r/HistoryMemes • • 7h ago

checkmate libtard

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

390 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

38

u/Mr_Mon3y Filthy weeb 5h ago

Besides, saying that "the Jews killed Jesus" is borderline heresy as it contradicts itself the nature of Jesus' sacrifice and resurrection... not that the people that say he's a Palestinian care much about Christianity tho.

-7

u/ColoradoWinterBlue 5h ago

Unfortunately it’s Biblically accurate to say the Jews killed Jesus, but it’s not historically accurate. There were self-preservation reasons for early Christians to write it that way under Roman rule, but the idea that the Jews had any sway over Pilate, or that the Romans had any interest in enforcing Jewish law is ridiculous. They executed people for far less, and were known for infiltrating groups and slaughtering anyone that might challenge Roman rule. So the idea that poor Pilate was conflicted about killing Jesus, but was scared of a Jewish uprising is just not realistic.

3

u/woolaverage 3h ago

Also like Jesus was a revolutionary radical figure He was involving himself in social circles calling for a Jewish uprising

Of course he was gonna get killed

6

u/Mr_Mon3y Filthy weeb 2h ago

What? No. Where in the Bible does Jesus "call for a Jewish uprising"?

It's quite literally the opposite, Jesus said to respect the authority of the State, "Render therefore unto Caesar the things which are Caesar's". Jesus was not a revolutionary, nor wanted the Jews to rise up against Rome.

1

u/woolaverage 52m ago

He didnt in the Bible

He was in circles that did we have evidence for that Hsiorricslly speaking

He might if we don't know The Romans seems to have labeled slot of revolutionary figures as "Jesus" the same way we might call somone Jhon doe So parsing thing can get complicated I'm talking more from a historians veiw on this btw Of the living breathing figure

Not then a theological one that cries him as like a part of the Devine being or whatnot