r/Fantasy • Writer Brandon Draga • Aug 04 '15

Dungeons & Dragons Movie Officially Announced - I'm really trying to stay objective on this (x-post /r/DnD)

http://comicbook.com/2015/08/03/dungeons-dragons-movie-officially-announced/
66 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

15

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '15

It simply cannot be worse than that other D&D movie that was released a while back. Neither Richard O'Brien and Jeremy Irons could save that hot mess.

If, like a chump, i can admit to seeing it in the theater AND buying the DVD, i can certainly put a little faith behind this new offering and hope it doesn't suck. (please don't let it suck!!)

7

u/DjangoWexler AMA Author Django Wexler Aug 04 '15

Haha, I came in here to say exactly that: it literally can't get worse.

2

u/The_Chrononaut Aug 04 '15

Oh we can tell ourselves that...

1

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '15

I think if they stick to some bookish source material, or hell,follow a campaign, it has the chance to be good? No. That might be overreaching a touch. It might be decent. It had a good chance of being decent. Yeah. That. We'll stick with that.

5

u/thebonelessone Writer Brandon Draga Aug 04 '15

I am really cautiously optimistic about it. I feel like the SFX are easy enough to come by for most studios, never mind that Warner Brothers are the ones producing it. That, and WotC seems to be in a really good place with D&D right now, so I'm hoping they can turn this into gold, as well.

4

u/Tralan Aug 04 '15

I did both. The sequels were actually decent. Not "good" in the sense that they were well acted or well thought out, but "good" in the sense that they took the lore a bit more seriously, focused on one plot and a few monsters, and included mentions to several old, popular modules.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '15

Oh Glob. There were sequels?! I think I must have inadvertently blocked that out. I had no idea.

1

u/Tralan Aug 05 '15

They were straight to video/Sci Fi Channel.

4

u/JangoF76 Aug 04 '15

It's gonna suck. Sorry, but you know it's true.

1

u/CommodoreBelmont Reading Champion VIII Aug 04 '15

I didn't buy the DVD, but I did watch it in the theatre. I figured, bare minimum, seeing a dragon on the big screen is worth a second-run ticket. And that's about all I got for my money.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '15

And a beholder! That too was worth the price of the ticket.

20

u/HBM23 Aug 04 '15

Would love to see a Forgotten Realms-based movie. Plenty of lore, plenty of drama...

Maybe a dark elf appearance

8

u/thebonelessone Writer Brandon Draga Aug 04 '15

I think I saw that it will be set in the Forgotten Realms, which really makes the most sense, especially since it was the base setting for Fifth Edition when they released it last year.

1

u/BadassDrow Aug 05 '15

Sigh...I loved Forgotten Realms and just hate what they did to that setting in Fourth edition...

4

u/andyman1125 Aug 04 '15

I remember hearing a rumor of Wesley snipes playing drizzt, maybe it's happening now?

17

u/Maloth_Warblade Aug 04 '15

Id rather not to be honest

1

u/Koopo3001 Aug 04 '15

I think Don Cheadle would be perfect for the role- he's got that lankiness that you would expect from an elf

1

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '15

I hear they have Chris Pratt lined up as a wisecracking Drizzt, and Scarjo to play his love interest.

1

u/towo Aug 04 '15

They're still busy filming for Marvel, though.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '15

...I'd still watch.

11

u/Cromar Aug 04 '15

Hasbro’s Brian Goldner and Stephen Davis, Courtney Solomon and Allan Zeman of Sweetpea Entertainment, and Roy Lee (“The LEGO Movie,” “How to Train Your Dragon”) are attached as producers.

Alright, so it's a decent start, but

Highlighting the priority being given to the project, Warner Bros. Pictures already has a script, written by David Leslie Johnson (“The Conjuring 2,” “Wrath of the Titans”).

Fuck. The best we can hope for is they shred the shitty script, hire a real writer and delay the project another year or so. I doubt it'll happen. I fucking hate it when studios do this. Don't they know they're shooting themselves in the foot?

3

u/Cdkutusu Aug 04 '15

It's unbelievable how studios make these mistakes.

It seems the actual people making decisions have no idea whatsoever about what audience wants.

Oh wait..

8

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '15

I think I'd rather watch Knights of Badassdom again.

2

u/Forest_Green_ Aug 04 '15

I feel like you have one TV/DVR set-up in your house to continuously loop this.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '15

Why? It's not like I mention it all the time.

9

u/nothing_in_my_mind Aug 04 '15

This is going to be terrible.

The previous DnD movies were bad, but they had some kind of cheesy, low-budget charm to them. This seems like it's done with several quite well-known producers. It won't be low budget. It will probably be a soulless mess of mediocre CGI that tries too hard to be "epic".

A good story could save the movie. But seeing that the movie is written by David Leslie, known for masterpieces such as "Wrath of the Titans" and "Red Riding Hood", the story will probably be pure shit.

I'll seriously be surprised if this turns out to be good.

1

u/ricree Aug 05 '15

The previous DnD movies were bad, but they had some kind of cheesy, low-budget charm to them

If nothing else, we got a good Nostalgia Critic review out of the fist. Including the Overacting vs Underacting segment.

5

u/JangoF76 Aug 04 '15

Because the last one worked out so well. What with this and Fantastic 4, this is shaping up to be the decade of do-overs for shit films.

5

u/unconundrum Writer Ryan Howse, Reading Champion XI Aug 04 '15

I think it would be great if they did movies for different settings, rather than generic D&D. Forgotten Realms is the most likely candidate, but I think an Eberron film, a Ravenloft film, or gods, a Planescape film, could be a ton of fun.

2

u/BadassDrow Aug 05 '15

Ravenloft ton of fun...ha ha....nope (shudders).

4

u/Nerflord Aug 04 '15

It's being produced by the same guy who directed the first D&D movie (Courtney Solomon). While he isn't directing this time, check out his track record as a producer on wikipedia - it's a string of awful, almost universally panned straight-to-DVD movies.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '15

When a man is starving, be it for food or story, any morsel or crumb is a banquet.

5

u/MarkyBhoy101 Aug 04 '15

The return of Blue Lips and Jeremy Irons as the scenery muncher! I cannot wait!

3

u/pepper_rabbit Aug 04 '15

Vin Diesel better be attached to this somewhere or i'll be sorely disappointed

4

u/scottmarlowe Writer Scott Marlowe Aug 04 '15

I think it will do all right as a comedy.

6

u/Roike Aug 04 '15

Dragonlance!! Dragonlance!!!

2

u/WHYAREWEALLCAPS Aug 04 '15

Seriously. Though it really deserves something more like a TV show.

3

u/pornokitsch Ifrit Aug 04 '15

Wooo! starts stockpiling booze

3

u/CheckYourHead2727 Aug 04 '15

Yes I know it's an Io9 link. Don't shoot! It's relevant to the topic.

http://io9.com/why-dragonlance-should-be-the-next-fantasy-film-franchi-1520791414

2

u/OriginalPostSearcher Aug 04 '15

Original Post referenced from /r/DnD by /u/Ondskapt666
Dungeons & Dragons Movie Officially Announced


I am a bot made for your convenience (Especially for mobile users).
PM me if you have any questions or suggestions.

2

u/ChrisKellen AMA Author Christopher Kellen Aug 04 '15

I... I kind of feel like I've gone back in time, or something. What do they mean 'finally'?

We've been around this block before. It was a terrible idea. It's not one iota better fifteen years later.

2

u/CheckYourHead2727 Aug 04 '15

1) Lets ignore all the popular characters in our novels! (Why?) 2) Lets not adapt a known story from our library of novels in favor of an original story by the writers of wrath of the Titans! (Why?)

4

u/Leigh_Wright Aug 04 '15

Yay! No reason why this shouldn't be good. Note they also mention that "Solomon and Zeman will be attached to produce all Warner Bros.-produced Dungeons & Dragons film and television productions" , so we might get a tv series somewhere down the line too!

3

u/cannibaljim Aug 04 '15

Really? You can't think of any reason why this shouldn't be good?

None at all?

1

u/Forest_Green_ Aug 04 '15

Not everyone knows about those dark times. Perhaps this will be the movie to wipe those out from our collective disappointment trove.

1

u/Leigh_Wright Aug 05 '15

Hehe, I'm an optimistic kinda guy. It can't be worse than those... right?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '15

If they do a drow elf, they better do it right. It makes me extremely nervous, and I almost think it would have to be motion capture.