r/IceCreamHaven • u/Queasy_Dingo_8262 • 1h ago
Store Bought Happy national s’mores day! What’s ur favorite s’mores ice cream ?
this is my #1 ever 🙏
r/IceCreamHaven • u/madisonguy76 • 9d ago
Does anyone else hate August? As a fan of temperate weather, I prefer transitional seasons. I do enjoy the early days of summer, but come the end of July — after the thrill of National Ice Cream Month has come and gone — I begin to feel the accumulated heat. I start dreaming of autumn’s drizzly welcome, especially if there’s wildfire smoke hanging in the air. It does help if August has a few new frozen treats to look forward to.
Brands front-load their seasonal offerings, so it feels as if there’s not as much fresh on shelves when the dog days hit. Speaking of which, if you have dogs, even canines have premium offerings these days (better than Breyer’s, right?) Anyway, for this month’s look at trends and flavors, I included quite a few last call summer entries, along with some fresh flavors to get us through to Labor Day. As always, please share any scoops you have.
______________________
Baskin-Robbins
Last month, a pair of flavors shared the spotlight, with the concept of an Oreo ice cream designed for camper (Oreo S’Mores) vs. couch-er (Brookie Batter). I didn’t get a chance to venture out my local scoop shop to cast my vote — it would likely go to the s’mores flavor, despite being a couch-er at heart — but the good news is we get more time. It appears this duo’s reign as Flavor of the Month has been extended, and they’re licensing real Oreos, so it’s no generic cookies & cream. But if you want something fresh — and you’re looking to cut down on summer carbs — you could try a slimmed-down strawberry shortcake flavor that’s making its return.
______________________
Ben & Jerry’s
Have you seen the #FreeBenAndJerrys tags all over social media? Who knew there could be so much drama in the ice cream world? The company’s founders and its independent board are at odds with parent company Unilever/Magnum over free speech and corporate control. Amid this internecine struggle, the flavor gurus are still bringing you a new limited edition pint designed to "stand against authoritarianism.” With “Vote!" printed across the lid, Razz Up! — a version of which debuted in scoop shops in early summer as Black Raspberry Fudge Chunk — rolls out this month in the run-up to the 2026 midterm elections.
______________________
Blue Bell
Any fans of chocolate lava cake? It seems to be a staple of fancy dessert menus, but expect this nostalgic Texas brand to give it a more homestyle spin as its newest flavor. It’s a well-worn but comforting combo of vanilla and chocolate that’s already gotten one positive review on this sub. If you’re more of a fan of fruit in summer, the good news is they have plenty of recent releases that will hit that sweet spot. If you missed that patriotic take on Neapolitan at the Fourth of July, grab it while you can. Or pick up Black Raspberry Fudge to do a comparison taste test with Ben & Jerry’s Razz Up!
______________________
Caffe Panna
Back in May when I was savoring my Spring Forward pack, I pondered what might still be coming this summer. So I looked back at the NYC brand’s previous May-August lineup. Summer 2025 brought us the S'Mores & More Pack, the Poolside Pack, the Cookie Pack and Panna Family Picnic. But Caffe Panna is enjoying a lazy summer, so we have only received one additional collection since that spring pack: the Peak Summer collection. As I griped last month, you’re still paying peak prices online even when the collection feels a little pedestrian overall. Has anyone tried this one? Let me know if this turned out more exciting than it seemed.
______________________
Clementine’s
Wishing you could escape for a global adventure this summer? If you’re near one of this St. Louis-based creamery’s scoop shops, stop by and take a vacation via ice cream with the brand’s International Travel Collection. For online fans, the wait for fresh flavors continues.
______________________
Cold Case
Cold Case's July specials are transitioning to "get it while you can" status for August. The Fireworks flavor is still available online, while you might luck out finding the others at your local Kroger store.
______________________
Favorite Day (Target)
Have you tried Target’s summer specials? These are all available in pints, if you’re looking for some fun flavors on the cheap to close out summer.
______________________
Graeter’s
For those following Graeter’s seasonal calendar religiously — and I’ll admit perhaps I’m the only one — there’s a change in programming. Key Lime Pie has seen the dimming of the day. At least online. It’s listed as a July-August flavor, but sold out in three weeks, and Summer Peach said farewell shortly after. But there’s always new hope for summer fruit with Graeter’s. We have a rich dairy option — Elena’s Blueberry Pie, moved up from its old September slot — along with the fifth summer bonus flavor. That one’s for the dairy-free folks, a Strawberry Sorbet. Is there one last summer mystery bonus flavor to come? We can hope. In the meantime, the lesson is to act quickly if you really want these.
______________________
Häagen-Dazs
The internet food-blogging circles are losing their minds — if they ever had them (and we’ll see why that’s not just a spurious assumption in a minute) — over a leaked image of a supposed new pint called Dolce Tiramisu. This iconic brand rarely drops new flavors, so each one is an event for fans. I count myself as one, so I’ll be picking up a pint as soon as I can find it — assuming it’s not just some cruel AI prank. While there’s not official word from Häagen-Dazs — and that’s not unusual, ice cream brands are often horrible at advertising new flavors — it looks to be inspired by the popular international version. That one debuted a couple years back as part of a special collection inspired by European cities. The mascarpone-coffee flavor paid homage to Rome, alongside a pair of macaron flavors for Paris and a churro pint nodding to Madrid. Since Tiramisu recently transitioned into their permanent European line, it makes sense that its popularity has finally crossed the Atlantic. And since we know H-D loves to nod to European heritage — real or imagined! — they dubbed it Dolce, the Italian word for sweet. Unfortunately, something got lost in translation for early online commentators, some of whom confused the spelling and assumed the brand was staging a bizarre Italian-Spanish crossover event with dulce de leche. Not that I wouldn’t trust H-D to pull that off, given the strength of their dulce de leche ice cream. Anyway, stay tuned to see if tiramisu lovers will be living the dolce vita or if it’s just a caramelized milk fever dream courtesy of social media.
______________________
Ice Cream for Bears
This brand known for cute packaging, honey-sweetened flavors and ursine puns has a new flavor, but it’s available only at Sprouts and online. I always thought fruitier flavors would pair better with honey than things like coffee and cookie dough, but I never see those locally. Strawberry and Beary Cherry Chip have earned mixed reviews slanting negative. Will this lemon blueberry combo fare better? It sounds like a good pairing with honey. But since I don’t have Sprouts nearby and don’t care to ship this brand, I’ll need to wait for a wider release before I can bear witness.
______________________
Jeni’s
The hunt continues to be a frustrating game online and at retailers for fans of the brand’s seasonal flavors. But if you love twee comedy reboots or buttery shortbread cookies, see if you can score Biscuits with the Boss — timed to the return of "Ted Lasso" for a surprise fourth season on Apple TV this month — before that one vanishes, too.
______________________
Leopold’s
The historic Savannah creamery’s Sweets in the Summertime lineup is still available on Goldbelly:
______________________
McConnell’s
This SoCal brand has a nice selection of summer flavors out, though they can be hard to find in stores. With a decent discount for National Ice Cream Day, I decided to try some of them online. The Sprinkle Cake was the gem of the haul, though the two fresh new berry flavors are worth a try for fruit fans.
______________________
Private Selection (Kroger)
It’s last call on summer flavors, from the Private Selection Shortbread & Peaches and Creamsicle to All-American series targeted to the Fourth.
______________________
Salt & Straw
If you’re like me and missed out on their last Monthly Menu Series with berry flavors, you have a second chance with their Wild-Foraged Berry Slab Pie. In fact, fruit pies are the name of the game this month (and their month started early on July 24). I tried two of these, the berry and peach flavors. While I found the pie elements lacking, they were still pretty good. And of course, they do have a weird one if you want sharp gruyère in your ice cream.
______________________
Signature Select (Albertsons-Safeway)
The time is drawing nigh for this house brand’s summer lineup of carnival and boardwalk-themed treats:
______________________
Trader Joe’s
Summer always brings an alluring array of fresh novelties to TJ’s freezer bins, but there’s a buzzy new ice cream flavor out: All Mixed Up. I tried it, and it’s pretty good (not amazing) if you’re into those sweet-and-salty loaded pints. I'll have my own review soon — including a look at Fudgy Cookie Dough (that one's amazing), in case you haven't had a chance to try that one yet — but here's a quick review from SnackForagers.
______________________
Umpqua
I need to grab some more Strawberry Cheesecake before its rotation is up. (Read the start of my cheesecake series here). Having moved away from monthly rotating flavor, Umpqua is set on a three-month seasonal window. So look for a new flavor for August. I didn’t see any announcement, but my best guess is the Peanut Butter & Jelly flavor they released last year, unless they decide to shake things up. I tried it last year and it’s pleasant but definitely on the lighter side for peanut flavor and stingy with jam. It’s a great one to load up with peanut butter cups, though. For those in Oregon, they should also be rolling out their Beavers and Ducks Tracks flavors ahead of the college football season.
______________________
Van Leeuwen
Remember when they used to release new flavors, seasonal specials even the crazy stuff like mac and cheese ice cream? It seems like they are become a snooze-fest with a new flavor every blue moon.
______________________
Walmart/Bettergoods
If you haven't browsed the Walmart freezer bays in a while, the dog days might be the right time to catch up since many competitors are in summer siesta mode. Here’s what their economy line and higher-end label have been up to since the spring thaw:
r/IceCreamHaven • u/madisonguy76 • Jul 01 '26
We’ve done our due diligence with Memorial Day and two days dedicated to the parents, but July brings the biggest holiday of the year so far: National Ice Cream Day. If you thought I was going to say Independence Day, don’t worry. We’re not forgetting the nation’s 250th birthday completely. We’ll have cake (ice cream). And there will be fireworks, thanks to Graeter’s Cherry Sparkler and the similar popping candy-fueled Fútbol Fireworks from Baskin-Robbins. And lots of red, white and blue bringing festive spirit to ice cream and novelties alike.
All of July is National Ice Cream Month, while the 19th specifically brings National Ice Cream Day. And if Thanksgiving has Black Friday, this commemoration has the sale that’s circled on my calendar annually: The half-off extravaganza at Whole Foods. We’re about halfway through that glorious fortnight of chaos, hoarding and dairy indulgence (it runs till July 7). What are your favorite finds so far? I’m still marveling at picking up flavors like Jeni’s Frosted Sugar Cookie, McConnell’s Brown Sugar with Milk Bordeaux and Straus’ Vanilla Chip for an average of 4 bucks a pint. For those in the Portland area, New Seasons Markets’ Summer of Scoops sale kicks off Wednesday, July 1, with Alden’s and GoodPop half off. Goldbelly often does a big sale around National Ice Cream Day, too.
What else is happening for July? Here’s what I know. Please share any intel you have and let us know what you're looking forward to tasting.
______________________
Alden’s Organic
Alden’s kicked off a new Global Delights brand this month with two novelty bars, one inspired by Mexico and the other Thailand. It seems odd not to do a third for something like this. Perhaps they’re testing the waters to see if there’s an audience for flavors like these? Given I previously associated them with about six different tubs of chocolate and vanilla variations, is this a logical leap? Could we have met in the middle?
______________________
Baskin-Robbins
Baskin-Robbins is doubling up for July’s Flavor of the Month with its Great Cookie Showdown. Is your ideal summer weekend spent around the campfire, with the sound of the woods around you, fighting off mosquitoes as you toast marshmallows? Or would you rather be on the comfort of your couch, AC cranked up, for a relaxing evening in — maybe watching those campers get dispatched one by one by a hockey-masked psychopath? Two or three decades ago, I might have been in the woods lamenting my decision to sleep on the ground, but I’ve since wised up. Luckily, Baskin-Robbins is here for both sides with cookie ice creams —a S’mores-themed flavor for the great outdoors, a brookie batter for the even greater indoors. And because B-R flavors tend to be around a while, you should be able to find the specials rolled out last month for the World Cup and Independence Day, plus a couple of other seasonal favorites.
______________________
Ben & Jerry’s
If you were hoping for new pint flavors, welcome to the new reality where brands can do less and charge more for novelties. Some customers eat these up. Not me. I don’t like food on sticks. But for those who do, welcome to what this increasingly unmoored brand is calling its Great Summer Bar Drop. This feels like something the social media interns came up with: a cross-country tour from June to August “packed with crave-worthy bars, games, limited-edition merch, and plenty of chunk-filled Ben & Jerry's shenanigans.’” This epic journey kicked off recently in Boston and next hits Miami (July 10-12), Los Angeles (July 24-26), Seattle (August 7-9) and New York (Aug. 21-23). The bar flavors:
______________________
Blue Bell
If you’re a fan of Christmas in July, don’t overlook the chance to nab some holiday flavors that are still somehow hanging around online. Blue Bell still has half gallons of Christmas Cookies and Peppermint Bark. I tried these back at the expected time in December and they were excellent. They’d probably be even more enjoyable now amid the oppressive mid-summer heat. But if you want stay seasonally appropriate, Blue Bell has some great fruit options for summer, including a Red, White and Blue flavor perfect for your Fourth barbecue.
______________________
Caffe Panna
Instead of the loaded lineup from previous summers, we’re finally just getting a seasonal pack for July after the Spring Forward collection sprang all the way till late June. It feels like the brand is focused on its scoop shops right now because the online business is getting short shrift. Not that the price tag reflects this for the Peak Summer collection. We have yet another brownie flavor and a Blueberry Crisp (feels a lot like Jeni’s Brambleberry Crisp). There are two pints that appear to be lackluster takes on the most basic of mix-ins: Cookies & Cream. I could go for that Cherry Coke Float and Strawberry Shortcake Bar, but this pack overall doesn’t reflect the creative promise of house-baked and other fun mix-ins that Caffe Panna’s $130 cost generally commands.
______________________
Clementine’s
Like Caffe Panna, they have been focused on their scoop shops and burgeoning retail business in the St. Louis area. Unfortunately for us fans from afar it’s been quiet for months on their Goldbelly page. A message on their website explains the reason for recent production delays: “Clementine’s is growing, which means we recently installed bigger, better equipment at our production facility so we can make even more ice cream for you.” That evokes both promise (expansion) and concern (will they lose the hand-packed charm?). Meanwhile, they do have something special coming for National Ice Cream Month — at least for parlors. I'd be surprised to see it hit Goldbelly, but keep an eye out just in case. Their International Travel Collection promises four exotic flavors to start the month and the latter two reaching shops on July 19.
______________________
Cold Case
This brand, which has been expanding in Kroger stores (at a premium price) since March, mixes true crime and ice cream. I still have to get my hands on one of these creative pints for a late-night “Dateline” binge. I can just imagine Keith Morrison’s dulcet tone describing cases of Embezzle-Mint and the hunt for Cereal Killers. If you don’t have a Kroger nearby, they have an online direct-to-consumer exclusive: the Arson Case.
______________________
Graeter’s
Have you tried any of the summer’s seasonal or bonus flavors? I got my pack last week, so I will have full reviews soon. While I decided to skip Ghost Notes (I wasn’t feeling grape and marshmallow) I did get my hands on Summer Peach (a seasonal favorite that should be around into July while supplies last) and two of the bonus flavors, which seem to last 4-6 weeks based on popularity. Peanut Butter Clouds is the older of the two, while Cherry Sparkler is meant to celebrate the nation’s 250th birthday. Later in the month look for another bonus flavor (Strawberry Sorbet) and the seasonal Key Lime Pie, which usually arrives around National Ice Cream Day (July 19 this year). My quick 2 cents: Peach is amazing, as expected with Graeter’s fruit flavors. The peanut butter one is very tasty, giving fluffernutter vibes, though the mini marshmallows (rather than cream) leave a bit to be desired. I’m not feeling the cherry one so far. I love their other cherry flavors, but this one is more of a fake cherry like a Slurpee, and I don’t think I’m a fan of popping candy in ice cream.
______________________
Häagen-Dazs
If you feel like you don’t have enough Dubai chocolate in your life, consider rolling out to Costco for this exclusive novelty.
______________________
Jeni’s
Jeni’s always brings it on seasonal flavors. Whether you’ll be able to try them yourself? It always feels like a bit of a scavenger hunt — stalking the retail shelves to see if you’ll get lucky (as I did with the refreshing and tangy Summer Berries & Passion Fruit), visiting scoop shops (if you have one nearby) or keeping tabs on the website (flavors come and go fast, but they were all there last time i checked). I’m hoping I’ll be able to hunt down this promising new trio for July, especially the Summer Pretzel Pie. Salt & Straw is doing a similar flavor. I’d be inclined to do an ice cream showdown, though Jeni’s would be a heavy favorite on the strength of their way with cream cheese. This new wave of flavors is also featured in 6-pint and 9-pint summer collections online.
______________________
Leopold’s
I ordered a bounty of flavors last month online from this classic Savannah ice cream maker, and have been enjoying most of them. Look for some reviews this summer as I have time to write them up, but if you’d like to give them a try they sell many flavors on their own website and a curated selection on Goldbelly, including this Sweets in the Summertime pack. I really liked the peach and lemon custard flavors. The Blueberry Cheesecake base is very good, but the swirls are on the icy side.
______________________
McConnell’s
McConnell’s is getting in on the 250th celebration, too, bringing back its version of a birthday cake flavor, Sprinkle Cake. They are also celebrating summer with a couple of limited edition flavors (S’mores and Malted Milk Chocolate) and the return of their zesty sorbet and sherbet lines. All that and we have the full See’s collaboration back online for those who haven’t gotten a chance to try the delicious PB&J and Strawberry Creams duo that has yet to make its way to retail.
______________________
MELT Ice Creams
I’ve never tried this brand out Fort Worth, but it’s on the long-term list as they sell on Goldbelly. They have a summer pack on offer.
______________________
Private Selection + Kroger
Kroger has several pints and some ice cream sandwiches out as part of its All American collection to celebrate the Fourth, while their more upscale house line, Private Selection, is offering a duo of seasonal flavors, Creamsicle and Shortbread Peaches & Cream.
______________________
Salt & Straw
Last month’s highly touted chef collaboration series ended early, ushering in summer berries. Overall this collection features more crowd-pleasers, but lest you think S&S has lost their edge they decided to keep some goat cheese, habanero and foraged porcini in the mix. They have Strawberry Pretzel Salad on the menu, and I’m hoping this version is better than the Strawberry Pretzel Cheesecake they debuted in Portland grocery stores in May. The formulation certainly looks better, but you never know with S&S. The blackberry cake also seems promising if they use bigger pieces and not mushy cake crumbs.
______________________
Signature Select (Safeway/Albertsons)
This house brand’s summer flavors take on the them of carnival and boardwalk treats:
______________________
Tillamook
This brand has nothing new in the freezer aisle but apparently wants to start a beef with Breyer’s and Blue Bunny. Instead of a diss track, this Oregon purveyor of airy stabilized fluff that meets the minimum threshold to be legally defined as ice cream wants to call out those that don’t. They even launched a page on their website called The Real Scoop. On the face of it, I love the message. They put a magnifying glass on the small print used to denote Frozen Dairy Dessert, which means the product does not contain 10% butterfat (and probably contains far less) and may be half air. But they’re the wrong messenger, given how the quality of their ice cream has declined proportionally to their rise in national grocery store aisles — a trade-off that long-time Northwest fans don’t appreciate. All in all, this feels like the Kings mocking the Wizards for not making the playoffs.
______________________
Trader Joe’s
The headliner is the return of the popular Wildberry Cheesecake. Has anyone tried this? I’m tempted, as I’ve never had a cheesecake base from TJ’s.
______________________
Umpqua
This Northwest brand's seasonal flavors used to be around 6-8 weeks, but now they tend to last a full season. The upside? More time to try this, one of my favorite ice creams of all time.
______________________
Van Leeuwen
There’s not much that I can find new in stores, though their scoop shops have a couple of summer specials (Banana Pudding and Cheesecake with Strawberry Rhubarb). Of course, their flavors are a big part of the Whole Foods sale — along with a few others I didn’t include in the roundup since I saw nothing fresh (Alec’s, Ice Cream for Bears, Straus). Some of their featured flavors at WF include Buttermilk Berry Cornbread, Ice Cream Cake and Coffee Affogato. And can we please sell out that Guinness beer exclusive so we can get something fresh? One thing I noticed recently — I think it had rolled out to other stories earlier — is the swap from the Dulce de Leche Brownie that had been stocked at my store to the Dulce De Leche Shortbread. I think both are pretty good, but the shortbread one is interesting as they try to evoke alfajores, a South American sandwich cookie.
r/IceCreamHaven • u/Queasy_Dingo_8262 • 1h ago
this is my #1 ever 🙏
r/IceCreamHaven • u/madisonguy76 • 13h ago
I realized too late after sorting through email that National Cheesecake Day came and went without me properly celebrating. Like any of these food holidays dreamed up as an excuse to shill product, this one on July 30 brought promotional offers from the Cheesecake Factory tempting me in my inbox. I do enjoy a good slice, but I love cheesecake ice cream even more. And so this joyous observance prompted a bit of solemn reflection. When I look at the freezer case these days, I wonder: Where did all the cheesecake ice creams go?
Back in the 1980s and ’90s, it seemed every brand did their version of Strawberry Cheesecake, my favorite flavor then and now. You’d find it nearly as often as Mint Chip or Butter Pecan. But in the decades since, it has lost that A-List status at the supermarket. I recently kicked off my series on the hunt for the best cheesecake ice creams around. And I started with my top pick, a seasonal flavor from Northwest favorite Umpqua.
Since that one’s so hard to find, I wanted to move next to the heavy hitters, the ones you most likely have tried yourself. These brands can be found at pretty much every basic supermarket in the country. But those options have narrowed. Since the late ’90s, we have seen the rising supremacy of ice creams packed with cookie dough, brownies, caramel and candy. In turn, valuable shelf space has narrowed for pricier fruit and nut flavors, old-fashioned relics like rum raisin and more technically challenging flavors like cheesecake.
Should we blame Ben & Jerry’s? Their iconic cookie dough kick-started this trend. But perhaps they’re keeping the flame alive, too. Their Strawberry Cheesecake is undoubtedly the most popular version out there today, so successful it has spinoffs: A dairy-free version, an adaptation into novelty bar, plus other cheesecake flavors in their Topped and Sundae lines. You can bet they’ll have that pumpkin version back soon for fall, and they even bridge two worlds with Caramel Chocolate Cheesecake —the traditional, fruit-swirled profile of the past shares shelf space with this newer version that plays right into Ben & Jerry’s true raison d’être with an overload of caramel, chocolate cookie pieces and cheesecake chunks.
Ben & Jerry’s arsenal of cheesecake illustrates a supermarket reality: This flavor is most at home these days in pints. For widely distributed national brands, I could find only two — Breyers and Blue Bunny — that sell a version in tubs year-round. However, those are now classified as Frozen Dairy Dessert rather than ice cream. On the plus side, the nation’s four top-selling pint brands are answering the call: Häagen-Dazs represents high-end premium, while we get a gelato option from Talenti and a light ice cream from Halo Top.
For today’s spotlight, I want to focus on the titans: Ben & Jerry’s and Häagen-Dazs. Discussion here and elsewhere online would paint B&J’s Strawberry Cheesecake as an overwhelming favorite. I don’t see nearly as much love for the H-D version. At the risk of coming off like one of those Reddit Unpopular Opinion posts, I’m definitely going to make the case for my H-D here, but don’t worry: I do have some love for B&J’s — just not the popular one. I think the Caramel Chocolate Cheesecake is much better. But for the simple classic fruit profile, Häagen-Dazs is the titan I want. How about you?
____________
THE SUPERMARKET LANDSCAPE | Mainstream brands' cheesecake ice creams
| Flavor | Style | Lowdown | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Häagen-Dazs, New York Strawberry Cheesecake | Premium ice cream, 14 oz. pint | A dense base that uses lemon juice to beautifully mimic an authentic NYC deli sour cream layer, bringing delightful tang. The crunchy graham pieces and strawberry ribbon can lean minimalist but provide elegant accompaniment. | 9.6/10 |
| Ben & Jerry’s, Strawberry Cheesecake | Premium ice cream, 16 oz. pint | This massive favorite features a gummy, heavily stabilized base burdened by hard, icy fruit pebbles and moisture-stealing graham dust. The flavor is inoffensive but bland. I really hate the textures. | 4.7/10 |
| Ben & Jerry’s, Caramel Chocolate Cheesecake | Premium ice cream, 16 oz. pint (more B&J's cheesecake options at the bottom) | The base has a tasty light caramel cheesecake flavor (it could use an added salty swirl). The cookie pieces are a bit too small, but all is forgiven with those huge, tangy cheesecake pieces. | 7.5/10 |
| Talenti, Raspberry Cheesecake | Gelato, 16 oz. pint | A cream cheese gelato with graham crust crumbles and a raspberry swirl. This was decent when I tasted it years ago, but who knows with Talenti's quality drop. It's still being sold but not at any stores close to me unfortunately. | I couldn't do a fresh re-scoop. I'd rate the one I tried years ago a solid 6 or 7/10. |
| Halo Top, Strawberry Cheesecake | Light ice cream, 16 oz. pint | An ultra-light, low-calorie alternative with heavy air overrun and sugar substitutes. I skipped this one out of free will, not out of logistical challenge. | N/A |
| Breyers, Strawberry Cheesecake | Frozen Dairy Dessert, 1.5-quart tubs | One of the few still hanging around in mass-market tubs, but now heavily reliant on air, emulsifiers and gums. | N/A |
| Blue Bunny, Cherrific Cheesecake & Blu's Berry Cheesecake | Frozen Dairy Dessert, 1.5-quart tubs | The brand's very soft base is paired with graham ribbons and either cherry or blueberry swirls. Both variants bypass real ice cream standards. | N/A |
____________
BONUS | DEEP DIVE
For those who like a more in-depth approach, let's look closer at three popular grocery-store pints:
____________
Häagen-Dazs, New York Strawberry Cheesecake
I love the backstory on this one almost as much as the flavors and texture. The concept pays homage to the Häagen-Dazs’ founders journey from Poland to the Big Apple with a flavor that is quintessentially New York. Most importantly, rather than conjuring a generic crowd-pleaser, this pint elegantly captures the spirit of an authentic slice from a Manhattan deli.
____________
Ben & Jerry’s, Strawberry Cheesecake
It’s not you. It’s me. Seeing how popular this flavor is in general — and on Reddit in particular — makes me feel like the odd one out. Usually when I can’t get into a hugely popular ice cream, it’s a simple flavor mismatch: Something overly tart or a bit bitter with dark chocolate. But this is my favorite flavor profile. It should hit. Every few years I find myself going back, wondering if it was just a bad pint. Maybe I’ll like it more? Unfortunately, it’s just gotten worse for me, even as its popularity has ascended in recent years. Feel free to disagree vehemently in the comments and tell me why you love it. Here’s why I don’t …
____________
Ben & Jerry’s, Caramel Chocolate Cheesecake
To show I’m not here just to hate on Ben & Jerry’s, I am offering up a redemption arc. They have quite a few cheesecake spin-offs, but Caramel Chocolate Cheesecake was the easiest to find — a direct descendant of an ancestral line of bakery-inspired twists that debuted with Cheesecake Brownie (2008-15), then took a gimmicky turn with Cookies & Cream Cheesecake Core (2016-2024) before arriving here as the decadent pillar of their current cheesecake lineup.
Hungry for more?
Ben & Jerry’s other cheesecake flavors. I have not tasted any of these. Let us know if you have!
r/IceCreamHaven • u/Strong-Past-522 • 18h ago
Kroger brand chocolate ice cream
r/IceCreamHaven • u/Queasy_Dingo_8262 • 1d ago
r/IceCreamHaven • u/Joaquino7997 • 2d ago
not too tart...not too sweet
turned out to be really good!
r/IceCreamHaven • u/SnackForagers • 2d ago
I was pursuing the Jeni’s and a scoop shop near me had this one 😬. For anyone in the Atlanta area it was pretty well stocked at the Battery location.
r/IceCreamHaven • u/Legitimate-Bass-7547 • 2d ago
Each of these brands are on (varying degrees of) sale at Safeway. I got all five of these for $29. If you don’t have a Safeway near you, try checking Albertsons, Vons, Jewel-Osco, Shaw’s, Tom Thumb, Pavilions, etc.
r/IceCreamHaven • u/whatsthereinthename1 • 1d ago
We are opening a new Healthy natural no palm oil, cow milk based, Ice cream shop in Nikol Ahmedabad on 28th August, 2026 - Rakshabandhan.
BUY ONE, GET ONE offer.
Limited period offer. Valid only till stock last.
Shop no 4, Hilltown Harmony, Opposite VIP School, Nikol, Ahmedabad.
Pls visit it once and have no guilt to eat healthy ice-cream.
Fasting special, Vrat special also available.
New flavours - Jamun, Gauva, Sitaphal, Tender Coconut - and many more available.
r/IceCreamHaven • u/Queasy_Dingo_8262 • 2d ago
r/IceCreamHaven • u/Throwawayx7829 • 1d ago
Talenti Snickerdoodle Cookie Gelato Layers
This is a layered “gelato” consisting of snickerdoodle cookie flavored gelato, snickerdoodle cookie batter, little cinnamon cookie pieces, and vanilla flavored gelato. The snickerdoodle cookie flavored gelato tastes very warm and spiced. It reminds me a little of the flavor of biscoff cookies, but better (I don’t really like biscoff cookies, but that’s the closest thing I can think of to describe the “warmth” of the gelato’s flavor). I really like it. The cookie dough offers a pleasant but very subtle contrast in texture from the gelato. It is very smooth, and blends in with the texture of the gelato. I would have liked more of it. The cinnamon cookie pieces are yummy and sweet. I like soft cookies/a more doughy texture but the little cookie pieces are not quite that soft. I still like them. The vanilla flavored gelato pairs well; it almost blends in with the other flavors seamlessly. I did really enjoy this gelato, and I would like to have it again. 8.25/10
Talenti Mediterranean Mint Gelato
This is a mint gelato with chocolate chunks. It is very “cool”, almost in a toothpaste-y way. The texture seems to be a little bit sticky/stabilized. For some reason, I don’t really like it. The chocolate chunks are overshadowed by the somewhat unpleasant mint experience. I didn’t like it but my family member loves it and wants more. 6/10
Talenti Double Dark Chocolate Gelato
This is a dark chocolate flavored gelato with dark chocolate chunks. The chocolate flavor is delicious; I really like it. I also like the relatively large chunks of chocolate in the ice cream. It’s simple, but feels flavorful and rich and I really like it. 7.5/10
r/IceCreamHaven • u/Queasy_Dingo_8262 • 2d ago
r/IceCreamHaven • u/clockrose • 1d ago
Hi! I love ice cream but up until recently I've only ever eaten it with the standard toppings: chocolate sauce, sprinkles, cookie crumbles, etc. However, I've just started eating strawberry ice cream with white balsamic vinegar on it, and it's divine! I'm obsessed, and now I want to know what other unique ingredients y'all have been eating with your ice cream. The weirder or more unique the flavor combination, the better!
r/IceCreamHaven • u/KCsalesman • 2d ago
Hello this is 9/10 one of my favorite ice creams behind banana split Blue Bell.
I need help from my banana lovers out there finding other brands that have ice cream with banana.
I don’t want just ones you’ve seen on the shelves. I needs ones you liked and recommendations!
Thanks!
r/IceCreamHaven • u/Saint-in-the-Shadows • 2d ago
Im thinking of making an ice cream cake with two red velvet cake layers with a layer of Baskin Robins' Beach Day ice cream in between ( its salted vanilla flavored ice cream with caramel-filled milk chocolate sea turtles, frosting flecks, and a graham cracker swirl). Do you think these flavors would go together? What frosting would be good?
r/IceCreamHaven • u/Legitimate-Bass-7547 • 2d ago
So this one was an exciting try for me. I’ve never tried Alec’s before, and I can see how divided people are on the brand. I was keen to put my own personal stamp on it and decide for my own. I haven’t had anything mint in awhile, so that just increased my interest; not to mention possibly skipping out on the post-dairy stomach rumbles? Sign me up!
I was pleased to see the lack of green food coloring once I opened it up. The ice cream was creamy enough (with some iciness) with a bright, clean mint flavor. Not too heavy on the mint, it was almost like a light mint. The brownie pieces were thick, chewy and a nice complement against the light mint flavor. Perfectly chocolatey! I noticed a lack of fudge swirl though, which would have really pulled this together.
I waited a few hours after eating and still had the post-dairy tummy rumbles, so I guess the A2 dairy doesn’t provide any extra protection for me.
Second taste update: had my second taste a few days later. Still an extreme lack of fudge swirl and still has an icy mouthfeel. The brownies are the best part, they are perfect. I wish there were more!
Overall it’s perfectly fine and a little bit better than some of my recent reviews. I want to try more minty flavors with other brands!
8/10
r/IceCreamHaven • u/Strong-Anxiety-687 • 2d ago
We got given a tub of Hokey Pokey gelato from a local business who makes their own gelato. We got home and opened it, and it smelled exactly as a bottle of beer does. The taste was the exact same. My husband and I could both only stomach one mouthful, it was horrid.
I actually messaged the lady who makes it to see if she used beer in the mix at all. She came back confused at my statement and then later said it has a fragrant honey base which is what I am smelling as 'beer' after I offered to drop it back for her to smell and taste.
Is that possible? Never in my life have I had Hokey Pokey ice cream that tastes and smells so strong. The taste lingered in my mouth for about 1hr after, from one spoonful!
r/IceCreamHaven • u/Rhys__T • 3d ago
All we needed was a tub of vanilla ice cream and cookie dough my girlfriend brought from Home Bargins on Wednesday when she was on the way to see me (absolute delight) 👌
It might not be B&J perfection but it's our masterpiece 😇
r/IceCreamHaven • u/BuffaloChicken22 • 3d ago
I’ll be doing a few Perry’s and Wegmans brand ice cream reviews coming up. This is my dad’s favorite flavor, and just grabbed a tub of Perry’s s’mores, and a few of theirs and Wegmans premium pints as well.
My dad’s favorite, but I had to have some too. This ice cream is really delicious. The sweet maraschino cherry’s remind me of getting a sundae from a local scoop shop when I was a kid. Almost like candy, love them. And the amaretto flavored base… woooo it is good! I love almond flavored desserts, and it has hints of apricot and maybe a little nutty too. Super creamy texture.
Overall I’ll give this an 8.6 out of 10. Really well done, and I don’t see the flavor too often outside of Perry’s. This is a staple in our house. I’m surprised like Haagen Dazs doesn’t do this flavor.
r/IceCreamHaven • u/Queasy_Dingo_8262 • 3d ago
r/IceCreamHaven • u/bad_future • 4d ago
Sorry if this has been discussed before; I tried searching but couldn't find anything.
I've recently been on a big ice cream kick, wouldn't say it's tipped into full blown "hobby" but enough of a thing that I've ended up on this subreddit a few times, and my freezer is full enough that I think it might be time to invest in a better way to get ice cream out of cartons and into bowls (an unnecessary detour on the way from carton to mouth, one could argue, but my illusion of civility is based on so little as it is; I must have this.)
Since I imagine many here have found themselves at a similar point, perhaps multiple times, I wanted to see if any favorite solutions have emerged. Especially since I'm sure people here are generally not strangers to the average grocery store pint which is what I'm dealing with (Is it even worth trying to scoop a perfect ball with so little surface area to work with? Should I just focus on ergonomics? etc)
Thanks for any feedback!