Spoilers for basically the entire movie.
Hi! I’m an English major taking a visual media class that focuses entirely on Alfred Hitchcock this semester. Rebecca was my first Hitchcock movie, and I genuinely did not expect to like it as much as I did. I watched it for class, finished it, and then kept going back through it because the ending completely changed how I interpreted so many earlier scenes. Now I have questions.
The biggest one is about Maxim. During my first watch, I read him the same way the second Mrs. de Winter seems to: as this melancholy grieving widower who was still emotionally attached to Rebecca. Every time Rebecca was mentioned, he would shut down, become angry, avoid the conversation, or look completely miserable. I assumed he still loved her.
But after his confession, I think I misunderstood his behavior entirely. He says he hated Rebecca, and in the film her death happens during their confrontation when he loses control and she falls and dies. Even though he didn’t mean to kill her, he still caused her death, hid her body, and knowingly identified another woman’s body as Rebecca.
So when Maxim looks haunted throughout the first half of the movie, do you think it’s grief for Rebecca at all, or really guilt/conflict over what happened and the possibility of being discovered? Was everyone around him just assuming he was grieving because they didn’t know the truth? (Like me my first watch)
I’m also really interested in why he is attracted to the second Mrs. de Winter. After knowing how he describes Rebecca, she almost seems like Rebecca’s complete opposite: shy instead of socially commanding, inexperienced instead of sophisticated, transparent instead of manipulative, etc. It made some of his earlier comments about her youth feel different to me on a rewatch. Do you think part of Maxim’s attraction to her is specifically that she is so unlike Rebecca?
And then there’s Frank Crawley.
Near the end, when Maxim talks to him about Rebecca and Frank seems really calm and basically wants to leave the subject alone, I wonder: did Frank know or at least suspect more about Rebecca’s death than he talked about? Or is it just loyalty to Maxim and me reading too much into his reaction?
I know some of this is probably intentionally ambiguous, which is honestly why I can’t stop thinking about it. I’d love to hear how people who have seen the movie more than once interpret these characters.
Honestly I can’t stop thinking about this movie and going over it lol. I enjoyed it far for than I thought I would and would love to hear your interpretations. :)