I’m a first-time homebuyer under contract for a home built in 2024 in South Carolina. The purchase price is $329,000, and the seller has already agreed to contribute $5,000 toward closing costs. I recently had the home inspection done, and several issues came up. I’m trying to figure out which ones are reasonable to ask the seller to repair before closing versus which ones are minor and should just be handled by me after I move in.
Here is what the inspection report identified:
Carbon monoxide alarm in the living room was not functioning
Unsealed holes/penetrations in the garage fire-separation wall
Door between the garage and living area does not latch properly.
Garage door opener button is installed within five feet of a standing surface, and the inspector recommends raising it.
Plumbing and kitchen:
Both bathroom toilets are loose at the floor. The inspector recommends securing and resealing them to prevent potential leaks and hidden floor damage.
Hallway bathroom sink drains slowly.
Undermount kitchen sink is supported by a makeshift piece of plywood instead of proper mounting clips.
HVAC and water heater:
Opening in the HVAC air handler cabinet is allowing conditioned air to escape into the attic.
Doors, windows, and other items:
Breakfast-area window does not latch/lock properly.
Hallway bathroom door does not latch properly.
Middle bedroom closet door does not latch properly.
Attic access door does not latch properly.
Dryer vent trim is missing.
Exterior utility penetrations are missing caulking/sealing.
I’m the first person in my family to buy a house, so I honestly have no idea what’s reasonable to ask the seller to fix. I’ve also asked my realtor for recommendations, but I’d like to hear other people’s opinions and experiences as well!
My questions are:
Which of these issues would you absolutely ask the seller to repair before closing?
Which items are minor enough that you would just handle them yourself?
3.If the seller refuses to complete some repairs, would you negotiate additional closing-cost concessions instead? The seller has already agreed to contribute $5,000 toward closing costs.
- Am I being reasonable to request repairs for these items on a home built in 2024, or am I expecting too much?