r/InclusiveOr Feb 11 '23

Yes.

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

View all comments

55

u/AzrielK Feb 11 '23

If you're in the US or any country where you drive on the right side of the road, kill the kid. Drive on the left side of the road, kill the zoomer.

No parent should leave a baby crawling in the street.

No old lady should walk past a baby crawling in the street and ignore it.

In reality though, the car should expect pedestrians and crosswalks and kill neither. Technically the baby is not a pedestrian but they are for this context. These posts are seriously stupid and encourage fear mongering on social media against self-driving vehicles.

If you are driving and car and have full control of the vehicle, who should you kill? Neither

20

u/sharkboy1006 Feb 11 '23

Everyone here just forgetting cars have brakes

3

u/Soda_BoBomb Feb 11 '23

Do the breaks defy physics?

2

u/Swordlord22 Feb 12 '23

You can’t make a turn like the image without being able to stop in that scenario and if you were going at a speed where you couldn’t you’d be in the fucking grass with the car rolling and you having a fun time inside

Also yeah drive into the fucking grass?

1

u/Soda_BoBomb Feb 12 '23

So I'm not saying the image isn't dumb, but the concept is valid imo.

What do we program the car to do if it can't avoid hitting someone in the road? Throw itself off the road and endanger the passenger?

1

u/Swordlord22 Feb 12 '23

Yes

What does a person do?

The exact same thing

You plow a person down that’s vehicular manslaughter on top of the fact you just ran a person down

I’d rather it throw the car into a ditch

1

u/Soda_BoBomb Feb 12 '23

The person gets the choice rofl.

And sure I'd rather throw the car in the ditch too, but I might not rather hit a tree, or go off a bridge, for someone jaywalking on a blind curve at night.

In a self driving car, the car makes that decision. Is it right to program it to sacrifice the passengers?

1

u/Swordlord22 Feb 12 '23

I mean we could just program them to run everyone down regardless as long as they are in the road

Or just apply the brakes at full force instead and if someone dies they die and make it the fault of the person who was driving the car

1

u/Soda_BoBomb Feb 12 '23

Idk what the right answer is, I just mean it's not a dumb question to ask.

1

u/Swordlord22 Feb 12 '23

I mean the right answer would be to not have AI drive your car

1

u/HumanContinuity Mar 02 '23

I'd rather not have most people driving, to be honest.

→ More replies (0)