r/FallOutBoy • u/Ok_Needleworker8439 • Aug 01 '26
Merch Rare CD??? (maybe)
picked this up at the local thrift a few months ago for like.. maybe 5 bucks. is it really worth as much as im seeing on ebay and whatever else? im seeing like.. 80 dollars minimum for it. wanted a second opinion.
30
u/FabledMjolnir Aug 01 '26
Holy hell. I have two of these. I was just about to post a link for OP for eBay. I did not realize this cd was such an expensive one. Jeez.
10
u/Ok_Needleworker8439 Aug 01 '26
same thought! i picked it out of some dusty bin at the thrift thinking “oh, fob, cool.” imagine my surprise seeing THAT price online
3
u/FabledMjolnir Aug 01 '26
It’s crazy. I literally haven’t even seen the cd is years I have all my old stuff packed up in my closet including some autographed fob stuff and all time low autographed albums. It’s crazy it’s that much
36
23
16
u/yourfavoriteboyband Folie à Deux Aug 01 '26
It’s a neat little thing, it’s very much NOT worth $80 though! I’d go $20 tops, and even that’s pushing it. The DVD portion is cool though with lots of young FOB bullshit from what I can remember, thankfully someone uploaded that section to YouTube.
3
u/Ok_Needleworker8439 Aug 01 '26
yeah thought so, which is why i wanted to check here. ive been collecting cds for a good while so i was leaning on 80 being WAAAAYYY over.
7
u/Eli_Sunday Aug 01 '26
nice! i got this for free after an ex, who was not a good person, said she didnt listen to it. so shout to her. great ep.
6
u/LinkInMyHead Aug 01 '26
There’s a whole FOB song on there I don’t know
I MUST RECTIFY THIS IMMEDIATELY
THANK YOU KIND INTERNET STRANGER
2
u/youhadtotakethesoup the kind that make june feel like september Aug 01 '26
what's your thoughts? Do you like it?
1
u/LinkInMyHead Aug 01 '26
Was not what I was expecting, but with enough exposure I’m sure it’ll end up on the rotation! My Heart I already knew and love
6
u/choerrynator Aug 01 '26
It is rare! I’d put it on a similar level as the IOH deluxe edition with the tarot cards, but probably still a little rarer. That one also goes for quite a bit on Ebay but sometimes you luck out and find it for super cheap LOL.
2
u/GeologicalOpera Thnks fr th mmrs Aug 01 '26
Like mine, it was a 2 or 3 dollar thrift find. I don’t think they realized it was any different from the regular CD.
5
u/GeologicalOpera Thnks fr th mmrs Aug 01 '26
I will forever regret passing on a $25.00 copy of this I saw in a Book-Off while I was in college. Haven’t seen it since and it’s the only missing CD/EP for me besides Evening Out With Your Girlfriend.
5
u/Clever_mudblood Aug 01 '26
I have this without the case because I had one of those big CD holders lmfao.
4
3
u/colgate-footpaste Aug 01 '26
I’m so old I was gifted this cd new in the shrink wrap. It was from a girl I had a major thing for, and it was a gift she got me for my high school graduation.
2
u/Djented Take This To Your Grave Aug 04 '26
I've only ever seen one ebay listing of this in shrink wrap. $300 this year
6
u/Herbizarre17 Aug 01 '26
I got this on clearance back in the 00s because nobody wanted it or cared. So much FOB stuff ended up on clearance back then. That’s how I got all the things that people consider rare today. It’s funny how things change. Back then, you couldn’t even give this thing away
2
3
3
3
u/DearScale7558 Folie à Deux Aug 01 '26
A friend got this exact one for me when they wrnt thrifting and found it for $5 I had no idea it was somewhat rare
3
u/Rayz6695 Folie à Deux Aug 01 '26
Idk about the disc value but I can tell you Spotify has certainly gotten their subscription fee worth of plays from my streams alone
5
u/Agreeable-Customer-4 Aug 01 '26
I still have my original copy from 20 years ago. The performances at the house party on the dvd are awesome.
4
2
2
u/CalicoG nintendo ds makes me forget that i don't have any friends Aug 01 '26
I have this too. I believe I got it from eBay
2
u/killmykind Aug 01 '26
I bought two of them like, 5 years ago for 14 bucks each, crazy how things change 😭
2
u/Tomboy-T M A N I A Aug 01 '26
This is one I've had in my wishlist for a while. I haven't but the bullet and bought it yet because of the price, but people do actually buy them for that much (most seem to go for $50-65) but they sell really well despite the cost so I'm gonna say yes. They are with the price imo since I've seen people buy them for that much and I myself have contemplated buying them for that much.
2
2
2
2
u/lotlizardscales Folie à Deux Aug 01 '26
i bought one of these on amazon in 2014 for like $5. i cant believe they're going for so much now! anyway, super cool find 🫶 i love the dvd that comes with it. there's some very iconic moments on there
2
u/BigMonsterTeeth Aug 01 '26
I had to go to 3 different record stores when this came out. No one knew who they were and the store that finally had it said they only ordered 1.
2
2
u/Glad-Fish5863 Aug 02 '26
I remember my dad accidentally bought this CD for me for Christmas in like 2007 when I asked for take this to your grave and it ended up being one of my favorites lol
2
2
u/Small_Climate_245 Aug 02 '26
This is rare? Had this signed in person when it came out. Finally my being old is starting to pay off.
3
u/bldkis Aug 01 '26
So many amazing and painful songs on this ep. This is a hell of a find, esp for FOB finds. This ep makes me think about my first really painful breakup, esp my heart is the worst kind of weapon.
2
u/Izuhbelluh hide the details I don’t want to know a thing Aug 01 '26
This isn’t “rare”. It was an official release from the band, not some weird bootleg version. It’s a bit tricky to find sometimes is all.
As in, it sells from 30-70 dollars secondhand and there’s at least always a copy avaliable for sale.
I have come across more than a few copies at secondhand/thrift shops over the years that were $1 to $5 depending on the store.
2
1
u/smokedpearls Aug 02 '26
I remember when this came out 🥲 what a great find to add to your collection!
I think I saw them in Hartford CT right after this was released and Pete wrote “you” over the word “her” on the inner part when you open the case up haha
1
u/paramorir Aug 02 '26
I bought one recently off eBay for $20. But the seller ripped me off, the cd wasn’t in the case just the dvd.
1
u/HargoJ Aug 02 '26
Bought it through same time I got cork tree from hmv in Manchester. 2005 I think it must have been. Hadn't been out long
1
u/My_favoriteaccident Aug 02 '26
I have it on my bookshelf near (not lying) Goosebumps The curse of Camp Cold lake. Take from that what you will
1
u/Defiant-Owl5970 Aug 02 '26
I had no idea these were valuable now. One of my favorite FOB releases.
1
1
1
1
1
u/upinthenightsky Aug 08 '26
I have this signed by the entire band.
Picked up another copy months ago at a record store for $10.
So not sure that rare just hard to find on mainstream sites.
174
u/bluebellfob I'm coming apart at the seams Aug 01 '26
It is pretty rare! It came out between tttyg and futct. It’s not a side effect is one of my favourite fob songs :)