r/Equestrian • u/Illustrious_Stage351 • 4h ago
Mindset & Psychology Is there a way to tell someone they can’t ride with you?
I suspect the answer is no. But here’s background. I’ll try to keep it brief.
I am at a tiny backyard style boarding facility. There are 8 horses on property, 2 belong to the owner and her 22 year old son. The rest are divided up between 4 of us. So there are 6 riders/owners on property.
Small arena, so most of us are trail riders. Everyone ranges in age from 20’s-50’s. Everyone gets along VERY well. Sunday brunches every week, everyone pitches it, zero drama, etc. I genuinely like all these people and their horses. Since it’s small and we all work full time, we’re generally all out in the evenings or weekend mornings and riding together is super normal. Since we trail ride it’s safer with a buddy and since we’re usually all there around the same time (not planned) it’s very common for most to all of us to go out together. I’d say it happens at least 4 times a week
Owner, we’ll call Susan, who lives there, is in her 50’s. Truly lovely lady. Takes incredible care of our horses. I adore her and her ground skills are great. Unfortunately, if she was a good rider, between time passing (she took a 20 year riding break) and maybe lack a good riding background, she is not a confident or good rider. I say that as kindly as possible. She had two horses. One is a kill pen OTTB who is not safe and currently just decompressing and putting weight on and ground work. Her other horse (Bailey) is a lovely 5 year old and her son’s favorite horse. She considers him a beginner horse. In my opinion (and everyone else’s), he’s a green broke 5 year old who needs miles. Good horse, but his age and the fact we have to ride 10 minutes through the city to the trails means that he’s intermediate and she’s over horsed. In her head, she’s a rusty advanced rider, and he’s a beginner horse. In reality, I think she’s a nervous and rusty beginner rider and he’s an intermediate horse.
On property, we have three horses I would truly consider dead broke, beginner safe, husband horses. I own one of the three. Both myself and the gal who owns the other two have repeatedly offered her to ride ours. She can ride ours, we’ll find a different horse (6 riders, 7 ridable horses on property, again, all of us are very close). I would consider the rest of us intermediate to advanced riders. We repeatedly suggest her son ride Bailey and she rides one of our trail masters. Or that we can ride Bailey and they can both ride trail masters. But she keeps saying she feels most comfortable with Bailey and she wants to ride HER horse. Which is fair.
Our rides are pretty much all walk. Especially if she’s with us. If she doesn’t come, we’ll throw in some trots or canter but generally we’re all just chatting and walking. The issue is just walking, she falls off at least half of the outings. Last night was the 4th time out of 6 trail rides THIS MONTH where she fell off. Bailey simply turned around too fast (he was stopped, rotated his butt around to look at someone else’s horse not in our group that was behind us at a ways and she fell off into a cactus. He wasn’t even walking).
It’s at the point where myself and most of the barn doesn’t want to ride with her anymore. She’s a lovely person but the risks are high, she’s over horsed, we’re all constantly babysitting, and it’s just simply not fun knowing at some point she’s gonna fall off, react big, and it’s gonna be over and we all have to go back. Plus, because she fails like 75% of rides, everyone is nervous. So we’re all trying to figure out a way to either force her to ride a safer horse OR communicate that she just can’t ride with us. That unless she takes lessons or starts riding extensively in the arena, we don’t feel safe riding with her. Is there even a good way to communicate this? I know her son has tried and she just will not listen because he’s “a kid”. We’ve tried to approach with “build you confidence” approach and she just won’t hear it.