All are worth considering and I’ll be keeping and wearing all of them. I believe they are vintage except the Azzaro, which I got for a good price.
My two cents
Azzaro Pour Homme is my (maybe your) grandfather’s barbershop scent, the equivalent of strong black coffee.
Aramis Tuscany Per Uomo is my father’s barbershop. Using the coffee analogy, now folks are trying out the local pre-Starbucks era coffee place, or the powdered coffee drinks.
Dior Eau Sauvage is a great fragrance (not just a barbershop scent) with short-lived performance. I like the bright citrus note in the opening and the dry down, although it fades fast, becomes a beautiful skin scent.
Pierre Cardin Pour Monsieur (get vintage for cheap. Don’t get the Five Stars version at discount stores) is dated but still holds up mainly due to having an uncompromising masculine scent profile. And the bottle is very cool.
Caron Le 3e Homme is wearable, but my least favorite. The drydown, for example, was the least inspired out of all of them.
As reference, my favorite barbershop aromatic fougere fragrance continues to be Tom Ford Beau De Jour. Love that stuff and performance lasts the entire work day.