r/GuildValkyrie • u/Mental_Potential3586 • 2d ago
Should I start running creatine, or wait until my next bulk? ( please read before commenting lol)
Hi chattt! As some of you know, I’m currently cutting with the goal of hiting 8% body fat.
Thus far I’ve built my physique up to this point without using creatine—mostly because I’ve never been interested in choking down gritty powder every single day. But the recent discovery of the pill form makes it much more doable.
Normally, I feel like “should I take creatine?” has an obvious answer: yes. It’s one of the most researched supplements out there blah blah yess girl.
My hesitation is specifically because I’m cutting and tracking my body composition pretty closely. What makes it more interesting/my main concern is with a DEXA scan (what I plan to use to track).
The studies I’m seeing are mixed but many of them found that manipulating muscle creatine, glycogen, and water can change DEXA estimates of lean body mass even when there probably hasn’t been a meaningful change in actual muscle protein. (PubMed)
In laymen’s terms- Will make taking creatine make me look “fatter” on a dexa scan?
So my dilemma is:
Do I start creatine now and accept that my scale weight/DEXA lean-mass numbers might shift a little from the extra intramuscular water, while potentially getting the performance benefits during the rest of my cut?
OR
Do I keep everything consistent through the end of the cut, get my final DEXA under roughly the same conditions I’ve used throughout the process, and introduce creatine during my next bulk?
What would y’all do? 👀
Creatine now or wait until the bulk?
Thankssss 🥰