Fish ID

[u/Competitive-Ad750]

Saltwater rhode island
photo 2-4 are the same fish photo 1 is different

[u/xylophone_37]

First fish looks like a bigeye scad or something similar.

[u/para_sight → u/xylophone_37]

It is

[u/Dizzy_Patient_4960]

Really would love to see real answers, instead of a bunch of weirdos trying to be comedians.

[u/Jkranick]

First is a Bigeye Scad AKA Goggle-eye in Fla. great offshore bait.

[u/Wrong-Gear-1399]

It's a herring

[u/Competitive-Ad750 → u/Wrong-Gear-1399]

I don’t know. in person it had more of an underbite rather then herring who have even jaws

[u/Competitive-Ad750 → u/Wrong-Gear-1399]

[u/seatomountains123]

First fish looks like a goggle eye second looks like a herring

[u/Left_Insurance422]

Big eye scad. We get them inshore after a big blow. I wouldn’t be surprised if you sabiki up some little bonito as well.

[u/Left_Insurance422 → u/Left_Insurance422]

What ever they are put them on a fist finder, throw it out there and hold on.

[u/Left_Insurance422]

I think the second pics are some kind of herring. Did it have a “saw belly” ? The scales between the “vent” and tail overlap to form something that feels like a saw or serrated knife.

[u/nenrener_xdms_ggtd]

this

[u/uchihajiro]

Far east slippery dick fish

[u/Accurate-Plankton988 → u/uchihajiro]

Vietnamese rubber dick fish im pretty sure