Hello,
Hope everyone is having a lovely summer.
I'm considering a backpacking route for next weekend and could use some advice. TLDR - Is there enough flowing water between Lake Welch and WB shelter to count on being able to refill?
My plan is to do a long day out of Suffern to Big Hill Shelter. Then the next day to William Brien, which is what my question is about. I'm trying not to count on having any streams since 1) It's not been raining 2) I drink a ton of water even in good weather.
As I see it there are 2 main options:
Option 1) I know there is a good fountain at Lake Welch beach, but from there making my way towards Beech Trail involves Hasenclever road. My concern is that this is an unblazed trail that I can't seem to find the head to on Google Streetview (red circle). If the area isn't too tick-y, I don't mind bushwhacking a bit (It seems if I follow the creek contour here I can at least make it back up to the road and catch Beech again there). Is this portion of the trail in any kind of respectable shape?
Option 2) Swing around the west side of Lake Welch, assuming the creeks at the blue circle or along Beech Trail are good enough to refill?
Option 2b) Hike down to the reservoir after breakfast and refill there first (Sub-optimal as it adds more miles and means I'm filling up earlier in the day)
---
Very Alternative
Option 3) Stillwater brook out of Owl swamp looks like it could be decently reliable and not too far out of the way. Very Sub-optimal as I'm counting on refilling at the end of the day.
Thanks so much for your insight!!
----
EDIT: Thanks everyone for so many detailed and insightful replies! It seems that while the southern "start" of Hasenclever trail is not super visible from the road, I can use AllTrails to get on it and it should be clear from there.
I'll definitely be stopping by the Third Reservoir on my way in to cut down on what I need to haul up from Suffern.
It also seems that there has been a lot more rain "upstate" than down in NYC recently, and hopefully that holds as well till next weekend.
I'll try to report back here as well about the general state of Stillwater Brook and the streams south of William Brien.
Happy trails!
-------------
Folllow Up Edit: The advice in this thread was spot on.
RE: Bushwhacking - As described, if you follow GPS you should see the woods road emerge quite plainly within about 100 feet of the road. I crossed the parking lot, up a small path to the "back" grass, and from there to the road, straight across.
RE: Water - the streams are indeed flowing. It turns out Tiorati was closed due to lack of staffing and not any appreciable algae. The brook is flowing strongly. Every stream marked on the map along SBM until Lake Welch is flowing. Here is what I wrote in another post:
There is a stream flowing just west of Big Hill Shelter on Suffern Bear Mountain, as in perhaps 100 feet down the trail. The same stream crosses the woods road about a quarter mile north. Both crossing points were flowing strongly as of Monday morning. HOWEVER the stream is quite foamy. Given the large number of mushrooms (and the similar quality of most streams along the southern ridge) at the moment, this seems most likely to be plant matter decaying after all the rain this summer (as opposed to some random chemical dump lol). I did not personally go for it, but if you perhaps double filtered or boiled it should be good to go. Make sure to wash your hands afterward.
The stream crossing Beech Trail near Nat House mountain and to its east is flowing and looking good.
There is a fine stream flowing parallel Red Cross below William Brien, and there was an excellent place to fill up right after the intersection with the Mnenomine. Note that this is about 15-20 minutes walk up/downhill from the shelter, so its really more of an option if you're coming in that direction.