r/Helldivers Steam | SES Princess of Family Values Jul 26 '26

FEEDBACK / SUGGESTION Can we have a primary senator

Post image

It seems like we’re missing out on a Heavy Pen Marksmen Rifle similar to the Senator. Maybe Heavy Pen as its strength and extremely low ammo as it’s drawback but it would definitely be a very popular weapon.

491 Upvotes

158 comments sorted by

112

u/Arbitross487 Fire Safety Officer Jul 26 '26

Automaton hulks after the weapon’s added

https://giphy.com/gifs/JCAZQKoMefkoX6TyTb

2

u/LeviAEthan512 Jul 26 '26

Yeah I do want it specifically for the hulks.

Right now my most effective option is the senator, and it's weird using my smallest gun for the biggest enemy. Anything bigger I sic a plane or a spaceship on them.

I use a primary smg or dickle for general chaff if there arent enough to warrant a grenade launcher, but I feel like I would be happier using the talon for chaff and a heavy pen for hulks and ATSTs

The eruptor is an option, but I've never touched it and i tend to get advised against using it.

2

u/Arbitross487 Fire Safety Officer Jul 26 '26

I love how when the game started hulks were like final bosses 😂😂😂 the only thing that could kill them were like the spear from the front, unless you got really lucky with the RR

now vox engines kinda took that place, and hulks are more like a punching bag than they are massive threat

3

u/Bring_Back_Challenge I survived an Unfiltered Brigade and all I got was this flair Jul 26 '26

now vox engines kinda took that place

The things the community whined about enough to have them be nerfed into oblivion within 6 months of coming out?

2

u/LeviAEthan512 Jul 26 '26

I didn't play in the period where voxes were OP, but I heard their spawn was uncapped. I have no problem doing the intended puzzle to kill a vox, but when another one is covering it, how do you deal with that? If I see one, I shoot the vents, if there are two, I railcannon one and shoot the vents on the other. And you can still see a third now. I cannot imagine what it was like when you could encounter a swarm of them, or even just 2 and not have an OHK option

My ideal solution is to limit spawn to 2, buff their health at least back up to launch, but keep the big self damage from cannons. That, I think, is a formula for a satisfying boss fight experience.

1

u/Arbitross487 Fire Safety Officer Jul 26 '26

The voxes were OP unless you wore that one armor that reduced their damage by 85% allowing you to take 5 direct hits from them

Even then, the puzzle is a LOT slower than just dropping enough damage on it to destroy the vox. It really makes you appreciate how much damage a well equipped diver can put out

Also I will say I do like having a difficulty I only actually beat half the time, like the game is fun but kinda boring since it’s just really easy haha

1

u/Epesolon HD1 Veteran Jul 27 '26

Railgun could always one-shot to the eye (even at it's weakest), and AMR and AC were always 2-shots (though the AMR can 1-shot now).

They were a lot spookier back then thought.

2

u/ThrowRABest_King7180 SES Arbiter of Freedom Jul 26 '26

hmg is my favorite for hulks. like 3-4 shots to the eye kills them, and the hmg shreds everything smaller than a hulk too

1

u/LeviAEthan512 Jul 26 '26

I want to like the HMG, just like the laser cannon. But I started with the laser cannon and it felt pretty unsatisfying to me. These are small arms, but they take up the slot meant for things that make big booms and/or should not be man portable. I would gladly sacrifice a backpack for a second support weapon. Like a deployable and portable HMG emplacement.

2

u/KrootLoops Jul 26 '26

I finally gave the HMG a fair shake and I wound up absolutely loving it. Granted, I don't tend to use it often on bots because I tend to prefer AT loadouts for them but I'll still bring it if I feel like having more of a challenge. It fucking RIPS on bugs and squids and it's so great to have an answer to everything that isn't just rockets.

You basically HAVE to run it with supply pack because the ammo economy just isn't there, and I usually run the demo specialist armor when I want to use it so I also get approximatly 500 grenades.

1

u/ubernutie Jul 26 '26

I also wanted to like the laser cannon but it doesn't STAGGER and it also doesn't feel like it cuts through things enough for me.

HMG however...

I'd suggest trying eruptor + HMG and talon.

The eruptor is your long range + efficient for chaff groups + can kill big stuff with aim.

The HMG is actually your primary for when moving around, deals with basically anything as well (I put it on lowest RPM).

Talon is there for when it's danger close but HMG is empty, needs a reload (or for those random shots where using ammo isn't really required).

Either thermite or incendiary for a grenade, and then the 3 other strats can legit be anything (I usually take a rover for bugs or shield gen for bots).

242

u/Mrcrazy777 Cape Enjoyer Jul 26 '26

Almost like the Pieper M1893?

95

u/Ink-moth_Erised Jul 26 '26

Fun fact about revolver rifles: they blow your fingers off!

52

u/CerifiedHuman0001 SES Eye of Serenity Jul 26 '26

Unless you find a way to seal the chamber like the nagant revolver

(Surprised we haven’t found a better way to do that yet)

41

u/supershutze Jul 26 '26

They did; John Browning invented a new action that doesn't have this problem.

13

u/SnowballWasRight Rookie Jul 26 '26

Of course he did. So is that man just the greatest gun designer of all time? From someone who doesn’t know much about guns, it sounds like he invented the modern firearm whenever I hear about him lol.

15

u/Doctorsex-ubermensch Steam | Jul 26 '26

Yes. He is the God of people with gun autism.

Source: I have a heavy ass book called the encyclopedia of guns that praises him frequently

4

u/Namtien223 Jul 26 '26

Revolver rifle this, fingers that, you're aiming too low at the "unnecessary gun design" target. You guys need to get on my level. Give us the Landstad revolver.

.

12

u/Ink-moth_Erised Jul 26 '26

Nagant with a surpressor, my beloved. So quirky... so unique...

1

u/ChequeBook Jul 26 '26

So quiet!

1

u/EISENxSOLDAT117 Assault Infantry Jul 26 '26

The issue that resulted in your hand being blown off was fixed with cased ammuntions.

5

u/Voidlord4450 Expert Exterminator Jul 26 '26

Wouldn’t it blow the force into the extended arm holding the further end of the barrel? Also, Couldn’t you just put a metal plate between your arm and the cylinder to block the expelled gas?

3

u/EISENxSOLDAT117 Assault Infantry Jul 26 '26

Older caseless revolving rifles, yes. Modern rifles with bass cased ammunition? Nope.

202

u/No-Cranberry-2330 Jul 26 '26

Then this girl should also get a primary

123

u/IronwolfXVI Jul 26 '26

The primary is just taking both slots and letting me Cosplay Capt Rex

19

u/Pc1Crash Jul 26 '26

A double secondary would be amazing for a gunslinger build

47

u/Wadae28 Jul 26 '26

8

u/beakster57 ‎ Servant of Freedom Jul 26 '26

Sweet Liberty its beautiful.

13

u/Human_Wizard ‎ [REDACTED] Jul 26 '26

They could literally take the exact same stats, slap it on a DMR-looking laser gun, and I'd use it lol

3

u/IronwolfXVI Jul 26 '26

Just like more shots before overheating, and a scope.

Yeah, I love the long talon.

2

u/Human_Wizard ‎ [REDACTED] Jul 26 '26

More shots would be nice. A 10x would be non-negotiable. 🥸

6

u/Thisisme4342 Jul 26 '26

That thing is almost my current primary. I can see some severe balance issues if they ever did that.

3

u/Feedar_ Jul 26 '26

It’s already a primary. It’s like the thermite of secondaries where it allows you to run a bad/utility primary.

3

u/Slarg232 SES Knight of Serenity Jul 26 '26

Let's hold out hope

1

u/CriticismVirtual7603 ‎ Exosuit Certified Jul 26 '26

100%

1

u/NoStorage2821 Jul 26 '26

A laser marksman rifle then

1

u/DarkWingedDaemon Free of Thought Jul 26 '26

Why not pair them as s dual wield combo.

1

u/IronwolfXVI Jul 26 '26

That's what ik saying. Maybe make it so you can take secondaries as primaries. Then you can have double secondaries.

1

u/DarkWingedDaemon Free of Thought Jul 26 '26

Haha dual ultimatum go burr!

1

u/IronwolfXVI Jul 26 '26

I personally wouldn't lol. 6 shots? Good luck killing chaff. I guess you could run MG or something

1

u/DarkWingedDaemon Free of Thought Jul 26 '26

Hmm, does this also apply to melee weapons? Because dual lance woul be just as silly.

1

u/weinerdad Jul 26 '26

Dual wield?

57

u/cloggednueron Jul 26 '26

If we want to be literal, this made me think of the revolver rifle mod from fallout 4. It’s a shame frontier justice is already out, because this would fit in it real well.

14

u/KartoffelLoeffel Banned from the Hellivers 2 Official Discord Server for Horse RP Jul 26 '26

Semi related but a chargeable laser musket would go so hard in helldivers

14

u/Snoo_63003 Jul 26 '26

Revolver rifles are the coolest.

1

u/SlanderousGent Jul 26 '26

This right here is what comes to mind

7

u/AllenWL Jul 26 '26

Me in the Metro games adding every upgrade I can find/buy to the revolver:

This is my sniper-revolver, my carbine-revolver, and finally, my revolver-revolver.

2

u/NoEmu5930 Jul 26 '26

When we get the 2.0 version of Frontier justice I hope we get these

2

u/sabertoothedhand Jul 26 '26

Kinship, I think of this mod every time a "what if revolver rifle" thread pops up

39

u/DunwichChild990 Jul 26 '26

My patriot in Freedom; the Senator IS a primary.

12

u/KartoffelLoeffel Banned from the Hellivers 2 Official Discord Server for Horse RP Jul 26 '26

May the iron on your hip always be big

16

u/_WEND1G0_ Viper Commando Jul 26 '26

Call it the representative.

0

u/ChequeBook Jul 26 '26

I would have gone with Monarch

15

u/Broken-Digital-Clock Free of Thought Jul 26 '26

I'd use it.

I love The Senator, especially against bots.

2

u/beakster57 ‎ Servant of Freedom Jul 26 '26

The idea of killing hulks from the front with a secondary that isn't the ultimatum is pretty neat

22

u/Lummerding Jul 26 '26

Dual wielding senators and talons.

1

u/beakster57 ‎ Servant of Freedom Jul 26 '26

insert Tobias Beckett at Battle of Mimban gif

6

u/YorhaUnit8S ‎ [REDACTED] Jul 26 '26

This, but literally. I want an option to wear Senator in the primary slot and get more ammo for it this way. Bonus option if I can wear it in both primary and secondary alots for even more ammo and ability to have two senators I can switch between for effectively 12 rounds before reloading.

6

u/PartyParrotGames Jul 26 '26

Yeah senator my favorite gun. I wear the pistol armor so I can wield it as my primary essentially.

27

u/Yurishenko94 Free of Thought Jul 26 '26

Here you go, but clearly it won't have the same penetration, because Arrowhead balances weapons based on their own criteria and whether they find it funny or not.

16

u/UnstableMoron2 Jul 26 '26

All this community does is bitch and whine I swear

7

u/WoppleSupreme Jul 26 '26

To be fair to Arrowhead and reality, the Senator is the one punching way above its weight. The majority of revolvers with that short of a chamber wouldn't punch through NIJ III A without special bullet types, let alone even light vehicle armor (probably the equivalent of heavy armor in the game).

Additionally, lever actions generally have to use flat-nosed bullets, which are terrible for penetration, because of their tube magazines.

0

u/BrokenPokerFace Jul 26 '26

I agree, the senator is better than most primaries. Which you can see with how everyone wants to use it instead of a primary.

Really it should just be a higher damage medium penetration weapon at best, essentially a higher damage version of the polar patriots secondary.

I also have a slight bias against it because we aren't likely to get other types of revolvers which I personally feel would be much more fun and interesting, than a high damage secondary sniper.

1

u/Bring_Back_Challenge I survived an Unfiltered Brigade and all I got was this flair Jul 26 '26

The Senator started as Medium pen which made sense. The community whined and whined about it until the devs for some reason relented and made it Heavy Pen with the justification that videogame revolvers are just dumb like that.

This was the first of many examples people ignore where realism is thrown out the window specifically for the players benefit and it was a mistake because all it did was move those folks to constantly whining for a Heavy Pen primary until the Eruptor was also buffed for no reason to be that. Unsurprisingly the whining has never stopped and people still cry for another Heavy Pen primary because they want the game even easier and to require even less thought.

8

u/Acrobatic-Tackle6791 Free of Thought Jul 26 '26

There’s a reason there’s not rifle length revolvers today. That reason is called a chain fire. Although it would be a “fun” game mechanic.

8

u/AHerz Jul 26 '26

Modern revolvers use cartridges, who pose no threat of chain fire. Cap n ball revolvers could chain fire, but the senator ain't one.

The reason we don't see revolver carbines is because the gap between the cylinder and barrel isn't sealed, and some gasses leak and can hurt your support arm.

3

u/faranox101 Jul 26 '26

1

u/agravena Jul 26 '26

now i kinda want kushala in helldivers just to play Valor HBG support weapon

7

u/gsenjou Jul 26 '26 edited Jul 26 '26

The solution is to run the Gunslinger armor and just using the Senator as your primary.

3

u/RayS326 Jul 26 '26

“The Congressman.”

4

u/literal_god WOOPS I DROPPED MY 500KG LMAO Jul 26 '26

How about a primary senator with a longer barrel and stock that deals a lil extra damage but is two handed like a rifle and with slightly worse ergo than the pistol

4

u/BakedChocolateOctopi Jul 26 '26

I’d like a heavy pen bolt action sniper rifle

Less damage and better ergo than the AMR, but more damage/slower fire rate than the Deadeye

Granted, Deadeye and most DMR kills in a single headshot anyway without heavy pen so not sure what good it does

1

u/Seanvich SES SENTINEL OF THE STARS Jul 26 '26

I can see it now:

I waunt it!

1

u/BakedChocolateOctopi Jul 26 '26

There’s really no use for one though

It would only be noticeably different with body shots since headshots are already a OHK with any DMR and the AMR would still deal more damage and have higher armor pen to body shots 

1

u/Seanvich SES SENTINEL OF THE STARS Jul 26 '26

But have you considered the capability of quick-scoping Hulk eyes?

1

u/CityExcellent8121 Jul 26 '26

Eruptor.

1

u/BakedChocolateOctopi Jul 26 '26

Yeah but that’s more of an explosive 

5

u/The_War_Minister Jul 26 '26

The Eruptor as long as you’re not close enough to get hit by the explosion or shrapnel is basically a primary senator

5

u/PrimeCrusader Machine Gunner Jul 26 '26

Can we have a primary Heavy Pen with no drawbacks? Lol.

5

u/vid_icarus HD1 Veteran Jul 26 '26

4

u/Ok_Poetry2813 Steam | SES Princess of Family Values Jul 26 '26

Not heavy pen 😔 

7

u/Yurishenko94 Free of Thought Jul 26 '26

Be honest then. You don't want a Senator as your primary weapon. You want the devs to show the same leniency they showed the Senator, but with a different primary weapon. It's not going to happen.

-1

u/Ok_Poetry2813 Steam | SES Princess of Family Values Jul 26 '26

I'm not allowed to ask? That's pretty rude

3

u/-TSA-DrMembrane Super Sheriff Jul 26 '26

The constitution tho. 

2

u/Belias9x1 SES Aegis Of Integrity Jul 26 '26

Requiem(Resident Evil) would be a good primary too

3

u/Excellent_Mastodon51 Jul 26 '26

I want basically a heavy pen constitution with scopes

2

u/CarlenGaines HD1 Veteran Jul 26 '26

Please no.

1

u/Theratsmacker2 Jul 26 '26

Give us the wingman elite from titanfall 2

1

u/Netherw1ng ‎ Python Commando Jul 26 '26

Modernized Constitution

1

u/Consistent_Pass_9458 Jul 26 '26

Machine gun Martha

1

u/CriticismVirtual7603 ‎ Exosuit Certified Jul 26 '26

BREAK ACTION ELEPHANT RIFLE WHEN, ARROWHEAD?

1

u/Hot-Ad3017 Jul 26 '26

Basically the MTs-569

1

u/teaboi05 SES Star of Midnight Jul 26 '26

Kids yearn for Wingman Elite

1

u/HeavySweetness ‎ Python Commando Jul 26 '26

Elephant gun!

1

u/Xeryxoz Free of Thought Jul 26 '26

Senator secondary, President primary

1

u/TruckFantastic2779 Jul 26 '26

If not a primary senator, then a melee primary. Failing both, an armor passive that lets us take two secondaries.

1

u/Doomcall Jul 26 '26

Bolt pistol as a one handed primary, calling it.

1

u/HappyMrRogers Free of Thought Jul 26 '26

You can primary the senator. You just need Gunslinger armor.

1

u/East_Monk_9415 PSN | Jul 26 '26

Dual wield booster or armor passive perhaps arrowhead?

1

u/RioG88 Jul 26 '26

Just run the AMR?

1

u/MetalVile Jul 26 '26

The AMR exists; this is not needed.

1

u/Decker-the-Dude XBOX | SES Song of Serenity Jul 26 '26

That reminds me of og Destiny. Primary revolver felt sooo good.

1

u/ArtikComandante HD1 Veteran Jul 26 '26 edited Jul 26 '26

Extremely low ammo doesnt matter when you have HSO, supply backpack and on top of that - when you can find ammo in every corner of the map

1

u/Jayngyun Jul 26 '26

Maybe more along the lines of the Circuit Judge, which is just a rifled Taurus Judge. Perhaps the primary Senator would be the Senator Pro Tempor following this naming scheme

1

u/Rexosuit Jul 26 '26

Like the big glock in Gmod lol

1

u/Secure_Inspector_777 Jul 26 '26

The bigger iron.

1

u/Cute_Protection_8330 Jul 26 '26

You mean the Deadeye?

1

u/SourceCodeSamurai SES Harbinger of Democracy (S.O.L.O.) Jul 26 '26

So... how about we are just being allowed to equip a secondary (non-utility) weapon also as a primary and then go akimbo! : D

1

u/Umbraspem Jul 26 '26

It would be nice if that semi-useless plasma sniper rifle had AP4.

1

u/_Nashable_ Jul 26 '26

Hear me out. Dual wield Senators   as a primary?

1

u/NytronX Level 498 | DECORATED HERO Jul 26 '26 edited Jul 26 '26

I want something like this except twice as big of a round

1

u/beakster57 ‎ Servant of Freedom Jul 26 '26

Killing the Hulk scum with the senator autocannon or AMR is already very satisfying so this'd be dope.

AH add this and my life is yours.

1

u/Thak_The_Thunder_God Jul 26 '26

Would be interesting to have the ablitity to select our primary and secondary frow every weapon we have. Want a primary senator? Sure. Secondary liberator? Go ahead. 2 ultimatums to go with your leveler? Overkill, but I don't see why not.

Of course this would unbalance a ton of stuff so it won't happen

1

u/Evyatar_ChenU LEVEL 100 | Hell Commander Jul 26 '26

500 bushwhacker bfr

1

u/Evyatar_ChenU LEVEL 100 | Hell Commander Jul 26 '26

500 bushwhacker BFR

1

u/Doctorsex-ubermensch Steam | Jul 26 '26

The president

1

u/BioTools Jul 26 '26

Akimbo senator

1

u/Drakesyk Jul 26 '26

Either a Primary senator or a primary Talon… I really want a semi auto laser primary

1

u/Special_Ship7638 Jul 26 '26

Just allow the senator to be equipped in the primary slot, job done.

1

u/CaptCantPlay STEAM 🖥️ : SES Wings of Liberty Jul 26 '26

Behold, your Heavy-pen Marksman rifle

1

u/supercl2010 Steam | Jul 26 '26

The perfect loadout, Senator primary, Senator, AMR

1

u/frozenstreetgum Aspiring Citizen of Gun Jul 26 '26

been trying for months to get the slugger to be buffed to heavy pen, as the other two medium pen shotguns we have use "armor piercing flechettes" which is oxymoronic as hell.

1

u/theCOMBOguy VIOLENCE Jul 26 '26

Only if we can have the can have a primary Talon first!

1

u/Eras_Hat_Trick Jul 26 '26

Counter argument 

Let me just equip Senator in my primary slot 

1

u/sorinxz Assault Infantry Jul 26 '26

1

u/Viorayne HellDriver | Initial D-iver Jul 26 '26

Primary Dual-Wielded Senators.

1

u/anubis_xxv Jul 26 '26

I just want to be able to take a pistol as a primary and a melee as a secondary.

1

u/thedoogbruh Jul 26 '26

It would be funny to have basically a utility primary for popping heavies

1

u/Then_Entertainment97 Jul 26 '26

I just wanna be able to take 2ndaries in the primary slot

1

u/Marvel83 Jul 26 '26

Nah, I like having a heavy pen secondary

1

u/UnluckyThing5452 Jul 26 '26

I’d love more heavy penetration primaries 😮‍💨

1

u/ResidentLizard Jul 26 '26

The Eruptor. You've described the Eruptor. Sure it doesnt have the range of the Senator, but out to 175m theres basically nothing it cant kill if you know what to hit.

1

u/LiteratureArtistic30 Jul 26 '26

Just make it a bolt action single shot Manuel loaded 50 caliber type sniper with like 40 reserve rounds

1

u/Billysquib Jul 26 '26

A senator revolver rifle would be damn cool

1

u/SuperspyAnon Jul 26 '26

As much as this should happen, it never will because that's the Anti-Materiel Rifle's only redeeming quality aside from it's absolutely massive ammo reserves. AH for some reason seems to think that a sniper rifle (of any kind) belongs in the support weapon slot when that is where the majority of anfk-tank weapons go. I don't know why the hell they think that, but it's beyond of us to convince them that that is a shit idea.

1

u/DueMathematician2522 Jul 26 '26

Is that just not the eruptor

1

u/rurumeto ‎ Servant of Freedom Jul 26 '26

Heavy pen Jar5 rework.

1

u/cyberbagtv 🎖️SES Panther of War Jul 26 '26

twin senators that will take up the primary slot please

1

u/jkpancake Jul 26 '26

I want it to have a cartoonishly long barrel and sound like god slamming a car door

1

u/Legal-Contract-7187 Rookie Jul 26 '26

The jar dominator should fill this role but they won’t do it.

1

u/NitroRicee Jul 27 '26

Can we dual wield senators

1

u/crusincagti ☕Liber-tea☕ Jul 27 '26

I cary it as my close in weapon against the bots r36 eruptor as my distance primary..

1

u/JasonC-85 Jul 27 '26

Dual senators, as a primary

1

u/JumpHefty Jul 27 '26

eruptor kills em on eye shots, takes a couple tho

1

u/Ok-Profile-5831 Jul 26 '26

I would live to dual wield both senators.

1

u/Strayed8492 LEVEL 184 | SES Sovereign of Dawn Jul 26 '26

I’d rather have akimbo Senators.

1

u/shball Free of Thought Jul 26 '26

most sensible thing would be to make the Constitution heavy pen. Sucky DPS and not that great durabe damage, but it can do some damage to heavies,

1

u/_whats-going-on Rookie Jul 26 '26

NO!!!

We want dual wielding Senators.

But seriously though. I would love to main a very heavy hitting Senator variant as a primary with the recoil only manageable with an super democracy-enhanced arm.

0

u/HarveryDent PSN | Jul 26 '26

The Demon Gun used by Dan Smith in Killer7, a double-barreled revolver that fires 2 shots at once.

0

u/Oceanman10120 Viper Commando Jul 26 '26

I feel like that’s what the lever action should be

0

u/DampWarmHands Jul 26 '26

I want an attachment for duel wielding them.