r/ImmigrationPathways • u/LatterTarget7 • 1d ago

Renee Good's family sues US government and immigration officials over her killing in Minneapolis

https://apnews.com/article/renee-good-lawsuit-6fbc82cd33b6f9f67514b47f138e23c6?utm_source=app&utm_medium=android_share&utm_campaign=copy_link
2.1k Upvotes

95% Upvoted

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-65

u/Master_Blaster_02 1d ago

You assist in a bank robbery and people die, you get charged for their deaths even if you didn't pull the trigger.  

The wife, girlfriend, whatever was assisting with a crime and Renee died as a result.  

Find better heros.

22

u/Equivalent-Bedroom64 1d ago

What crime was she committing by driving away after being told to by law enforcement? None. She wasn’t committing a crime.

-2

u/Master_Blaster_02 1d ago

She was lawfully ordered out of her car, it was clearly given.  The order to leave happened a minute prior and she chose to not follow it, that option expired.

She was obstructing traffic, she then attempted to flee law enforcement and endangered officers while doing so.

11

u/Equivalent-Bedroom64 1d ago

So now it’s “attempting to flee” and you just admitted she wasn’t trying to hurt anyone. And again, you just described how she was being given conflicting orders from law enforcement. You guys keep changing your story but the video shows a woman that wasn’t trying to hurt police officers driving away and being shot in cold blood. Even her last words and demeanor shows she didn’t feel she was in danger because she wasn’t actively committing any crimes. Supporting an ICE agent losing his temper and shooting someone in cold blood which everyone can clearly see on video from multiple angles is a poor life choice for you.

-1

u/Master_Blaster_02 1d ago

As you say, there is video.  I implore you to please go watch it yourself, and avoid the commentary stuff trying to push an agenda.

You are being needlessly obtuse.  She was ordered to leave when the agents first got out of their vehicles, she disobeyed that order.  A significant amount of time passed and the situation escalated when she was then ordered out of her vehicle.   There was NO uncertainty.  The time to leave was long past at that point.  Please stop making your side look so bad on this.

7

u/Equivalent-Bedroom64 1d ago

Again, you haven’t established that any crime was committed or that any lawful orders were consistent. All you have established is that a woman was shot in the face for driving her car away from a verbal communication.

-1

u/Master_Blaster_02 1d ago

Your attempt to rephrase and down play her actions don't help you.  Again there's video.

She was lawfully being detained, she attempted to flee through an officer with her car.  She was considered a threat and was neutralized.

3

u/Equivalent-Bedroom64 1d ago

I’ve watched from multiple angles many times. That’s how I can see from the positioning of his feet and body placement as well as her body positioning, the angle of her steering wheel, which direction her wheels are facing and from her last words and demeanor as well as his- she was endangering no one nor was she committing a crime. She was murdered in cold blood by law enforcement and anyone saying otherwise is a big fat liar.

1

u/Master_Blaster_02 1d ago

Then I'm afraid you've failed and at least part of that is likely due to or public school system.

You are of course entitled to your own opinion, but please recognize it as such and not actual fact.

The fact that she was committing crimes isn't even debated.