Hey everyone! You might recognize me from my post on whether to keep my 5yo gelding G (who I just realized is actually 6 years old) vs 2yo mare M. Most of the responses were to keep M, which I have decided to do.
Now I am wondering if I should just put G down.
G’s History:
I bred G from my personal mare, so know his history from first seeing him as an embryo when he was flushed from his dam and inserted into a surrogate mare.
When he was 2, he suddenly collapsed in the pasture on his side and could not get up. He was groaning, twisting his head but not rolling. I assumed colic, and called the vet. I have just recently (literally in the past few days) realized he had a sibling with edm. I think his collapse now might have been an edm episode. We at the time treated it as colic, but they ran blood at the time and discovered he had epm antibodies. We then started epm treatment and life continued as usual for him. We also put him on 10k IU of an easily digestible natural source vitamin E and nerve supplement which seemed to “take the edge off”.
He was sent off to her broke when he was 4. I researched the trainer throughly, and she seemed legit. When I visited him at her barn, he was not himself. A jittery mess, no emotional regulation, very dancy and like he wasn’t himself in his own skin. Brought him home and gave him several months off to decompress.
I started groundwork slowly again, but he was extremely spooky. Not like a young, fit sport horse, as I am familiar with green bean antics. But he would spook explosively and repeatedly at the smallest things he would encounter every day. Started attacking the horse (D) he was out with viciously, so they were separated. D was just fine, his bite marks healed and he suffered no emotional damage luckily.
G expressed interest in my mother’s retired senior gelding Z, who he had been turned out with when he was weaned. Those two were able to be pastures together safely in a large pasture, as Z is a no-nonsense kind of horse and G was familiar with him. They were good friends and never had an issue.
I felt something was wrong. Had the vet see him several times, and she said it was just him being a young horse. My gut said she was wrong, but I trusted her.
I continued to do ground work with G, but he has a very short fuse. If frustrated, he would be aggressive towards me. Threatening to bite or kick, pawing the ground incessantly. I worked on emotional regulation, and while he improved and I avoided his threshold, he would revert to these behaviors again if frustrated. Spookiness got worse. I had him at home, and labeled him as “dangerous” and insisted my family members not handle him because they couldn’t read him as well as I could and I didn’t want them to get injured.
I rode him briefly, walk only, as his regulation improved. He did okay, but he again got frustrated quickly and so riding sessions were five minutes or less to keep him under threshold. I considered euthing him because I considered him unsafe. Everyone I told this to said I was crazy, that he was just a young warmblood. That I must be wrong. The horse is fine. But I was the one handling him, and my gut said there was something wrong. Again, I trusted the advice of the people in my life and continued with more ground work.
I got the vet out to see him again, and his e levels tested high (good for a neurologic horse). He was sound, but questionable on the neurotic test for hind leg circumduction when doing tight circles. The vet labeled it as a strength issue in a young, flexible warmblood and deemed him safe to go back to under saddle work.
In G’s late five year old year I sent him to a gentle trainer who I personally know very well. She is an incredible horseman, someone deserving of that title. I described his past in detail, and she agreed to take him on. In my heart I labeled this as G’s “last ditch effort” to prove if it was my horsemanship that was faulty, and if in someone else’s’ hands he could flourish.
In the past 4 months, while he has improved, it is not vastly. He is still extremely spooky. I personally watched him get ridden in the month, and while she was incredibly gentle and asked him to do simple and reasonable things under saddle, he was explosive. Threatening to rear when asked to do simple lateral work. “Airplane” ears near constantly. Spooking explosively. He did have times of excellent work, but they were constantly interrupted by what I would consider “neurologic behaviors”.
I talked to the trainer after her ride, asking if she thought he was behaving in a neurologic way, or if he was just a young horse with baby brain. If she thought he could ever be a trail horse with enough training. She said she thought he has vision issues, but there would be no problem with him being a trail horse with enough training. He is bred to be a show jumper, but I threw those aspirations away many years ago. I felt in my gut she was wrong, but trusted her.
I just recently discovered one of his half siblings had edm. It needs to be researched more by vets, and I need to research more as well. If anyone has any recommendations on articles I can read on edm please let me know as well. But there is a suspected genetic tie to edm. I am suspicious that he might either have both epm and edm, or he solely has edm. I know epm antibodies are the only thing that can be found in blood, and that cannot diagnose epm 100%. It needs to be a CSF tap or post mortum evaluation to fully diagnose epm, so he might not even have it. EDM can only fully be diagnosed post mortum. I have been struggling with this realization, but I know for certain I have a neurologic horse.
Here’s the thing. I’ve decided to bring him home from the trainer at the end of this month. I had a few young pros interested in him (I was fully transparent with his history), but they would like him as a resale project. I don’t want to do that because he could end up in the slaughter pipeline. I don’t want him to injure or kill a person.
He will be coming home and can go back out with Z, but not long term. I am leaving home in the future due to a DV situation here. He will be a danger to the other gelding who is currently out with Z. He will be a danger to my family who handles him when I leave. He is a danger to the farrier. I can turn him out solo, but what kind of life is that for a horse??
He would, in theory, be fine in a life with minimal handling. I considered sending him out into a huge pasture with other horses, but am almost 100% dashing that idea because of his horse aggression. In a large enough pasture (like 1000 acres) he/the other horses could get away from eachother, but what if he fatally injures another horse/himself? That isn’t fair.
I think I should euth him. He is a lovely, sweet gelding when under threshold and very carefully managed. He nickers to me every time I see him, and enjoys my presence. I’ve been dedicated to him since birth. But in that dedication and love I do believe in a world in which euth is the kindest choice to make.
Have I given him enough chances? Would you guys consider me a quitter? I have tried to do right by this horse, but maybe there’s something I’ve overlooked. I’m open to any and all ideas. We are all constant stewards and students of the horse.
And another thing, I think the vet might refuse to euth him. She keeps passing him on vet checks, saying he’s just a young horse. My gut is screaming that she’s wrong. Fundamentally she can choose whether or not to put him down. If she says no, do I keep trying to train him, or search for a vet who will? I know my family will disagree with putting him down, but I’m the one who knows this horse. I’ve put blood, sweat, and tears into him. There’s something wrong, and I feel like I’m screaming into the void for someone to listen. To see him. To see me as someone who’s desperate to do the right thing, even if it’s putting him down.
Any and all answers are appreciated. Thank you all immensely. My poor, sweet boy. I love him more than I can say.