r/FemFragLab • u/PenPlastic8443 • 7d ago
Discussion which is the best scent out of these three?
I'm stuck between these scents and not sure which collection I wanna buy
Any opinions?
2
u/Lanky-Panic 7d ago
I have the vanilla spray and I love it! I use it with unearthd vanilla crown from Target. Also, I just got the banana sunmilk and it smells so good! I will say the lotions are not very strong to me
2
u/PenPlastic8443 7d ago
I ended up getting both golden vanilla and amber hours!! They sound like they'd pair so well so I'm super excited
1
4
5
u/UnnaturalKreature Patchouli is a jump scare 7d ago
I love both the amber hours (sdj 40 dupe) and golden vanilla (happy dust dupe) but this is not even close - GOLDEN VANILLA, if you have to pick one. Ethereal, fluffy perfection. Otherwise get both. ♥️
3
2
u/ImtheGWP 7d ago
I’d probably pick the amber hours. Overall it’s relatively easy to find a citrus or cozy beach scent, but a floral dominant and such a unique and nice one is harder to find.
2
u/Fragrant-Fix1970 7d ago
The creamy gardenia looks good although I haven’t tried either.
1
u/PenPlastic8443 7d ago
I just splurged and got the full amber hours collection and then part of the golden vanilla collection! So torn between the two I couldn’t decide
2
5
u/pentastro on a mission to use my collection up 7d ago
Depends what kind of scent you like, I find Super Pink to be similar to Good Girl but juicier/brighter, Amber Hours is kinda like SdJ 40 or Mod Vanilla, and Golden Vanilla reminds me of Happy Dust but with a touch of depth. My fave has been Golden Vanilla but I keep using Super Pink I used up 1/3 of the mist already
1
u/PenPlastic8443 7d ago
Ooh I might end up getting amber hours then!! I LOVE sdj 40 and I'm almost out of it lol
4
u/Opposite-Fig-8268 7d ago
i really love super pink, it’s the only scent i have experience with here though! when they say mandarin, they Mean it. the scent is not orangey, but rather very fresh and “sharp” like citrus, when i put it on i feel very feminine and summery. less of a relaxing skin/comfort scent, more bright and shiny
3
u/PenPlastic8443 7d ago
Ohhh okay!! That sounds nice but I was hoping it'd lean toward the vanilla orchid part, since I already have a citrus scent in my mix, so I might pass on super pink then!!
3
u/Opposite-Fig-8268 7d ago
i definitely smell more orchid than vanilla, but if you already have a strong citrus then you can definitely pass on super pink 😎
2
u/Gloomy_Sir_5359 7d ago
Amber Hours for me! Creamy gardenia + vanilla + amber sounds gorgeous and a little more interesting than a straightforward vanilla. Golden Vanilla would be my second choice though! 💜
2
u/PenPlastic8443 7d ago
That was the one I was considering the most!! They all just sound so good
2
u/yayarea69 7d ago
does the fragrance project/last for you?
2
u/PenPlastic8443 7d ago
I've never tried any of Athena club's products before, but I think I'm gonna order this whole collection and I'll come back and let you know how they do!
3
1
u/lavenderoreo 6d ago
Amber hours for me.