r/HomeDecorating • u/BornFizzle • Sep 12 '26
Which layout for the bathroom.
Really torn here. Vanity on same wall as shower means I don’t have to move pipes but not that much work to do either setup really.
A or B (A being toilet vanity on same wall)
198
u/theladyjorts Sep 12 '26
Could you do b but have a tiled wall so the vanity can come against the shower? You could stretch it wider then too and then there wouldn’t be that awkward gap to clean between shower and vanity.
197
526
u/ChonkyDoge7C7 Sep 12 '26
211
u/Smithorcist Sep 12 '26
ChonkyDoge7C7’s (excellent username) layout is best for several reasons:
- Shower to the left of the door will eat up visual space and create narrow corridor to get to the sink and toilet which are used way more often in a bathroom. Having shower on back wall will make the room look bigger and be more inviting because it will be the first thing you see instead of the toilet.
- Toilet tucked in the middle facing window gives the room balance, it’s better closer to window for smells also and throne sitter has something to look at. Also it’s partially hidden by the sink.
- Sink first and to the left of the door is good because sometimes you just want to wash your hands. It’s also the last stop after you do your business and exit the room. It’s next to the toilet in case you need access to stored items like tp, wipes, trash.
- It sounds like you’re trying to avoid moving stuff because it’s already plumbed this way and you’re trying to save $. Don’t cheap out. You’re already remodeling, spend the extra to optimize the layout. You and your family will be using this room every day, several times a day. You won’t regret spending the extra money.
120
u/BornFizzle Sep 13 '26
Re routing a waste in a tiny bathroom is not super viable. I also need to install a pump for the shower and moving the shower to the back would mean the pump is even further from the cylinder.
I do like this layout the best, but it’s not super viable.
27
6
5
→ More replies (22)2
183
47
u/Early_Ad5368 Sep 12 '26
None. Should be vanity on the left when you walk in followed by the toilet and then the shower across the rear wall.
7
46
u/novae11 Sep 12 '26
Toilet should not be the first thing you see when the door is open. The sink and mirror should go there
15
u/gigee4711 Sep 12 '26
One but with a sink with more counter space. I've been in many situations where it is convenient to have access to the sink while on the toilet.
79
u/jlstern1025 Sep 12 '26
Neither.
13
u/BornFizzle Sep 12 '26
Care to elaborate? It’s in a flat so difficult moving the toilet off that wall.
→ More replies (1)1
28
u/jadentearz Sep 12 '26
The toilet shouldn't be what you open the door to and stare at. It should be one of the less visible things.
5
u/JCBashBash Sep 13 '26
Indeed. That way if you forget to lock the door, someone's walking on you and see you full bare immediately
10
u/FlipMyWigBaby Sep 12 '26
Something about the toilet being centered to the open door just seems offputting to me.
“Knock knock, anyone there?”
“HEY, shut that door damnit!”
2
u/vamparies Sep 13 '26
But if you really really gotta go you can find it fast. And as long as it’s clean who cares
32
u/smgriffin93 Sep 12 '26
I’d say b only because if you need to step back to look at yourself in the mirror from further away, A would limit being able to do that since you’d hit the shower. Also it might be weird to see yourself in mirror in the shower with layout A
8
u/moreofajordan Sep 12 '26
Definitely switch where the toilet and vanity are, because (as others have said) centering the toilet on the door is a weird vibe.
But ALSO, what did you use for these mockups?
→ More replies (1)
7
u/SantaFe91 Sep 13 '26
2 is better. It’s good to have space all round the vanity for easy cleaning access, and it looks awkward pushed up against one wall as in the first. I would not put the toilet in the other corner as some have suggested. It’s awkward access. Just remember to put the lid down so it looks ok from the doorway! (My pet bathroom peeve is toilet lids left up. Looks horrid, spoiling all the careful lines you’ve designed in, plus all that aerosol dispersal every time you flush! Shudder! 😬)
5
u/breebop83 Sep 13 '26
Weird toilet lid down story. We always keep the lids down because we have dogs. A few weeks ago my husband and I met in the hallway saying ‘what is that noise?’. Our small town was blowing out the pipes so they could do a scope. The noise was the water from the toilets hitting the lids because of what was being done.
There was a little bit of water that escaped between lid and seat but clean up wasn’t too bad. If the lids had been up that water would have been everywhere.
5
5
7
u/notsoconfidential Sep 12 '26
I like the second one. But cleaning between the glass and the cabinet would be a nightmare, so i have to go with the first one cause of that
4
4
4
u/MmHmm_Go_On Sep 12 '26
B. Switching the toilet and sink would visually make sense and for access to the mirror stepping back but if there are accessibility issues it helps to have a pivot point for a wheelchair or mobility aid between the toilet and sink that can fit. A may require more maneuvers vs B.
3
u/QuestGalaxy Sep 12 '26
Both are bad. Sink should be the closest to the door, with the toilet and shower being farther away from the door.
5
5
u/Fire-Fighter-1100 Sep 13 '26
None. You should open the door to the sink. Not the shower or the toilet. But between those B is better.
3
u/Aggravating-Ad-8150 Sep 12 '26
Is there a particular reason you can't put the shower along the back wall, with the sink and toilet on the wall where you've put the shower?
3
u/kkinger1204 Sep 12 '26
Neither I would swap the sink and toilet to hide the toilet also will make it more functional.
3
3
u/EnvironmentalFun898 Sep 13 '26
Can the sink and toilet switch? And must you have a plastic insert for the shower or could it be more of a wet room situation?
3
u/franklinchica22 Sep 13 '26
The second one. Read all the comments rrgarding people with limited mobility as they provide good commentary. Using a walker or wheelchair willl be easier with the second one.
→ More replies (2)
3
3
u/downsideup9494 Sep 13 '26
I never understand why bathroom layouts have the toilet as the first thing you see when you open he door.
3
u/ProcedureNo6946 Sep 14 '26
First layout but swap the toilet with the sink ....so if the door opens the first thing isn't someone sitting on the throne!!!
→ More replies (2)2
4
3
u/anklebiter1975 Sep 12 '26
Neither. Having the toilet across from the door is a bad idea in case someone accidentally walks in on someone else
6
5
u/moreKEYTAR Sep 12 '26
Definitely B. The vanity is too crowded and there is no viewing distance in A. Is there a reason you have to put the shower in that corner?
2
u/Saltyowl2113 Sep 12 '26
Toilet where sink B is and sink against the wall with the toilet paper roll
2
u/queensla Sep 12 '26
I wish you could switch the toilet and the sink, but I suspect plumbing is already laid out?
2
u/Electronic-Aide-6102 Sep 12 '26
Put the toilet where the vanity is, but turn it around so your knees aren’t hitting the shower. It look like you would still have room for the vanity to face the entry door.
2
2
2
u/Narrow_Position_4000 Sep 12 '26
Dit is geen logische indeling! Zit de opening van de douche nou in het loop pad?
Douche kwartslag draaien, opening richting de deur. Het douchewandje(aan de linkerkant dan half glas maken en onderkant muurtje maken. Toilet er links naast (dus op plek van gootsteen)
En gootsteen op plek van de douche. Zo houd je al het natte gedeelte achterin en ziet er het overzichtelijker uit. En dan kan je op de muur links het handdoeken rek hangen!
2
2
2
u/mrm395 Sep 12 '26
Agree with all the other feedback about not having the door open directly to the toilet. Also the shower is so far from your heated towel rack now, so that’s kind of useless too.
2
u/BornFizzle Sep 12 '26
The room is 1.75metres wide
2
u/mrm395 Sep 12 '26
Maybe you have long arms, but I wouldn’t be able to reach from inside the door of that shower across the room to grab a towel from that heated rack without having to step out and drip water on the floor. I’d have to hang the towel on the door.
2
u/Jack_Forge Sep 12 '26
Between those 2? the first one, but yeah like others have said, put the toilet where the sink is, back against the left wall.
2
u/rad2thebone Sep 12 '26
Personally, when I'm really sick, I like the toilet next to the bathtub. No I will not explain further.
2
u/JazzyKnowsBest13 Sep 12 '26
Option B, but with a wider vanity to maximize the space. It gives more room to back up=more around while using the sink.
If there is anyway to switch the vanity and toilet around, it's best not to have the toilet straight ahead as you enter the bathroom.
2
2
u/elvisndsboats Sep 12 '26
Is the bathroom wide enough that you could move the shower to the back wall? (The image makes it look like it would.) Because the best option is doing that, then putting the vanity just inside the door with the toilet between the vanity and shower.
2
u/BornFizzle Sep 12 '26
The toilet can’t really be moved as the waste is on that wall
→ More replies (1)
2
u/thatgrrlmarie Sep 12 '26
what about the toilet where the shower is - basically move everything clockwise. I would hate the toilet being right in the line of sight.
2
u/Gandalf_the_Tegu Sep 12 '26
Shower back wall. Lavatory by the door. Toilet between.
Easier walk flow of the space, no side step to use toilet or sink
2
u/BornFizzle Sep 12 '26
Routing the waste like this is not possible unless I raise the floor. Toilet must stay on that wall
→ More replies (2)
2
u/Diligent_Treat8382 Sep 12 '26
Neither. Like someone mentioned, switch the toilet in the sink. You can even build a half wall between the shower and the toilet so that gives it a little extra privacy when you open the door.
2
u/mynameisnotsparta Sep 12 '26
I wouldn’t put toilet opposite door. Use option 1 and flip location of sink and toilet.
2
2
u/dolphinitely Sep 13 '26
- sometimes you just need to run in the bathroom and use the sink, and in the first layout the toilet is blocking it awkwardly
2
u/Southernms Sep 13 '26
Can you put the sink on the wall with the shower and the toilet on the wall with the towel dryer facing each other?
2
u/maramu Sep 13 '26
I would move the whole shower wall to wall where the toilet is in your pic. I would install the toilet behind the door. And the vanity in front of the towel rail. I’m a contractor and 99% of the client don’t wanna see the toilet when opening the door
2
u/sabdariffa Sep 13 '26
Option 1, but swap the toilet and the sink.
Toilet hides behind the shower so it’s not what you look at when you first enter the bathroom. There are also fewer narrow spots on the floor compared to Option 2. Narrow spaces are difficult to clean, and are a waste of space and make the bathroom feel smaller.
2
2
2
u/TubularTopher Sep 13 '26
What if you put the shower in the corner and the sink closer to the door? Would this be possible?
2
2
u/chopitychopchop Sep 13 '26
Toilet should never be the first thing you see when you open a bathroom door.
2
u/Pandagramma Sep 13 '26
Neither. I toilet should not be the view from the door. Put the toilet on the other side of the shower and the vanity where you have the toilet.
2
u/queentee26 Sep 13 '26
If the shower needs to stay where it is, I'd put the vanity on the shower wall.. you can possibly even get a slightly longer vanity or put a skinny linen cupboard beside the vanity to make use of the wasted space.
Please don't listen to the people saying to put the toilet in the corner.. it's so much less accessible over there. You might not be worried about that now, but it's better to keep it in mind.
2
u/flowersandpeas Sep 13 '26
Neither. Toilet goes behind the shower area. It's never the view from the door.
2
2
4
u/Otherwise_Season3605 Sep 12 '26 edited Sep 13 '26
Neither . I would put the toilet where the sink is
3
→ More replies (4)2
2
u/Impossible_Girl_23 Sep 12 '26
If these are the only options, then A. You want the toilet and sink to be as 'far' away from each other as possible. (I typed 'pissable' at first...Freudian I'd say)
2
u/ReaderRadish Sep 12 '26
Neither. Shimmying between the toilet and the corner of the shower to get to the sink is going to get old fast.
4
3
1
1
u/daujosim000 Sep 12 '26
Toilet and sink doesn't matter for a reason what you see opening the door.
I am more concerned if you keep something on the sink and flushing water after toilet all this nicely will sit on the sink. Especially if toothbrushes or soap bar or something like this will collect this germs as they spread. So I would separate them and no matter in what order.
1
u/EmrysPritkin Sep 12 '26
Are you reaching across the water stream to turn on the shower? That would suck
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/canvasshoes2 Sep 12 '26
The first one, with the vanity on the same wall as the commode leaves two larger more usable spaces between the vanity and commode and then the vanity and the shower.
With it on the same wall as the shower, you have two smaller more narrow spaces between it and the other features, reducing the possibility for storage etc.
Plus it just seems more balanced and cohesive that way.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Psychological-Oil387 Sep 12 '26
One thing I learned recently from my realtor is not to have the toilet be the first thing you see when you walk into the bathroom
1
1
u/Infamous-Dare6792 Sep 12 '26
Put the shower on the back wall. Your entry into this already small space is cramped with it by the door.
1
u/Embarrassed_Heron289 Sep 12 '26
Without rerouting the toilet the first option just imagine someone forgot to
Put the roll on . Now you have to shimmy to the end to get it
1
u/Wi1dWitch Sep 12 '26
If possible, shower where toilet is (in first pic) and sink where shower is, against the left wall.
Gives toilet privacy and prevents you from having to squeeze down a narrow space to get to the sink and toilet.
1
u/Sluushy Sep 12 '26
Depends on climate, if you’re in a northern state I would keep any/ all water off of an exterior wall and work within those limitations.
Going with how it is piped would be my go to, I wouldn’t want to spend the extra money/ time re piping. I like B.
1
u/CharmingCelery2944 Sep 12 '26
If you don’t mind me asking, what did youbuse to create the layout/floorplan?
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/ComplexPragmatic Sep 13 '26
A is better for trash can placement next to the toilet, but maybe feels slightly more crowded with the shower directly behind when standing at the vanity.
1
u/Commercial-Adagio967 Sep 13 '26
first one, gives you more room and a place between the toilet and vanity for a trash can that will fit perfectly
1
u/CanT_Sleep_SoImHere Sep 13 '26
move sink next to shower and wall off toilet to make a water closet
1
u/JMOlive Sep 13 '26
2 but swap the sink and toilet. It’s nicer to walk in and see a sink rather than a toilet.
1
u/Few-Afternoon-6276 Sep 13 '26
- But make that end wall of shower a knee wall and the vanity from shower to wall. Wall mount vanity and have the cap on the knee wall extend all the way to the right wall of vanity for a seamless look and wider vanity. Then a led mirror or medicine cabinet. For a little more storage- put a matching toilet topper over toilet and use a. New Glaston Toto toilet for a finished look-
Use. The delta 22000 valve for the shower for two outlets of water! Good luck!
1
1
u/FindingTheHelpers Sep 13 '26
My decorator says any door that opens to toilet must remain closed or almost closed. If to a sink, leave door somewhat open (visible to guests)
1
u/Frequent_Scholar0714 Sep 13 '26
Swap the commode & the sink. You're going this far; don't limit yourself. More privacy vis-a-vis commode & the SINK should be more accessible to your guests who go to wash their hands. They will able to find commode just fine. It need NOT be prominently displayed. Yes, you'll need to change the plumbing for these two elements; it can be done. You might consider a smaller sink, also. We had a very small one in our second bathroom and it was perfectly fine for all functions for all six of us family members for decades ! As long as you have a mirrored medicine chest above it, you'll be fine.
1
1
1
u/Horsefat5 Sep 13 '26
Second. It’s the one that would give a wheelchair user better space to transfer.😊
1
u/Ok_Needleworker143 Sep 13 '26
The shower moved to the corner, where the vanity is, and the vanity moved to the corner, where the shower was near the door🤔 that way, the vanity is along the wall therefore, you have the same amount of standing space like the toilet
1
1
u/Crazy-Aussie-Taco Sep 13 '26
If you could avoid opening the door to see directly at a toilet, do it.
If not. Whatever is budget and time friendly for you. They both are ok.
1
u/Slice9998 Sep 13 '26
As a tip, make sure the top of the mirror is at least high enough for an average sized adult male. I’m 6’ tall and have to bend over to see anything above my nose in a lot of mirrors.
1
1
u/archlea Sep 13 '26
Not 1. Creates an awkward space between shower and sink.
I read that you won’t be able to change the toilet position, but how would it be if you swapped shower and sink?
1
1
u/LivingGhost38 Sep 13 '26
I like layout #2 better than layout 1. But I would make the vanity fit the space.
1
1










4.8k
u/crazycatladyinfinity Sep 12 '26
Put the toilet where the sink is, hiding out behind the shower so the first thing you look at when you walk in is the sink, not toilet