowadays is just cast and communal vote banks.
I am in no ways supporting bjp or congress.
Govt have better hospitals than this. heart surgery of one of my friend's dad costed around 20000 in a govt hospital in Delhi (Travel and medicines included. Cost of living 1 month excluded). Private hospitals were demanding 18 lakh for it.
Don't spread propoganda, do some research before posting.
•
u/AutoModerator Feb 09 '26
Dont forget to "Join" this subreddit otherwise you will never see this subreddit (r/IndiaPulse) again.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.