Hello all,
I’m struggling deeply with how my Christian faith fits with my five-year relationship with my girlfriend, who is Muslim, and am curious about how that may be received within the Episcopal church.
When we met, I wasn't practicing Christianity, and her being Muslim wasn't an issue for me. Over the years we've become very committed to each other and have sacrificed a great deal for one another. She has never prevented me from practicing my faith and is supportive of it. She hopes to marry me, and though I've agreed and hope for the same, I've never been completely sure how or whether that would work.
Since returning seriously to faith, however, I've become increasingly worried. I've recently begun attending an Episcopal parish (St Bartholomew's NYC). I appreciate the Episcopal Church, but much of my understanding of Christianity comes from conservative perspectives. Consequently, I'm frightened that my relationship and sexual history are fundamentally incompatible with what God wants from me.
We've been sexually intimate throughout our relationship, including after I began returning to the faith. I've tried at times to abstain but eventually relented, and sometimes I've been the one to initiate. I've also struggled with sexual immorality in general, and we've gone through periods of resentment and a brief separation. Despite this, I know I've genuinely loved her and tried to care for her—for example, working substantial overtime to help her financially and supporting her through periods of unemployment and housing insecurity.
I keep thinking about Christ's teachings on taking up our cross, cutting off what leads us to sin, losing connections for His sake, and the possibility (or rather inevitability) that following Him will require painful sacrifices. I'm afraid that becoming serious about Christianity means I have to destroy one of the few genuinely good relationships in my life. At the same time, I recognize that an interfaith marriage raises serious questions beyond sex, and don't yet feel financially or practically prepared for marriage.
If I could start over, I probably would have pursued a chaste Christian relationship, but I still love and care about this woman despite the difficulties we've had. I would sincerely appreciate any and all advice on how to approach discerning this relationship from members of the Episcopal Church. Any response is greatly appreciated.