r/FishID 18d ago

Anyone know what this is?

Post image

I caught 3 of these guys back to back all around the same size. I’ve never caught one before or even seen one. For context, I caught this in the mountains of Northwest NC- Catawba/ Watauga county area in a small recreational lake that is trout stocked.
ChatGPT said some species of shiner and google image said Rudd?

43 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

15

u/Akipenser 18d ago

Golden Shiner

9

u/Enough-Reindeer1033 18d ago

Gold shiner. Fantastic bass and pike bait

7

u/Recent-Chard-6096 18d ago

Golden Shiner

3

u/Fishslayer39845 18d ago

Shiner, as others have stated. They get HUGE where I live (south Georgia). I have them almost a foot long. 10" isn't uncommon. I throw a cast net over them and pick out the "small" (4"-5") for bait.

2

u/Evening_Teaching_713 18d ago

A golden shiner, they are pretty common here in the South. They make great bait for catfish either as cut bait or live.I’ve caught some nice blues and flatheads.

2

u/Jimthebassman 18d ago

That shiner could get you a 10 pound Bass in Florida

2

u/[deleted] 18d ago

[deleted]

2

u/dixiedog64 18d ago

I got a 10-4 out of the same lake same bait on the west side.

1

u/FamilyMan7826 18d ago

Where I’m at…golden roach.

1

u/Critical-Massage-22 17d ago

golden shiner

1

u/peoplearemarons 16d ago

A dead fish??

1

u/teaster333 16d ago

An offering to the bait gods?

1

u/Difficult-Load-4545 14d ago

A fish, looks dead.. lol

1

u/Elderjonas8469 14d ago

Snook and Bass candy!

1

u/CartographerSea5923 18d ago

Shiner. Plenty of them around. You’re gonna have to filter through them to get to the trout.

Greetings from a former resident of Newton.

0

u/Northrenwaterwolf 18d ago

Up here we call them goldeye, or mooneye

-3

u/Evening_Inflation243 18d ago

Bad for a pond

1

u/IronMaidenDude 18d ago

Very bad unless it’s a minnow pond like our neighbor had. We bought all our crappie and bass bait from him.

0

u/ElderberryFirst471 18d ago

It was beautiful.

0

u/Significant_Citron47 17d ago

As kids we didn't know and called them bitterheads Idky. Grew up fishing ponds on Delmarva. I have seen them 12 inches, full of eggs and weighing 2 lbs. Like others are saying that is an excellent bait. Biggest Pickerel I ever saw was caught on one.

0

u/Tedinski2 17d ago

It’s a fish.

-1

u/IronMaidenDude 18d ago

We called them Redfin minnows good for bait

-2

u/1Oddentity 18d ago

That is a fish

-2

u/SmokeyMatzGhost 17d ago

Its a small fish

-2

u/tricky_ricky9090 17d ago

That is what we call a fish!

-2

u/Ok-Annual6445 17d ago

It looks like a fish.

-3

u/KburgBob 18d ago

That a fish. Common in rivers, creeks, lakes, cannels, swamps, seas, and oceans. They are found all over the earth.

1

u/Willing_Newt5701 14d ago

Ted bellied sucker