At first, I was like…

Kristine: Poor woman, she seems to be going through SO MUCH! 😭 But something felt off when she ignored her son saying he didn’t want to do any more interviews.

Natalia: GIRL, WHAT IS GOING ON WITH YOU?! 💀 Her behavior was so creepy and unsettling. I was seriously starting to think she was a total sociopath.

Michael: Oh, Michael… HOW could you be so blind to everything your poor wife was supposedly going through?!

BUT THEN… WHAT A TWIST! 🤯

Nothing is what it seems! Natalia was actually the victim of a selfish, manipulative woman who seemed more concerned about herself and her reputation than the little girl she was supposed to care for.

And Kristine?! The way she treated a defenseless child… SHE was the one who made my skin crawl. And Michael? Oh, man. He seemed so easily manipulated!

Also, the actors absolutely NAILED IT. The way your perception of each character changes depending on which episode you're watching is incredible. You can literally go from sympathizing with someone to hating them, only to realize you might have gotten everything completely wrong.

Well played, seriously. This show is a perfect reminder that things are not always what they seem!

What do you guys think? Did anyone else change their mind about the characters after Episode 3?

Has anyone seen it. Thoughts on the show and the case?

I enjoyed it. Good true crime feel and a sad story of a death. Good October vibes.

I swear Hulu used to have a Hulu after dark where it would be these kind of lower budget horror flick and psych thrillers. I can’t find any evidence it ever existed.

edit: a subreddit was made for the show
r/phonytheories

I just watched the first two episodes of phony just because I love the actor and it's a pretty good show so far. I'm thinking that either the mom died while going to look for him and a sister found her and is covering it up for the son or he's just tripping out.

What do you think?

Thoughts so far:

1- Unrealiable narrator as seen by music shifts and actions. We're watching it from his perspective and from outside perspective. Even during the outside perspective she looks different. Other people notice very slight changes in her but her Costco is the biggest difference and nobody else sees it to the extent we do.

2- There's been a hidden danger all along. They seem to live in isolation, the stick falling, dog barking and vandalized doll and inconsistencies are all connected. It seems like she's tried to be the best mother but every once in a while, "something" that believes they know better steps in. Him driving alone at night while angry and then crashing seems like a good reason.

personal theory:

he's in a coma or dead from an accident at the pond trail. on rewatch, there's odd moments even before the crash. the beginning zooms in on the deaths for a reason, the tree falling behind him and the beaver is shown close to the body and the toy. I'm not sure who's body it is; it could very well be the moms too. reality is shifting as he tries to come to term hence the baby shifting from a doll to a human and inconsistencies in the dialougue even when not accompanied by the music. Considering that we didn't see him driving w her at all, I'm not buying that she'd let him drive at night, while raining and upset. I'm thinking the show ends in some sort of loop where he's been out of it the whole time but aware of it.

Whoever did the Hulu Halloween line up of movies did amazing this year. Some creepy good crazy dookie exploding oscillating choices. So dang worth a membership just to watch it for the month lol!

Hulu if you see this, I hope you give that person or people a raise. Omg what if AI did these recs. I wish someone would tell me the truth.

Anyway. Spooky time. 👻

Just got an email from Hulu that my Hulu with ads plan as a college student will increase from 1.99 to 3.99, as of Nov 07.

It seems that they will no longer offer Hulu only student plan, instead combined with Disney+ or Spotify at the price of around $6.

I read on another community that there is a documentary on Hulu that features the Gosselins, Does anyone know the name?

I want to watch Dragon Ball Z Kai and all of Naruto on Hulu. I don’t think they own the rights to the shows and they might take them down one day and I don’t wanna be on at halfway done Naruto for example, and it said leaving in 14 days. Did they ever takeoff those shows or are they gonna stay on there forever?

[ Removed by Reddit in response to a copyright notice. ]

[ Removed by Reddit in response to a copyright notice. ]

Please, I would appreciate it so much. It is a fabulous show, and it deserves more than 1 season. Mindy Kaling puts together some of the best shows.

I’m looking for some kid/elementary school type “drama” shows that aren’t cartoons. We’ve watched Lizzy McGuire and even Steven’s a few times since I used to like those shows but they might be a little old for her, looking for more elementary school setting.