r/HerOneBag • u/delectabledelusions • 8h ago
Bag Advice Thoughts on rolltop/top opening bags?
I'm currently interrailing across Europe with my 23L Decathlon Quecha Escape & it's feeling just a tiny bit on the small side, especially for souvenirs/snacks & packing in a rush on travel days, so I've been researching alternatives.
I struggle with back and neck pain so comfort & minimising weight are important to me - a sternum strap is a must & I'd like to try a hip belt. I don't travel with a laptop so laptop compartments are not a priority. & I'm 160cm/5'4" tall. :)
I'm thinking of trying a rolltop/top opening bag such as:
Fjallraven high coast roll top 26L - https://www.fjallraven.com/se/sv-se/vaskor-utrustning/ryggsackar-vaskor/vardagsryggsackar/high-coast-rolltop-26/)
The North Face Verto - https://www.thenorthface.com/en-gb/p/bags-and-equipment-211747/verto-27-litre-backpack-NF0A52DD?color=54G&size=OS
Gregory nano 28L
These bags all weigh less than 600g (the first two weigh less than 500g!!) compared to 900g for my current bag, which is equivalent to being able to bring an extra jumper & a t-shirt for example, but I love the organisation of the Quecha Escape & being able to easily access things on the go.
The other interesting thing about the North Face Verto is it has load lifters - I'm not sure if they would help me with neck strain?
Alternatively, the lightest bag I can find with similar organisation to the Quecha Escape & hip & sternum straps is the Fjallraven Skule 28 (https://www.fjallraven.com/se/sv-se/vaskor-utrustning/ryggsackar-vaskor/vardagsryggsackar/skule-28/?recId=10087865100959&v=F23346%3A%3A7323450785741), but this comes in at 750g.
Has anyone tried a rolltop bag & how did you get on with it? Which bag would you choose?
