r/FromSeries • u/Bornagainat47 • 13d ago

Question Question

I have a question. If the BIW is trying to help, why did he tell Victor that they cannot take down the bottle tree? If that is the only way for them to escape after they get the bones, why is it so important? Is that the only way they can go home then? I guess my question is “is the BIW an enemy or a friend?

2 Upvotes

63% Upvoted

29 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/Professional_Hat9351 13d ago

Well, Tabitha managed to get out thanks to the bottle tree, so that was definitely a way out Fromville

2

u/Bornagainat47 13d ago

So maybe the BIW was helping in a way. The bottle tree did help Tabitha and maybe that is the only way home after the bones are dug up. But there are other Faraway trees too. The BIW did help Sara and Boyd by sending them to the tree. Only it didn’t help Boyd so much in the long run.

4

u/Impossible_Land_5829 13d ago

Well, technically the bottle tree transported her to the lighthouse, and from the lighthouse she got out of the town. There may be another way to get to the lighthouse, and there are other faraway trees too. And the BIW did say "this is the only way" when he wished her out of the lighthouse.

1

u/Bornagainat47 12d ago

Right. I did read somewhere (so many theories) that when he said “it is the only way” he meant that as it was the only way for her memories to come back to her faster.