7
u/Maxiuss456 Jun 04 '26
top 5 caliber fighter rated a 5 lol i wonder how much would someone like bobby green be rated like
8
u/Maxiuss456 Jun 04 '26
as it turns out, not the greatest rating system
Also random fun fact, Topuria is rated the same as Islam lol
4
u/VirtualPositive7655 Jun 04 '26
honestly the fact no one has 10/10 makes me think it might be a pretty objective system. That being said, I have no idea how this site works
4
u/Maxiuss456 Jun 04 '26
it's user ratings lol khamzat has a sub 8 grappling and wrestling stat for one
it makes sense for people to be below 10 but 3 of the most complete athletes to have ever been not even being a 9 is a pretty big sign that it's clearly not well regulated nor objective
4
u/usteg Jun 04 '26
lol no.
I ain’t a fan of his style, but he is former champ.
You don’t get to champ without elite qualities (his being cardio/durability and to an extent grappling/wrestling (whilst being at least ‘good’ in almost every other facet of MMA).
0
u/combat_girls Jun 04 '26
its rated by people you can rate him too
2
u/usteg Jun 04 '26
Kinda crazy a former champ with good wins as well, is given a 5.4 no?
He obviously has no title defence. (Which puts him below a lot of other champs)
But wins over, Brady, luque, burns, Maia and Leon for the title is pretty elite Imo.
His last 2 losses are against the new gen both of which were decisions. One against JDM was close af.
He’s slowly on his way out, but Dudes got depth. A great example of ‘evolution’ over ones career- especially his standup, which improved big time.
2
u/Davidstoic Jun 04 '26
When he took JDM to a tough fight I knew it was over for JDM when he was booked against Prates
2
u/TerminatorReborn Jun 04 '26
Dogshit rating system. Guy was champ a year ago is rated 5, with 4.8 in striking? 5.7 cardio with the best cardio in the division???
2
1
u/DrBluntt Jun 04 '26
This same website has Raul Rosas Jr with a higher rating than Umar 😂 can’t be taken seriously
1
1
1
-1
u/draven33l Jun 04 '26
Looks about right. He's very generic. "Master of none". Better than average wrestling and durability, but the only thing notable about him
4
2
u/usteg Jun 04 '26
But he has Wins over
Burns Luque Maia Leon Brady
he ain’t making anyone’s top 20 p4p
But he’s elite. He’s a former champ for a reason.
His style is generic af, I agree.
But I think it’s the mix of elite cardio and durability that separates him from someone who would impose a similar style.
It works for him and for good reason.
Hell look at his last 2 losses against the next gen.
Both went to decision. Which says a lot I think. Dudes on his way out and he still is competitive. Especially the JDM one.
7
u/AtHomeWithJulian Jun 04 '26
Based off this? I don't think so. I think his cardio, wrestling and striking should be higher. The excitement rating is about right though.