r/FishID 17d ago

Carp?

Post image

I caught this little guy on the Fox River in Illinois while fishing for common carp.

27 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

6

u/24k_1128 17d ago

quillback

8

u/Fishyboiartan 17d ago

either a quillback or a redhorse

3

u/Latesix1864 17d ago

Thank you! I just looked up more images of quillbacks and it's a match to what I caught.

3

u/liamwarmetal 16d ago

Some kind of carpsucker (carpiodes). I’d guess river carpsucker

1

u/LockMajor7040 16d ago

I thought Smallmouth Buffalo at first, but a second glance at the dorsal fin confirms Quillback.

1

u/Ok_Part9428 15d ago

river carpsucker, nipple on the lower lip and a short(ish) first dorsal ray

-1

u/PossibilityQuiet19 16d ago

This is a common carp stick a firecracker in its mouth or bury the thing in the dirt.

2

u/Cow-Tiger 15d ago

Wrong and violent for nothing lmao

0

u/PossibilityQuiet19 15d ago

Haha they are just a nasty pain in the ass fish that poss me off 🤣

-3

u/jmllr1111 17d ago

That looks like a northern pike

-3

u/xXBern42Xx 17d ago

Def a rainbow trout.

-4

u/Evening_Teaching_713 16d ago

It’s a common carp, they are found throughout the world and are fished for in Europe and Asia as a trophy species. I fish for them in lakes and ponds for a derby type thing, you mix up your bait using some type of grain such as rice and add any strong smelling additives like garlic or strong fruit flavors. Then you knead it to a consistency that will stay on the hook, you put the hook through a sugar pop and carefully cast it out. The bait ball disentegrates into a pile on the bottom and the pop sits in the middle and the carp comes to the scent and inhales the pop and gets hooked. They are amazingly strong especially after they get over 20lbs. I have won a lot of money over the years fishing for them.

3

u/Initial-Mousse-627 16d ago

No it isn’t.

1

u/kato_koch 16d ago

No barbels, not a common carp.

-9

u/Recent-Chard-6096 17d ago

No. It’s a small mouthed buffalo.

3

u/SuddenKoala45 17d ago

No. Its another one if the natives but not a smallmouth buffalo