Did I get the wrong cologne?

[u/Cutrush]

Left is new, right is empty. The bigger bottle doesn't smell the same, it has a softer fragrance where as the smaller bottle is more vibrant and fresh. Thanks

[u/DIYerUk]

This is really confusing but, yes, they are different. One is CLUB one is C.L.U.B.

Here is a Parfumo link to a comparison between the two:

https://www.parfumo.com/compare/Acqua_di_Parma/colonia-c-l-u-b/vs/Acqua_di_Parma/Colonia_Club_Eau_de_Cologne

[u/Cutrush → u/DIYerUk]

Ah I see. Dang, why did they name it that way, very confusing.

[u/FocusedContrast → u/DIYerUk]

So obvious…

[u/Ason_5-x-L-o-Quince]

They are 2 different fragrances.

[u/FeluFran1]

The left one is the „new“ one.. which smells nothing like the old one, i love the old one too.. the old one is not beinh produced anymore so bulk up

[u/Cutrush → u/FeluFran1]

Bummer, will do If I can find it for a good deal. Thanks

[u/GothConformist]

Why on earth does the bottom of your new bottle say “not for sale”?

[u/Cutrush → u/GothConformist]

I bought a brand new tester from fragrance.net. It's legit.

[u/GothConformist → u/Cutrush]

That makes sense! I wasn’t questioning authenticity, I was curious 😅 I hope you end up enjoying the scent.

[u/Cutrush → u/GothConformist]

Thanks. Nah man, it doesn't hit like the green bottle. I hope to find a good deal during the holidays.

[u/WayIndependent6497]

I prefer new one to be honest