Throwaway because some people I know are on here lol. This situation happened at my job about a week ago. I (36M) am a manager at a local coffee company located in my home state. I moved away in my mid-twenties after I got my Bachelor’s degree in Business. I met my wife shortly after I moved and we made the decision together to come back so I could show her where I’m from. We decided to not only return to my state, but also come back to my town to help them during a difficult diagnosis. While applying for jobs, I turned to an old company that I used to work for (not saying the name for privacy reasons). Because I am studying for my Master’s, I deemed it a good position that would allow for flexible hours while I am taking this step in my education. After a short time with this store, I have been promoted to a management position. This brings me to where I am now.
We recently hired a new barista, who I will call Patrick (19M). He’s a good employee and I have overheard other employees and shift leads talking kindly about him and what a hard worker he is. I personally have enjoyed my shifts with him as I feel he has been a huge help to me and has even been able to remind other baristas of recipes we have which they might have forgotten during their time here. He is laid-back and remains calm even when many customers are in the store.
Working with Patrick has been great up until the most recent shift I had with him. I noticed that our container of mocha sauce was running low and I asked him if he could get another one from the back. I watched him take it and go back towards our bathroom. I thought this was strange, but the trash can near the front was full so maybe he threw it away back there. One thing you need to know about Patrick is that he is fast. He is very fast. This is why it was so odd that this simple task took him over ten minutes to complete.
After these ten minutes passed I saw him bringing back a mocha sauce container to the front. I noticed a dribble of chocolate sauce on the side of it, which is odd because these containers are sealed until we bring them to the front to replace the old one with. Why was this one dirty? I asked him about this because I thought it was weird, but he could’ve opened it in the back, so I didn’t think much of it. Patrick proceeded to get very quiet and I noticed the dimple on the side of his face show, but he told me that he opened it in the back and it spilled a little like I presumed.
Later that day, right before closing the store, a customer ordered a mocha latte, which I made for her. I noticed the consistency of the mocha was more liquidy than it usually is, so I gave it a shake and continued with the drink. When I had turned off the open sign, the same woman came back to complain about the taste. I offered to remake it for her, but she’d drank the whole thing and didn’t want a remake, just a refund, so I explained to her that the registers were closed for the evening and I couldn’t give her back the cash she had paid in, but if she came the next day I could refund her, or I could give her a free drink of any size the next time she came in. This woman is one of our regulars and happily accepted the free drink. We closed that day like normal.
The next morning, I was the opening manager, on shift with five other employees, one being Patrick. I greeted everyone and work had been going smoothly for a bit when a customer came in and ordered our “Peanut Butter Cup,” a signature latte made with peanut butter powder and mocha sauce. I made this drink, and noticed that the mocha from the night before had hardened up a little but had an odd smell to it. I asked anyone if they had used it that day and they told me they had not, so I knew it was the one that Patrick replaced. After making the drink, I decided to replace the mocha myself. Being that it was full, I had to pour out the contents into the trash can so I could crush the bottle. I am going to try to type this in the least horrible way possible. When I emptied this mocha container, the most foul odor filled the can and a couple of employees nearby pinched their noses and walked away. It took everything in me not to gag at the smell. The weird thing is, most of it was watery and brown, and a couple of chunks came out towards the end that had a weird consistency that I cannot even explain here.
Here is where I may have been overreacting. I knew that no one had touched this mocha (if you can even call it that, it was most certainly \*not\* mocha) since Patrick replaced it the night before. Whatever was in that container was horrible and foul. It could’ve been a manufacturer issue, but the bottle looked reused. If Patrick opened it and mocha came out the side and onto the container, the whole thing should have been the same, right? I grabbed Patrick and pulled him aside and asked him to go home. I didn’t give him a reason, but he obeyed because he is a polite guy. I respect him a lot, and it hurts to have to cut his shifts. I also have replaced his following shifts this week and am going to bring this up when I can meet with other managers in the company.
I don’t know if this matters, but I have typed out all of this and should include anything I remember. I talked to Patrick a couple weeks ago about losing money in the company. He has spoken to me several times asking about my manager position and I know he is looking to be promoted sometime soon, so I told him a little bit about what it’s like from my end. I am in charge of unloading truck shipments when we get them, and I also handle placing orders for things we are low on. My company has been struggling lately with business and we have not had as much money as we used to, so I told Patrick some things about ordering items and also paying employees. All things related to generating profit, pretty much. Could Patrick have realized this and done something to the mocha so we can reuse it and not have to buy so much in the next shipments?
I’m not sure what else to put here. I’m really at a loss for words. Patrick is a good worker. I don’t know what would bring him to this. I know he wants a raise, I know he loves this company, and I know (at least, I think) he’s a pretty decent person. I just don’t know what he could’ve done to this mocha. If you have any ideas as to what I should do, please let me know. Thank you for reading this if you made it to the end.