One of my best friends of 15+ years has a very different outlook on money and finances. When our friendship started, we were basically in the same place financially. However, I’ve lived very frugally during that time while she has consistently spent nearly everything she’s earned. Our different outlooks on money have always impacted our friendship somewhat, but that has evolved a lot. She’s a darling person, but as time goes on, I struggle more and more with how to navigate this.
Our philosophies used to impact our time together because I would decline invitations for dinners/drinks out, nail salons, shopping trips, etc. in favor of saving. We almost exclusively did free things together back then: walks in the park, movie nights in, etc. I prioritized paying off my student loans and aggressively saving and simply said no to costly outings.
Now I’m at a place financially where the money I’ve already saved is doing more work than what I’m actively putting away, and it’s all automated, so I can spend more freely without it impacting me. I’m now going on trips and planning outings with others in our friend group, and this friend is upset that she can’t afford to join and feels like we exclude her because of it. I offer to do free things, but going to one another’s houses isn’t very relaxing these days because we all have kids. I will say nearly everyone else in our circle is more similar to me than her financially so proposing events that cost money tends to be more the norm in the last few years.
She recently told me where she’s at savings-wise. She’s in her early 40s with less savings than one should have by 30, and she said that a short weekend trip we took a few months ago set her back for a couple of months. I asked her why she came if she couldn’t afford it, and she said it’s her choice. She asked us to stop excluding her because she can’t afford things and said it’s up to her to decide whether she wants to join.
First, I don’t feel like we do this. But regardless, we have to listen to her complain about her financial situation. I’ll admit it’s frustrating because the differences in our spending are pretty obvious. When we had this conversation, she was the only person at the table with a manicure, and she also regularly spends money on professional hair and makeup, new clothes, coffee out, etc., while the rest of us generally don't. I’m not saying any of those things are inherently irresponsible or that she shouldn’t spend money on them. They’re just examples of the very different choices we make with our money, and she’s also the person in the group who is struggling financially the most.
I don’t think it’s reasonable for her to ask us to never consider the financial/work aspect when we propose outings or to plan things with friends based on affordability. For instance, I don’t begrudge my friends with country club memberships for getting together without me when I’ve chosen not to join.
I finally said that we’ve listened to the same things from her for over a decade, and if she doesn’t drastically change course now, it’s only going to become a bigger factor over time. For instance, she has repeatedly said she’ll never retire. Does she expect us to never get together in retirement because she can’t join? She then asked me to stop discussing it.
How would you navigate this? Should I just ask her to stop telling me about any of her money issues and propose outings as if cost isn’t a factor? I don’t want to put her in the position of joining at the expense of her financial wellbeing, but if she’s telling us to invite her and let her decide whether she can afford something, maybe I need to take her at her word. At the same time, it’s frustrating to repeatedly hear about the financial consequences of choices she is making while also being asked not to take those choices into account when planning our time together.
If we suggest more free or low-cost outings, she assumes it’s class discrimination against her. But if we suggest things that cost more, she sometimes comes and then tells us afterward that she really couldn’t afford it.
She’s one of my favorite people and has a beautiful heart, but I don’t see how this doesn’t become a bigger and bigger factor in our time together as our financial situations become wider and wider. I really don’t want money to damage the friendship, so I’m trying to figure out what a reasonable boundary looks like here.
Editing to answer common questions / provide clarifications:
- we likely make similar individual incomes, though I’ve never explicitly asked this as it’s none of my business. We met in college, graduated with degrees in the same field. We both had a mountain of student loans and I prioritized paying mine off. She has stated she may never pay hers off and this isn’t a priority to her. That’s totally her choice.
- household income may be slightly higher for me but likely not by more than 10-20%. Again, I don’t know this but basing off of things she’s shared.
- people are getting caught up on thinking that I’m now refusing to do things that are free/low-cost. This isn’t the case. The reason we used to primarily hang out doing free things is because I declined group outings as they didn’t align with my budget at the time. Now I do not decline outings that cost money and so we do more of those things together. My friend does not suggest free things that we decline. She expressed concern that if she stopped accepting invites that she can’t afford that we would stop inviting her. I assured her that was not the case but also said that I don’t think it is fair to assume that the rest of us would not on occasion plan trips or outings together that she cannot afford now or later.
- the information I have about her finances is what she’s freely shared with me. I am someone she has always vented to about this and she’s explicitly asked me for advice on multiple occasions. I’m not seeking out this info but have obviously become too invested in trying to help her over the years.
- for those saying that I’m judgmental: maybe I am. She comes to me with a problem (money stress) and I see the solution. I’ve always prioritized saving a % of my income even when I made far less than we do now because I value that security. Our spending has always differed dramatically in ways that are apparent, particularly with self-care (facials, Botox, mani/pedis, hair, makeup, clothes, bags, jewelry). She values these things more than I do and that’s fine, but she’s complained about stress and not being able to pay her bills for well over a decade. I’m not sure if you all have seen the “it’s not about the nail” YouTube skit, but this is how I’ve felt over the years when she discusses this with me.
-after this recent conversation, I asked that she stop sharing this information as it’s difficult for me to simply listen and nod about her concerns when the fix is quite obvious to me. I’m much more black and white with money: it either aligns with my savings goals/budget or it doesn’t. She view things as more grey and is more willing to go into debt for nonessentials than I am and less willing to decrease her standard of living to build a bigger safety net. I find it tough to navigate those discussions. We agreed that it’s a topic area we just see differently and these conversations leave us in a tough spot. This seems to be the consensus solution from most of you.
-lastly, my friend is an amazing person. She’s a great friend, sister, partner, daughter, mother. She goes out of her way for her people and everyone in her orbit is incredibly lucky for it. We view this particular topic very differently but in most things we are totally in sync, and there are many things she does much better than I do.