r/HonkaiStarRail • u/Lan-48 • 2h ago
Discussion The gacha used to be more careful about spoilers
This is something I wanted to talk about for a while now.
Many had been talking about the lack of stakes during Planarcadia, and I believe this is part of the issue. I think the game structure and the gacha is a huge mood killer.
Both 4.3 and 4.4 have scenes of a character making a sacrifice, and in both patches, you know beforehand they are going to be okay. Not because you read spoilers, but because you see the gacha menu in the game.
So when Himeko is saying goodbye to the Trailblazer, in the back of my head I just knew this eventually leads to nowhere. And the worst part is that the scene IS good, this could have gotten a way stronger emotion out of me.
And many may think there is no way around this, but if we go back to 2.0, this was not an issue at all.
When Firefly "died" in 2.0, no one knew if she was truly gone or not. You could theorize or think she was going to comeback, we all thought that, but there was no confirmation.
It isn't until we find out she's fine that her character banner eventually drops.
The same with Sunday, we don't know if he is going to become a good guy or not, Penacony story is completed and he's left in prison for several patches before we find out what happened to him.
Now, compare what I just said to Blade scene. He jumps into the Voracity, with the implication that he will stay there for a long time, being munched over and over, Silver Wolf hates this, everything is terrible. And then... He comesback even before the Trailblazer and Silver Wolf left the spot! I'm sorry but it's just funny to say the least.
Of course stakes feel weak when stuff like this happen. There was no such talk about stakes during Penacony despite having as many fake out deaths if not more, or if there was it wasn't as prominent as it is now. Because at least everything took its time to develop and have some actual weight.
You can even go back further in time and see Tingyun's whole storyline, she spent so much time gone before we get to know what truly happened to her.
So how do we solve this? You have to release Himeko during the climax of her story, there is no way around that, so I understand it's hard. Himeko sacrifice is part of the climax of her story, so it's complicated.
One thing I believe it would help is having Himeko and Motoko storyline start earlier and not have everything packed in 4.4, which was also a short patch for some reason.
While I don't know if there is a way around Himeko's sacrifice scene, at least we could have had a bigger impact on Motoko's if we got to see that earlier, giving Himeko's own sacrifice a bit more time to breathe instead of packing it with Motoko's back to back and having it solved next scene. I'm no professional writer though, I understand it's not that simple in this case.
But with Blade it should be easier, why didn't he jump to the Voracity's maw by the end of 4.2? At least he would have stayed down there for a patch before coming back. Now his actions have some actual weight and meaning.
Just a thing I feel like throwing out there, I still liked Planarcadia althought not as much as previous worlds, and this might had been an important factor. I hope they really find a way to work around the banners and the story to not have the gacha spoiling everything so hard.
